Optical response of edge modes in time-reversal symmetric topological superconductors

Hirokazu Kobayashi, Han Bi, James Jun He, Seishiro OnoarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Topological superconductors and Majorana edge modes at their boundaries have been theoretically predicted. However, their experimental observation remains controversial. Recent theoretical studies suggest that chiral Majorana edge modes exhibit distinct spatially-resolved optical conductivity compared to chiral Dirac edge modes. In this work, we investigate the optical conductivity and spatially-resolved optical conductivity induced by Majorana edge modes and Dirac edge modes under time-reversal symmetry and crystalline symmetry. We conduct numerical calculations and analytical calculations with edge effective theory for two-dimensional ${\mathbb Z}_2$ topological insulators, strong topological superconductors, and topological crystalline superconductors. Our results show that even under time-reversal symmetry and crystalline symmetry, Majorana edge modes and Dirac edge modes exhibit different optical responses.

Introduction

The search for Majorana fermions—particles that are their own antiparticles—is a central pursuit in modern condensed matter physics. Predicted to exist as edge modes at the boundaries of topological superconductors (TSCs), these particles are notoriously difficult to detect. Conventional methods, such as identifying zero-bias peaks in electrical conductance, are often ambiguous as other physical effects can produce similar signals.

A critical challenge lies in distinguishing Majorana edge modes from the Dirac edge modes found in topological insulators (TIs). While previous research highlighted unique optical signatures for chiral Majorana modes, many promising materials possess time-reversal symmetry (TRS) or crystalline symmetries that complicate the identification. This study investigates whether spatially-resolved optical conductivity can serve as a definitive "smoking gun" for Majorana modes in these symmetric systems.

Methodology

To address this, we employed a hybrid approach combining numerical simulations and analytical modeling:

  1. Numerical Simulations: We utilized the recursive Green’s function method to model 2D lattices of ${\mathbb Z}_2$ topological insulators, strong TSCs, and topological crystalline superconductors (TCSCs). This allowed us to calculate the spatially-resolved optical conductivity, measuring the system's response to light applied to specific regions, such as the edge.
  2. Analytical Edge Theory: We derived low-energy effective models for the edges and applied symmetry analysis using Effective Altland-Zirnbauer (EAZ) classes. This helped determine which optical transitions are physically allowed or forbidden.
  3. Symmetry Classification: Systems were categorized by how their edge states transform under time-reversal and crystalline symmetries to predict low-energy light absorption characteristics.

Results and Discussion

The "Helical Silence" of Topological Insulators

In ${\mathbb Z}_2$ topological insulators, symmetry forbids optical excitations between edge states at the same momentum. Consequently, the spatially-resolved optical conductivity remains constant and independent of frequency ($\omega$) at low energies. This "helical silence" results in a flat spectral response, as shown in the numerical results for TI models.

Optical conductivity of a ${\mathbb Z}_2$ topological insulator. The inset in (c) demonstrates the flat, frequency-independent response of Dirac edge modes at low energies, characteristic of the "helical silence."

The Majorana Frequency Fingerprint

In contrast to insulators, topological superconductors exhibit a strong frequency dependence in their optical response. Even when specific transitions are forbidden at zero momentum transfer ($q=0$), the overall spatially-resolved signal varies significantly with $\omega$.

In topological crystalline superconductors, such as those in the p11a group, the presence of multiple edge bands enables interband optical excitations that are strictly forbidden in simpler models. This makes them significantly easier to detect optically. Our results show that by combining symmetries like mirror and time-reversal, one can diagnose the type of edge mode based on its low-frequency absorption profile.

Optical response of topological crystalline superconductors. These systems exhibit a distinct frequency-dependent fingerprint in their spatially-resolved conductivity, providing a clear experimental signature for Majorana edge modes.

Conclusion

Our findings demonstrate that Majorana edge modes in topological superconductors leave a distinct frequency-dependent fingerprint in spatially-resolved optical conductivity, distinguishing them from Dirac edge modes in topological insulators even under high degrees of symmetry. While idealized linear dispersions were assumed, future work will involve convolving these theoretical results with experimental parameters like laser spot size to facilitate direct comparison with laboratory measurements. This optical approach offers a promising new pathway for the unambiguous detection of Majorana fermions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Topological superconductors and Majorana edge modes at their boundaries have been theoretically predicted. However, their experimental observation remains controversial. Recent theoretical studies suggest that chiral Majorana edge modes exhibit distinct spatially-resolved optical conductivity compared to chiral Dirac edge modes. In this work, we investigate the optical conductivity and spatially-resolved optical conductivity induced by Majorana edge modes and Dirac edge modes under time-reversal symmetry and crystalline symmetry. We conduct numerical calculations and analytical calculations with edge effective theory for two-dimensional ${\mathbb Z}_2$ topological insulators, strong topological superconductors, and topological crystalline superconductors. Our results show that even under time-reversal symmetry and crystalline symmetry, Majorana edge modes and Dirac edge modes exhibit different optical responses.
BibTeX
@misc{kobayashi2024optical,
  author = {Hirokazu Kobayashi and Han Bi and James Jun He and Seishiro Ono},
  title = {{Optical response of edge modes in time-reversal symmetric topological superconductors}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2411.09985},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.09985},
}
Figure