Optical Recording of Fast Neuronal Membrane Potential Transients in Acute Mammalian Brain Slices by Second-Harmonic Generation Microscopy

Daniel A. Dombeck, Leonardo Sacconi, Mireille Blanchard‐Desce, Watt W. WebbJournal of Neurophysiology 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel optical method using Second-Harmonic Generation (SHG) microscopy to record fast neuronal membrane potential changes deep within intact mammalian brain slices. By employing the FM4-64 dye, the researchers achieved high-contrast imaging of neuronal membranes, enabling the optical recording of action potentials and voltage steps at depths previously inaccessible to optical techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the electrical activity of neurons is fundamental to neuroscience. Traditional methods like microelectrodes are limited to recording from a few points, hindering the study of complex neural networks. Optical methods offer the potential for multi-site recordings, but existing techniques face significant challenges when applied to deep tissue:

  • Light Scattering: In thick biological samples like brain slices, light scattering severely limits the depth at which optical signals can be reliably detected. One-photon fluorescence methods are typically restricted to depths less than 50 µm.
  • Background Noise: For fluorescence-based methods, signals from dye molecules not precisely located on the plasma membrane (background) can obscure the true membrane potential signal, making quantification difficult.
  • Spatial Resolution: Recording from fine neuronal processes like dendrites and spines requires high spatial resolution, which is challenging to achieve at depth.

The authors aimed to overcome these limitations by combining the advantages of nonlinear microscopy (optical sectioning and depth penetration) with sensitive membrane potential indicators.

Methods

The core of this work is the application of Second-Harmonic Generation (SHG) microscopy for voltage imaging. Here's a breakdown of the key techniques:

  • SHG Microscopy: This nonlinear optical technique uses a pulsed laser (1064 nm in this study) to excite a fluorescent dye. When the dye molecules are arranged in a specific, non-centrosymmetric way (like within a membrane), they can emit light at exactly half the excitation wavelength (532 nm for SHG). This process is highly sensitive to the local molecular environment.
  • FM4-64 Dye: This lipophilic dye was used to label neuronal membranes. Crucially, it was introduced intracellularly via patch-clamp pipettes, allowing for precise labeling of the plasma membrane.
  • Intracellular Filling: Unlike previous SHG studies that often relied on extracellular dye application, this work demonstrated successful intracellular filling of neurons in acute brain slices. This is a significant advancement for studying intact tissue.
  • Line Scanning: To capture fast voltage transients (milliseconds), the microscope used a line-scanning approach. This involves rapidly scanning the laser across a single line on the neuron and collecting the emitted SHG signal over time. Averaging multiple line scans improves the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N).
  • Patch-Clamp Electrophysiology: This standard technique was used to simultaneously record electrical membrane potential and control voltage steps, allowing for direct comparison with the optical SHG signal and calibration of the dye's voltage sensitivity.
  • Comparison with Two-Photon Fluorescence (TPF): The researchers directly compared their SHG method with TPF, another nonlinear microscopy technique, using various voltage-sensitive dyes. This comparison was crucial for validating the superiority of SHG in this application.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses acute mammalian brain slices from rats as the biological sample.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SHG's Intrinsic Membrane Contrast: SHG generation requires specific molecular alignment. This inherent property means SHG signals primarily arise from dye molecules precisely oriented within the plasma membrane, leading to exceptionally high membrane contrast and minimal background signal from intracellular or extracellular sources. This is a major advantage over TPF.
  • Intracellular Labeling is Key for Brain Slices: Successfully loading FM4-64 intracellularly allowed for deep penetration and high-contrast SHG imaging, overcoming the limitations of extracellular labeling in thick tissue.
  • FM4-64 as a Superior SHG Probe: Among the tested dyes, FM4-64 demonstrated the best combination of SHG signal strength, membrane loading, and stability in brain slices, making it the preferred probe for this application.
  • SHG's Robustness to Background: Unlike TPF, where background fluorescence can significantly degrade signal quantification, SHG's high membrane contrast allows for a more direct and reliable relationship between the optical signal change and the actual membrane potential change (ΔVm).
  • Depth Penetration: The SHG technique, combined with FM4-64, enabled optical recording of neuronal activity at depths greater than 125 µm below the slice surface, far exceeding the capabilities of previous optical methods.

Key Results

  • High Contrast Imaging: SHG imaging of FM4-64-filled neurons in brain slices achieved a membrane-to-intracellular signal ratio of >125 µm, with high contrast even at depths >125 µm.
  • Linear Voltage Response: The SHG signal showed a linear response to changes in membrane potential (ΔVm) with a sensitivity of approximately 7.5%/100 mV.
  • Action Potential Recording: The researchers successfully recorded action potentials (APs) optically with a signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of approximately 7–8 by averaging about 50 line scans.
  • Dendritic Voltage Step Recording: Fast voltage steps were recorded from dendritic arbors at depths inaccessible to prior optical methods.
  • SHG Superiority over TPF in Slices: Direct comparison showed that SHG with FM4-64 provided a superior S/N for Vm recording in brain slices compared to TPF with various probes, primarily due to SHG's low background and high membrane contrast.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Photodamage: While photodamage was observed at higher laser intensities, the researchers found that reducing laser power and increasing the time between line scans helped mitigate this issue. Further studies are underway to characterize and reduce photodamage, potentially using antioxidants.
  • S/N Limitations: The current S/N is limited by photodamage and the number of collected photons. Future work aims to increase S/N by improving dye molecules (higher sensitivity and effective cross-section) and detector technology.
  • Single-Trial Recording: Achieving single-trial recording of fast Vm events would require a significant increase in S/N, which could be facilitated by improved photodamage mitigation and higher photon collection.
  • Backward-Directed SHG: The paper notes a backward-propagating SHG signal, which could be beneficial for in vivo applications due to potentially longer scattering lengths.
  • Future Applications: The authors envision this technique being used for detailed studies of Vm dynamics in dendritic spines and fine dendrites, as well as for large-scale, high-resolution recordings of population activity deep within brain tissue, potentially combined with other functional indicators.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although nonlinear microscopy and fast (approximately 1 ms) membrane potential (Vm) recording have proven valuable for neuroscience applications, their potentially powerful combination has not yet been shown for studies of Vm activity deep in intact tissue. We show that laser illumination of neurons in acute rat brain slices intracellularly filled with FM4-64 dye generates an intense second-harmonic generation (SHG) signal from somatic and dendritic plasma membranes with high contrast >125 microm below the slice surface. The SHG signal provides a linear response to DeltaVm of approximately 7.5%/100 mV. By averaging repeated line scans (approximately 50), we show the ability to record action potentials (APs) optically with a signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of approximately 7-8. We also show recording of fast Vm steps from the dendritic arbor at depths inaccessible with previous methods. The high membrane contrast and linear response of SHG to DeltaVm provides the advantage that signal changes are not degraded by background and can be directly quantified in terms of DeltaVm. Experimental comparison of SHG and two-photon fluorescence Vm recording with the best known probes for each showed that the SHG technique is superior for Vm recording in brain slice applications, with FM4-64 as the best tested SHG Vm probe.
BibTeX
@article{dombeck2005optical,
  author = {Daniel A. Dombeck and Leonardo Sacconi and Mireille Blanchard‐Desce and Watt W. Webb},
  title = {{Optical Recording of Fast Neuronal Membrane Potential Transients in Acute Mammalian Brain Slices by Second-Harmonic Generation Microscopy}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00416.2005},
}
Figure