TL;DR
This paper presents extensive optical observations of the Type Ic supernova SN 2007gr, revealing it to be a "normal" SN Ic with unusually narrow spectral lines and a possible early signature of helium. These characteristics, combined with progenitor analysis, suggest SN 2007gr resulted from a less energetic explosion of a smaller-mass star in a binary system, potentially with an aspherical ejecta distribution.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Supernovae (SNe) are crucial cosmic events that mark the end of massive stars' lives and are key to understanding stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis. Type Ic supernovae (SNe Ic) are particularly interesting because their progenitors have lost their hydrogen and helium envelopes before exploding, making them challenging to identify and study. While broad-lined SNe Ic (BL SNe Ic) have been linked to gamma-ray bursts, "normal" or narrow-lined SNe Ic (NL SNe Ic) are less understood. This paper aims to characterize SN 2007gr, a normal SN Ic, to better understand the diversity of stripped-envelope supernovae and constrain the properties of their progenitors, which are notoriously difficult to detect.
Methods
The authors employed a comprehensive observational strategy, collecting a large dataset of optical photometry (UBVRI bands) and spectroscopy over an extended period, from about a week before maximum light to over a year after.
- Photometry: Ground-based telescopes (KAIT, Nickel, TNT) provided the bulk of the data, with late-time observations from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) WFPC2. Standard data reduction techniques were used, including bias subtraction, flat-fielding, and cosmic ray removal. S-corrections were applied to account for instrumental differences.
- Spectroscopy: Low-resolution optical spectra were obtained using the Kast spectrograph at Lick Observatory and the LRIS spectrograph on the Keck-I telescope. These spectra were reduced using standard IRAF and IDL routines.
- Spectral Modeling: The SYNOW code was used to model early-time spectra, allowing for the identification of spectral lines and the estimation of photospheric velocity and temperature.
- Progenitor Analysis: Pre- and post-explosion HST images were used to pinpoint the supernova's location and analyze the surrounding environment, including nearby star clusters. Spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting was performed on a nearby bright source to constrain its nature (single star vs. star cluster).
Datasets
- SN 2007gr: Extensive optical photometric and spectroscopic data spanning from t ≈ -8 days to t ≈ +430 days relative to B-band maximum.
- Comparison Supernovae: Photometric and spectroscopic data from previously studied SNe Ib/c (SN 1994I, SN 2002ap, SN 2004aw, SN 2008D) and a Type Ia supernova (SN 2005cf) were used for comparison.
- HST Images: Pre- and post-explosion images of the SN 2007gr site in NGC 1058 from the WFPC2 instrument.
- Stellar Libraries: The Pickles (1998) stellar spectral flux library and starburst99 code were used for SED fitting of potential progenitor environments.
Key Insights and Ideas
- SN 2007gr as a "Transitional" SN Ic: The detection of a possible early helium signature (He I λ5876) alongside prominent carbon lines suggests SN 2007gr might bridge the gap between SNe Ib (helium-rich) and SNe Ic (helium-poor), indicating a progenitor that lost its hydrogen but retained a small amount of helium.
- Less Energetic Explosion: The unusually narrow spectral lines and lower expansion velocities compared to SN 2002ap point towards a less energetic explosion for SN 2007gr, likely from a smaller-mass progenitor.
- Aspherical Ejecta: The asymmetric double-peaked profiles observed in nebular emission lines ([O I], Mg I]) strongly suggest an aspherical explosion, with ejecta distributed in a torus or disk-like geometry. The differing distributions of oxygen and magnesium within this geometry are also inferred.
- Progenitor in a Binary System: Analysis of pre-explosion HST images points to SN 2007gr originating from a low-mass star (8-9 M☉) within a star cluster, which, combined with the observed properties, favors a Wolf-Rayet star in a close binary system as the progenitor.
Key Results
- Light and Color Curves: SN 2007gr's light and color curves are similar to those of SN 2002ap but show differences in late-time evolution compared to other SNe Ib/c and SNe Ia.
- Spectral Characteristics: SN 2007gr exhibits narrow spectral lines, prominent carbon lines, and a slow evolution of line velocity. A possible He I λ5876 absorption feature was detected at t = -8 days.
- 56Ni Mass: The estimated mass of 56Ni synthesized during the explosion is 0.061 ± 0.014 M☉.
- Progenitor Environment: Pre-explosion HST images suggest the progenitor was likely part of a star cluster with a turn-off mass of 8-9 M☉, consistent with a low-mass Wolf-Rayet star in a binary system.
- Nebular Line Profiles: Asymmetric double-peaked profiles in [O I] and Mg I] lines indicate an aspherical explosion and different distributions of O and Mg in the ejecta.
Limitations and Future Work
- Helium Detection: The detection of helium is tentative and requires further confirmation.
- Progenitor Location: While SN 2007gr is likely associated with a star cluster, its exact membership is not definitively proven and warrants further scrutiny with future, dimmer supernova observations.
- Aspherical Explosion Details: While the evidence for an aspherical explosion is strong, the precise geometry and the mechanisms driving it require further investigation.
- Comparison with Models: The authors suggest that future work could involve more detailed modeling of the spectral evolution and ejecta geometry to further constrain the explosion physics and progenitor properties.
Summary updated