Optical Fiber Demodulation System with High Performance for Assessing Fretting Damage of Steam Generator Tubes

Peijian Huang, Ning Wang, Junying Li, Yong Zhu, Jie Zhang, Zhide Xi2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, high-speed optical fiber demodulation system designed to accurately measure fretting damage in steam generator tubes, a critical issue in nuclear power plants. By employing a non-scanning correlation method with a super luminescent light-emitting diode (SLED) and a specialized Fabry-Perot sensor, the system achieves fast and precise detection of radial collision forces, paving the way for improved safety and maintenance in nuclear facilities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Steam generator tubes (SGTs) in nuclear power plants are susceptible to fretting damage, which can lead to cracks and premature failure, accounting for a significant portion of failure risks. This damage is caused by factors like fluid motion and thermal energy transmission, leading to fatigue. Accurately assessing this fretting damage is crucial for the design, optimization, and lifespan prediction of SGTs. A key parameter for assessing this damage is "fretting work," which depends on radial collision force, axial displacement, and impact time. However, the confined space (approximately 4 mm) between the SGT and the tube support plate (TSP) makes it challenging to install traditional electric force sensors. Therefore, there's a need for a compact, high-performance sensor and a corresponding demodulation system capable of accurately measuring these forces in real-time, especially given the short impact times involved.

Methods

The core of this work is a novel non-scanning correlation demodulation system for optical fiber Fabry-Perot (F-P) force sensors. This system utilizes a super luminescent light-emitting diode (SLED) as the light source, chosen for its high power density, which allows for shorter CCD integration times and higher demodulation speeds (up to 5-10 kHz).

Key components and techniques include:

  • F-P Force Sensor: A compact sensor (17x5x3 mm³) designed to convert applied force into F-P cavity length variations. This sensor uses a clamped-clamped beam structure where beam deflection, caused by the radial collision force, alters the F-P cavity length.
  • Non-Scanning Correlation Demodulation: This method avoids moving parts and expensive lasers. It relies on a Fizeau interferometer (optical wedge) to spatially separate the modulated light signal from the F-P sensor. A linear CCD array then detects this spatially separated signal. The position of the peak intensity on the CCD corresponds to the F-P cavity length.
  • SLED Optimization: The paper investigates the effects of SLED parameters like center wavelength and bandwidth on demodulation accuracy. They found that a larger bandwidth generally improves signal strength and contrast, while a specific central wavelength (840 nm) minimizes noise.
  • Mode-Mode Interference Mitigation: A challenge arises from coupling light from a single-mode fiber (SMF) to a multi-mode fiber (MMF) in the sensor, which can cause mode-mode interference and introduce errors. To address this, a piezoelectric ceramic transducer (PZT) is used to induce random phase modulation on the MMF. This technique stabilizes the SLED spectrum and significantly reduces the root mean squared error (RMSE) of the demodulation signal, with an optimal driven voltage of 80V identified.
  • Optical System Calibration: The relationship between the CCD pixel position and the F-P cavity length was calibrated using F-P etalons of known lengths, demonstrating excellent linearity (R² = 0.99979).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using laboratory setups and a 1:1 steam generator test loop.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SLED Bandwidth Matters: A wider SLED bandwidth, contrary to initial intuition, leads to a stronger and more robust demodulation signal, even though it might narrow the signal width from the optical wedge. This is crucial for reliable detection.
  • Central Wavelength Sensitivity: The central wavelength of the SLED is critical. Wavelengths shorter than 740 nm introduce significant noise that can corrupt the effective signal, highlighting the importance of selecting an appropriate SLED.
  • Reflectivity Optimization is Key: The reflectivity of the F-P cavity ends (R₁) and the optical wedge (R₂) significantly impacts signal strength (ΔI) and contrast. The paper identifies optimal values (R₁=20%, R₂=40%) that balance signal quality for CCD detection.
  • PZT Modulation for Stability: The use of a PZT to induce random phase modulation is a clever solution to mitigate mode-mode interference, a common issue in SMF-MMF coupling, leading to a more stable and accurate F-P cavity length measurement.

Key Results

  • The developed non-scanning correlation demodulation system achieved a demodulation speed of 5 KHz.
  • The system successfully demodulated a force signal of 32 N with a collision time of 2 ms in a 1:1 steam generator test loop.
  • The system demonstrated high performance in a simulated humid, high-pressure, and vibrating environment.
  • The PZT modulation method reduced the RMSE of the demodulation signal, with the smallest RMSE achieved at 80V.
  • Calibration showed a strong linear correlation between CCD pixel position and cavity length.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Demodulation Speed and Accuracy: While the system achieves 5 KHz, the authors acknowledge that future work will focus on developing systems with higher demodulation speed and accuracy.
  • System Stability: The paper mentions that the stability of the demodulation system will be investigated in future work.
  • Real-world Complexity: The 1:1 test loop simulates real conditions, but the long-term performance and potential degradation of the sensor and system in a continuously operating nuclear environment would require further investigation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{huang2018optical,
  author = {Peijian Huang and Ning Wang and Junying Li and Yong Zhu and Jie Zhang and Zhide Xi},
  title = {{Optical Fiber Demodulation System with High Performance for Assessing Fretting Damage of Steam Generator Tubes}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18010201},
}

Loading related content...

Figure