Abstract: Orderly topographic maps in the primary somatosensory cortex (SI) serve as an anchor for our understanding of somatosensory cortical organization. However, this view is mostly based on data collected in the anesthetized animal. Less is known about these topographies in the awake primate. Even less is known about the relative activations of different subdivisions of SI (areas 3a, 3b, 1, and 2). Toward the goal of understanding the functional activation of SI, we conducted intrinsic signal optical imaging of areas 3b and 1 in awake squirrel monkeys. Monkeys were imaged repeatedly for a period of >2 years in awake and anesthetized states in response to vibrotactile and electrocutaneous stimuli presented to individual fingerpads. During this period, we found stable somatotopic maps in both the anesthetized and awake states, consistent with electrophysiologically recorded maps in areas 3b and 1 in the anesthetized state. In the awake animal, signal sizes were larger, but variability was greater, leading to decreased signal-to-noise ratios. Topographic activations were larger (in both area and amplitude) in the awake animal, suggesting either a less precise topography and/or more complex integration. This brings into question the role of a precise topographic map during behavior. In addition, whereas in the anesthetized animal strongest imaging signals were obtained from area 3b, in the awake animal, area 1 activation dominated over that in area 3b. Differences in relative dominance of area 3b versus area 1 suggest that inter-areal interactions in the alert animal differ substantially from that in the anesthetized animal.
Introduction
Most of our fundamental knowledge regarding how the brain maps sensory input—known as topography—is derived from studies conducted on anesthetized animals. While anesthesia is traditionally used to minimize physiological noise and movement, it also significantly suppresses neural activity. This study addresses two critical questions: first, whether the somatosensory map remains stable over long periods across different behavioral states; and second, whether the functional hierarchy of SI subdivisions (areas 3a, 3b, 1, and 2) observed under anesthesia persists in the awake state.
Methods
The researchers employed Intrinsic Signal Optical Imaging (ISOI) to measure local hemodynamic changes following neural activity. Two adult squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus) were implanted with chronic optical chambers over the somatosensory cortex, allowing for repeated imaging over a period exceeding two years.
Stimuli consisted of precise vibrotactile and electrocutaneous pulses applied to individual fingerpads. The study involved 29 imaging sessions (15 awake, 14 anesthetized), with up to 96 repetitions per stimulus in awake sessions to compensate for higher physiological variability. Optical maps were validated against traditional electrophysiological recordings to ensure topographic accuracy.
Results and Key Insights
Topographic Stability and the "Awake Boost"
Despite the inherent noise of the awake brain, the core somatotopic "hotspots" for individual fingers remained spatially stable throughout the two-year study. However, cortical responses in awake monkeys were significantly larger in both amplitude and physical area compared to the anesthetized state. Awake signals showed peak reflectance changes roughly 2–3 times larger than those under anesthesia (e.g., ~0.27% vs ~0.07% dR/R).
The Dominance Shift
A primary finding of this research is the shift in inter-areal dominance. Under anesthesia, area 3b—typically considered an earlier stage of somatosensory processing—exhibited the strongest signals. In contrast, in the awake state, area 1 activation dominated in 61% of cases. The spatial extent of activation in area 1 was also significantly larger in the awake state (~4.88 mm²) compared to area 3b (~3.09 mm²).
Precision vs. Integration
While the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) was lower in the awake state (~5.9) compared to the anesthetized state (~11.6), the larger activation zones suggest that the awake brain engages in more complex integration. Rather than just recording a stimulus with high precision, the alert cortex likely contextualizes sensory input through feedback loops and higher-level processing that are suppressed by anesthesia.
Discussion and Limitations
The study demonstrates that anesthesia masks the true scale and hierarchical dynamics of cortical processing. However, several questions remain. The monkeys in this study were awake but quiescent; active touch (e.g., voluntary exploration) would likely further alter these dynamics. Additionally, as ISOI is sensitive to subthreshold synaptic activity, it remains challenging to distinguish between actual neuronal output and internal cortical "chatter." Future research is needed to explore the roles of areas 3a and 2 in the awake state to complete the functional picture of the primary somatosensory cortex.
Reference: Chen, L. M., Friedman, R. M., & Roe, A. W. (2005). Optical Imaging of SI Topography in Anesthetized and Awake Squirrel Monkeys. The Journal of Neuroscience, 25(33), 7648–7659.
Summary updated