Optimal Adaptive Matrix Completion

Ilqar Ramazanli, Barnabás PóczosarXiv 2020 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "sparsity-number" parameter to analyze and improve adaptive matrix completion algorithms. The authors propose new algorithms that can recover low-rank matrices with significantly fewer observations, especially for matrices with coherent column or row spaces, outperforming existing state-of-the-art methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Matrix completion, the task of filling in missing entries in a matrix, is crucial for many real-world applications like recommender systems, signal processing, and gene expression analysis. When the matrix is known to be low-rank, we can often recover it from a limited number of observed entries. Adaptive sampling methods, which intelligently choose which entries to observe, have shown promise in reducing the number of required observations compared to passive sampling. However, existing adaptive methods often struggle with matrices where the column or row spaces are "coherent" (meaning they are not spread out evenly across the standard basis vectors), sometimes requiring observation of almost the entire matrix. This paper tackles the challenge of developing adaptive matrix completion algorithms that are more efficient, particularly for these challenging coherent cases, and require minimal prior information about the matrix.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the introduction of the "sparsity-number" (denoted by $\psi$) for vectors, matrices, and subspaces. This parameter quantifies how "spread out" a vector or subspace is with respect to the standard basis. The authors establish a crucial link between this sparsity-number and the problem of exact matrix completion.

Based on this new parameter, they propose two main algorithms:

  1. ERR (Exact Recovery for rank r matrices): This algorithm aims to recover a rank-$r$ matrix with minimal prior information, only requiring the rank itself. It works by finding linearly independent rows and columns and using them to reconstruct the rest of the matrix. The key insight is that the sparsity-number of the column and row spaces directly informs the observation complexity.
  2. ERRE (Exact Recovery while Rank Estimation): This algorithm is designed for scenarios where the rank of the matrix is unknown. It adaptively estimates the rank while performing matrix completion, making it more robust when prior knowledge is limited.

The theoretical analysis leverages this sparsity-number to derive new, tighter bounds on the number of observations required for exact recovery, especially in cases of high coherence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments are conducted on synthetically generated low-rank matrices with varying degrees of row and column space coherence.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sparsity-Number as a Key Parameter: The paper introduces a new parameter, the "sparsity-number," which provides a more nuanced way to analyze matrix completion problems than traditional coherence measures, especially for adaptive sampling.
  • Bridging Sparsity and Coherence: The authors demonstrate a direct relationship between the sparsity-number of a subspace and its coherence, allowing them to leverage the sparsity-number for theoretical analysis and algorithm design.
  • Improved Performance for Coherent Matrices: The proposed algorithms, particularly ERR, show significant improvements in observation complexity for matrices with highly coherent column or row spaces, a known weakness of previous methods.
  • Minimal Prior Information: The ERR algorithm requires only the rank of the matrix, making it applicable in a wider range of scenarios compared to methods that need estimates of coherence.
  • Rank Estimation Capability: The ERRE algorithm offers a practical solution for cases where the rank is not known beforehand, by adaptively estimating it during the completion process.

Key Results

  • The proposed algorithms achieve exact matrix recovery with significantly fewer observations than state-of-the-art methods, especially for matrices with coherent column spaces.
  • For $\mu_0$-coherent column space matrices, the algorithms achieve recovery with probability at least $1-\epsilon$ using observation complexity $\mathcal{O}(\psi(U) r \log(r/\epsilon))$, which is substantially better than previous bounds like $\mathcal{O}(\mu_0 rn \log(r/\epsilon))$.
  • The ERR algorithm requires only the rank $r$ as input and achieves observation complexity bounded by $\mathcal{O}((m+n-r)r + \frac{mn}{\psi(U)}\log(r/\epsilon))$.
  • The ERRE algorithm, which estimates rank, achieves recovery with probability $1-\epsilon$ and an observation complexity that is also improved, particularly when row or column spaces are incoherent.
  • Experimental results on synthetic data demonstrate the superiority of the proposed algorithms across various coherence scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical vs. Practical: While the algorithms are theoretically sound, their practical implementation might involve challenges in precisely computing or estimating the sparsity-number, especially for very large matrices.
  • Noise Robustness: The current work focuses on exact matrix completion. The authors mention that future work will extend these algorithms to be robust for different types of noises, which is crucial for real-world applications.
  • Heterogeneous Observation Costs: The paper briefly mentions an extension to scenarios with heterogeneous observation costs, suggesting this as a direction for future research.
  • Generalization to Tensors: The paper's focus is on matrices, but the concepts might be generalizable to higher-order tensors, which is another avenue for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the problem of exact completion for $m \times n$ sized matrix of rank $r$ with the adaptive sampling method. We introduce a relation of the exact completion problem with the sparsest vector of column and row spaces (which we call \textit{sparsity-number} here). Using this relation, we propose matrix completion algorithms that exactly recovers the target matrix. These algorithms are superior to previous works in two important ways. First, our algorithms exactly recovers $\mu_0$-coherent column space matrices by probability at least $1 - \epsilon$ using much smaller observations complexity than $\mathcal{O}(\mu_0 rn \mathrm{log}\frac{r}{\epsilon})$ the state of art. Specifically, many of the previous adaptive sampling methods require to observe the entire matrix when the column space is highly coherent. However, we show that our method is still able to recover this type of matrices by observing a small fraction of entries under many scenarios. Second, we propose an exact completion algorithm, which requires minimal pre-information as either row or column space is not being highly coherent. At the end of the paper, we provide experimental results that illustrate the strength of the algorithms proposed here.
BibTeX
@misc{ramazanli2020optimal,
  author = {Ilqar Ramazanli and Barnabás Póczos},
  title = {{Optimal Adaptive Matrix Completion}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2002.02431},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2002.02431},
}
Figure