Optical fibers for endoscopic high-power Er:YAG laserosteotomy

Lina M. Beltrán Bernal, Ferda Canbaz, Salim Darwiche, Katja Nuss, Niklaus F. Friederich, Philippe C. Cattin, Azhar ZamJournal of Biomedical Optics 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the performance of various optical fibers for transmitting high-power Er:YAG laser light, crucial for minimally invasive bone cutting (laserosteotomy). They found that germanium oxide fibers offer the best balance of transmission efficiency and flexibility, enabling deep bone ablation in a laboratory setting, paving the way for future endoscopic surgical tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cutting bone during surgery, known as osteotomy, traditionally relies on mechanical tools. While lasers, particularly Er:YAG lasers, offer advantages like reduced collateral damage and precise cutting, their application in minimally invasive procedures, especially endoscopically, is limited. A key challenge is efficiently delivering high-power Er:YAG laser light (at 2.94 µm wavelength) through optical fibers without significant loss or damage. Finding fibers that can handle this high energy, maintain flexibility for endoscopic use, and withstand the harsh surgical environment has been a significant hurdle. This paper aims to address this by evaluating different optical fiber materials for their suitability in transmitting high-power Er:YAG laser light for deep bone ablation in a minimally invasive context.

Methods

The researchers compared four types of optical fibers: germanium oxide (GeO2), sapphire (Al2O3), zirconium fluoride (ZrF4), and hollow-core silica. They evaluated these fibers based on three key criteria:

  1. Transmission Efficiency: How much of the laser energy is transmitted through the fiber.
  2. Resistance to High Laser Energy: How well the fibers withstand high pulse energies without damage.
  3. Bending Flexibility: How well the fibers maintain transmission when bent, a critical factor for endoscopic applications.

They used a microsecond high-power Er:YAG laser and measured transmission efficiency at different input energies and repetition rates (5 and 10 Hz). Stability over time and input tip temperature were also monitored. For bone ablation, they developed a miniaturized focusing system and used sheep tibia cortical bone samples. Histology was performed to assess tissue damage.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used sheep tibia cortical bone samples obtained from animals euthanized for unrelated experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Germanium Oxide Shines: The germanium oxide fiber emerged as the top performer, offering the highest transmission efficiency (around 68%) and the best bending flexibility (minimum bending radius of 4 cm) among the tested fibers.
  • Hollow-Core Limitations: The hollow-core silica fiber struggled with high energies, burning at around 400 mJ, limiting its practical application for high-power ablation.
  • Sapphire's Resilience: While not the most efficient, sapphire fibers demonstrated excellent resistance to damage, even at the highest tested energies (820 mJ), and showed good temperature stability.
  • Fluoride Fiber Issues: The fluoride fiber showed initial transmission drops and, critically, experienced tip burning when bent, highlighting potential durability concerns.
  • Beam Divergence Matters: The performance of sapphire and hollow-core fibers was significantly impacted by beam divergence not perfectly matching their numerical aperture (NA), suggesting careful optical design is crucial.
  • Temperature Management is Key: While most fibers showed stable temperatures, the germanium oxide fiber's tip reached higher temperatures (around 70°C), indicating that thermal management strategies (like splicing with sapphire or improved cooling) will be necessary for practical endoscopic devices.

Key Results

  • Transmission Efficiency: Germanium oxide fiber achieved the highest transmission efficiency (68% ± 3%). Sapphire fiber showed 64% ± 2%, fluoride fiber 65% ± 3%, and hollow-core silica fiber was significantly lower (51% ± 1% at 5 Hz, 45% ± 5% at 10 Hz).
  • High Energy Handling: Three fibers (germanium, sapphire, fluoride) withstood energies up to 820 mJ per pulse at 10 Hz. The hollow-core fiber could only handle up to 330-380 mJ without burning.
  • Bending Stability: Most fibers maintained transmission efficiency when bent to their minimum radii, except for sapphire (a drop from 60-67% to 53-60%) and fluoride (which burned).
  • Bone Ablation: Using the germanium oxide fiber and a custom focusing system, they achieved a deep bone ablation depth of 6.82 ± 0.99 mm in sheep bone with an output energy of 370 mJ per pulse at 10 Hz. Histology confirmed no structural damage to surrounding bone tissue.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temperature Management: The higher tip temperature of the germanium oxide fiber is a significant limitation for prolonged endoscopic use. Future work should focus on resolving this, perhaps by splicing with sapphire or incorporating active cooling systems.
  • Focusing System: The developed focusing system, while effective, used non-biocompatible 3D-printed materials. Future iterations will require biocompatible components.
  • Irrigation and Cleaning: The current setup for water jet irrigation and air cleaning is not optimized for the small working distances required in minimally invasive procedures. Adapting this design is necessary.
  • Hollow-Core Fiber Optimization: While not ideal for this study's high-power requirements, further research into optimizing hollow-core fibers for specific applications might be warranted.
  • Clinical Translation: The study was conducted in a laboratory setting. Further validation and refinement are needed before clinical implementation. The authors suggest that the presented fiber system has the potential for future endoscopic laserosteotomy devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

The findings suggest that our prototype could be used in future generations of endoscopic devices for minimally invasive laserosteotomy.
BibTeX
@article{bernal2021optical,
  author = {Lina M. Beltrán Bernal and Ferda Canbaz and Salim Darwiche and Katja Nuss and Niklaus F. Friederich and Philippe C. Cattin and Azhar Zam},
  title = {{Optical fibers for endoscopic high-power Er:YAG laserosteotomy}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.26.9.095002},
}

Loading related content...

Figure