Optical property measurements of lithium chloride aqueous solution for a novel solar neutrino experiment

Y. T. Liang, Tong Xu, Jialiang Zhang, Shuo Li, Ming Qi, Zhe WangJournal of Instrumentation 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a highly transparent and long-attenuation-length lithium chloride (LiCl) aqueous solution, a promising medium for next-generation solar neutrino detectors. By purifying the LiCl solution and adding a wavelength shifter, they've demonstrated its potential to enhance light yield and improve detector performance for MeV-scale solar neutrinos.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting solar neutrinos, particularly those in the MeV energy range, is crucial for understanding neutrino oscillations and the solar model. Current detectors often rely on large volumes of water or liquid scintillators. However, for a specific type of neutrino interaction involving the 7Li nucleus (ve + 7Li → e⁻ + 7Be), a lithium-rich medium is desirable due to the high interaction cross-section. Lithium chloride (LiCl) is an attractive candidate because it's cost-effective, neutral, non-toxic, and highly soluble in water, allowing for concentrated solutions. The main challenge with previous attempts at LiCl-based detectors was poor optical transparency, especially in the ultraviolet (UV) range, which hinders the detection of Cherenkov light. This paper addresses this by investigating and optimizing the optical properties of saturated LiCl solutions for use in a novel solar neutrino detector.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-step purification process for the LiCl solution. This involved:

  • Microfiltration: To remove insoluble and colloidal impurities.
  • Adsorption with Powdered Activated Carbon (PAC): To remove impurities that affect UV transparency.
  • Recrystallization: A process of dissolving and re-crystallizing the LiCl to further enhance purity and transparency.

To measure the optical properties, they used:

  • UV-Vis Spectrophotometry: To determine the absorption spectrum of the purified LiCl solution across various wavelengths.
  • Tubular System for Attenuation Length Measurement: A custom-built apparatus, adapted from existing liquid scintillator detector designs, was used to measure how far light travels through the LiCl solution before being significantly absorbed. This involved shining monochromatic light (430 nm) through varying lengths of the solution and measuring the transmitted intensity with a photomultiplier tube (PMT).

To evaluate the Cherenkov light yield, they utilized a cosmic ray muon telescope. This setup uses plastic scintillators to trigger on muons passing through an acrylic tank filled with the LiCl solution. The Cherenkov light produced by the muons is detected by PMTs placed at the top and bottom of the tank. They also investigated the effect of adding a wavelength shifter, Carbostyril 124 (C-124), to the LiCl solution to enhance light detection.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involved measurements of the LiCl solution itself and comparisons with pure water.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LiCl as a Viable Detector Medium: The study confirms that a purified saturated LiCl solution can indeed serve as a Cherenkov detector medium, overcoming previous transparency issues.
  • Purification is Key: The multi-step purification process (filtration, PAC adsorption, and recrystallization) is critical for achieving the necessary optical transparency, bringing the absorption spectrum close to that of pure water in the PMT-sensitive range.
  • Wavelength Shifting Enhances Performance: Adding a small amount of Carbostyril 124 (C-124) significantly enhances the light yield by converting short-wavelength Cherenkov light into longer wavelengths that are more efficiently detected by PMTs. This is crucial for large detectors where short-wavelength light is quickly absorbed.
  • Improved Resolution Potential: The combination of LiCl and a wavelength shifter is proposed to offer better energy and vertex resolution compared to pure water detectors, in addition to providing directional information.

Key Results

  • Absorption Spectrum: After purification, the saturated LiCl solution exhibits minimal absorption in the 400-550 nm range, matching the sensitive region of bialkali PMTs.
  • Attenuation Length: The purified LiCl solution achieved an impressive attenuation length of 50.1 ± 3.6 meters at 430 nm, significantly better than what was previously thought possible for LiCl solutions.
  • Cherenkov Light Yield:
    • Pure water yielded 0.76±0.08 PEs at the top PMT and 15.8±1.5 PEs at the bottom PMT per muon event.
  • Saturated LiCl solution showed a slightly lower top PMT signal (0.54±0.08 PEs) but a comparable bottom PMT signal (17.2±1.5 PEs), indicating minimal hindrance to Cherenkov light propagation.
  • With 1 ppm of C-124 added, the top PMT signal increased to 3.7±0.4 PEs, and the bottom PMT signal remained high at 16.0±1.6 PEs, demonstrating the effectiveness of the wavelength shifter.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper acknowledges that while the LiCl solution with C-124 shows promise, the top PMT signal is still lower than that of pure water. The "minor reflection" seen on the top PMT also suggests room for further optimization. The solubility of C-124, while sufficient at 1 ppm, might be a consideration for higher concentrations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this LiCl solution with a wavelength shifter can be used as a "Cherenkov-enhanced detection medium." This implies further development and integration into a full detector design, leveraging the improved direction resolution and better energy/vertex resolution capabilities. The potential for a large-scale, water-based, Cherenkov-enhanced lithium-rich detector is highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The lithium chloride aqueous solution has great potential to be the detection medium of a novel solar neutrino detector. The nuclide 7 Li provides a charged-current interaction channel with a high cross-section for the MeV-scale solar electron-neutrinos, enabling measurement of the solar neutrino spectrum. This work measures the optical properties and the light yields of a saturated lithium chloride solution. After adsorption with activated carbon and recrystallization, the solution shows little absorption in the sensitive wavelength range of the bialkali photomultipliers. The attenuation length is evaluated to reach 50 meters at 430 nm. In addition to being a pure Cherenkov detector medium, a wavelength shifter, carbostyril 124, is added to the LiCl aqueous solution. The compatibility and the enhancement of the light yield are confirmed, enabling the development of a water-based Cherenkov-enhanced lithium-rich detector.
BibTeX
@article{liang2023optical,
  author = {Y. T. Liang and Tong Xu and Jialiang Zhang and Shuo Li and Ming Qi and Zhe Wang},
  title = {{Optical property measurements of lithium chloride aqueous solution for a novel solar neutrino experiment}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/18/07/p07039},
}
Figure