Optical calibration of the SNO+ detector in the water phase with deployed sources

Mark R. Anderson, S. Andringa, M. Askins, D. J. Auty, F. Barão, N. Barros, R. Bayes, E. W. Beier, A. Białek, S. D. Biller, L. Bezrukov, M. G. Boulay, E. Caden, M. Chen, J. Caravaca, O. Chkvorets, B. T. Cleveland, D. Cookman, J. Corning, M. A. Cox, C. Deluce, M. M. Depatie, F. Di Lodovico, J. Dittmer, E. Falk, N. Fatemighomi, V. Fischer, R. Ford, K. Frankiewicz, A. Gaur, K. Gilje, O. I. González-Reina, D. Gooding, C. Grant, J. E. Grove, A. L. Hallin, D. Hallman, J. Hartnell, W. J. Heintzelman, R. L. Helmer, Jun Hu, R. Hunt-Stokes, Safeer Hussain, A. S. Inácio, C. Jillings, T. Kaptanoglu, P. Khaghani, Hamza Khan, J. Klein, L. L. Kormos, B. Krar, C. Kraus, C. B. Krauss, Tereza Kroupova, I. Lam, Benjamin Land, A. Latorre, I. Lawson, L. Lebanowski, C. Lefebvre, A. Li, J. Lidgard, Yen-Hsun Lin, Y. Liu, V. Lozza, M. Luo, E. E. Khoda, S. Manecki, J. Maneira, R. D. Martin, N. McCauley, A. B. McDonald, M. Meyer, C. Mills, I. Morton-Blake, S. Nae, M. Nirkko, L. J. Nolan, H. M. O’Keeffe, G. D. Orebi Gann, J. Page, William C. Parker, J. Paton, S. J. M. Peeters, T. Pershing, L. Pickard, G. Prior, P. Ravi, A. Reichold, S. Riccetto, R. Richardson, M. Rigan, J. Rose, J. Rumleskie, I. Semenec, F. Shaker, Manoj Kumar Sharma, P. Skensved, M. SmileyJournal of Instrumentation 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

The SNO+ experiment, designed to search for rare nuclear decays, has successfully calibrated its optical properties during its water phase. By deploying a light source ("laserball") and a gamma source, they precisely measured how light travels and is detected within the detector, leading to a significant reduction in energy scale uncertainties. This detailed optical characterization is crucial for the experiment's future success in detecting elusive neutrinos.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting rare events like neutrinoless double beta decay requires extremely precise measurements of the energy deposited by particles. In large detectors like SNO+, the Cherenkov light produced by these interactions must travel through various materials (water, acrylic) and be detected by numerous photomultiplier tubes (PMTs). The way this light propagates, scatters, and is absorbed is complex and depends on the optical properties of the detector's components and media. Any uncertainty in these properties directly translates into uncertainty in the reconstructed energy of an event, which is a major systematic error. Before filling SNO+ with its primary scintillator target, the experiment operated as a pure water Cherenkov detector. This "water phase" provided a unique opportunity to meticulously measure these optical properties in situ using deployed calibration sources, thereby establishing a robust baseline for the detector's performance and improving the accuracy of future analyses.

Methods

The core of this work lies in precisely measuring the optical properties of the SNO+ detector. This was achieved using two primary methods:

  • Laserball Calibration: A light-diffusing sphere ("laserball") was deployed at various positions within and outside the detector. This sphere emitted light at different wavelengths, mimicking the Cherenkov light produced by particle interactions. By analyzing the timing and intensity of the light detected by the PMTs, the researchers could:
  • Determine the attenuation lengths of the ultra-pure water and the acrylic vessel.
  • Characterize the angular response of the PMTs and their light concentrators.
  • Measure the group velocity of light in water.
  • A sophisticated Monte Carlo simulation model was developed and iteratively fitted to the laserball data to extract these parameters.
  • 16N Gamma Source Validation: A deployed 16N gamma source provided a known energy signature. This source was used to validate the detector model built with the optical parameters derived from the laserball data. By comparing the simulated response to the actual data from the gamma source, the overall accuracy of the detector model and its impact on the energy scale could be assessed.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this paper are:

  • Laserball Data: Collected during two main campaigns in December 2017 and July 2018. This data comprises measurements from the laserball deployed at approximately 40 internal positions and 19 external positions, covering six different wavelengths.
  • 16N Gamma Source Data: Collected in November 2017 from 80 different positions within the detector. This dataset served as a validation tool for the calibrated detector model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • In-situ measurements are crucial: The paper strongly emphasizes the necessity of measuring optical properties directly within the detector. External measurements might not accurately reflect the conditions inside a large, complex detector.
  • Water phase as a calibration opportunity: Operating SNO+ as a pure water Cherenkov detector before filling it with scintillator was a strategic choice that allowed for a comprehensive optical calibration, significantly improving the detector model.
  • Acrylic attenuation is measurable: For the first time, the effective attenuation of the acrylic vessel was measured in situ by combining internal and external laserball data. This is a significant improvement over relying on external measurements.
  • PMT angular response degradation: Comparisons with previous SNO measurements revealed a degradation in the PMT-concentrator angular response over time, highlighting the importance of ongoing calibration.
  • Energy scale uncertainty reduction: The meticulous optical calibration directly led to a significant reduction in the energy scale systematic uncertainty, a critical factor for the sensitivity of the experiment.

Key Results

  • Water Attenuation: The water attenuation coefficients were measured across a range of wavelengths, showing good agreement with literature values.
  • Acrylic Attenuation: Effective acrylic vessel attenuation coefficients were measured in situ for the first time.
  • PMT Angular Response: The angular response of the PMT-concentrator assembly was characterized for various wavelengths and incidence angles, including angles above 45 degrees for the first time.
  • Group Velocity of Light: The group velocity of light in water was measured and found to be consistent with the values used in the SNO+ simulation.
  • Energy Scale Validation: The calibrated detector model, incorporating the measured optical properties, was validated using the 16N tagged gamma source. This resulted in a position-dependent energy scale uncertainty of only 0.6% for the Nhit estimator.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Acrylic Uniformity Assumption: The Monte Carlo model assumes the acrylic is uniform, while real-world bonding or surface effects might exist and are not fully accounted for.
  • PMT Degradation: The observed degradation of PMT-concentrator optical surfaces over time is difficult to model precisely, making it challenging to create a time-evolving model.
  • Future Work: The paper implies that these calibrated optical parameters will be directly incorporated into the SNO+ detector simulation for future analyses, particularly for the search for neutrinoless double beta decay. The success of this calibration in reducing systematic uncertainties sets a strong foundation for the experiment's primary science goals.

Summary updated

Abstract

SNO+ is a large-scale liquid scintillator experiment with the primary goal of\nsearching for neutrinoless double beta decay, and is located approximately 2 km\nunderground in SNOLAB, Sudbury, Canada. The detector acquired data for two\nyears as a pure water Cherenkov detector, starting in May 2017. During this\nperiod, the optical properties of the detector were measured in situ using a\ndeployed light diffusing sphere, with the goal of improving the detector model\nand the energy response systematic uncertainties. The measured parameters\nincluded the water attenuation coefficients, effective attenuation coefficients\nfor the acrylic vessel, and the angular response of the photomultiplier tubes\nand their surrounding light concentrators, all across different wavelengths.\nThe calibrated detector model was validated using a deployed tagged gamma\nsource, which showed a 0.6% variation in energy scale across the primary target\nvolume.
BibTeX
@article{anderson2021optical,
  author = {Mark R. Anderson and S. Andringa and M. Askins and D. J. Auty and F. Barão and N. Barros and R. Bayes and E. W. Beier and A. Białek and S. D. Biller and L. Bezrukov and M. G. Boulay and E. Caden and M. Chen and J. Caravaca and M. Chen and O. Chkvorets and B. T. Cleveland and D. Cookman and J. Corning and M. A. Cox and C. Deluce and M. M. Depatie and F. Di Lodovico and J. Dittmer and E. Falk and N. Fatemighomi and V. Fischer and R. Ford and K. Frankiewicz and A. Gaur and K. Gilje and O. I. González-Reina and D. Gooding and C. Grant and J. E. Grove and A. L. Hallin and D. Hallman and J. Hartnell and W. J. Heintzelman and R. L. Helmer and Jun Hu and R. Hunt-Stokes and Safeer Hussain and A. S. Inácio and C. Jillings and T. Kaptanoglu and P. Khaghani and Hamza Khan and J. Klein and L. L. Kormos and B. Krar and C. Kraus and C. B. Krauss and Tereza Kroupova and I. Lam and Benjamin Land and A. Latorre and I. Lawson and L. Lebanowski and C. Lefebvre and A. Li and J. Lidgard and Yen-Hsun Lin and Y. Liu and V. Lozza and M. Luo and E. E. Khoda and S. Manecki and J. Maneira and R. D. Martin and N. McCauley and A. B. McDonald and M. Meyer and C. Mills and I. Morton-Blake and S. Nae and M. Nirkko and L. J. Nolan and H. M. O’Keeffe and G. D. Orebi Gann and J. Page and William C. Parker and J. Paton and S. J. M. Peeters and T. Pershing and L. Pickard and G. Prior and P. Ravi and A. Reichold and S. Riccetto and R. Richardson and M. Rigan and J. Rose and J. Rumleskie and I. Semenec and F. Shaker and Manoj Kumar Sharma and P. Skensved and M. Smiley},
  title = {{Optical calibration of the SNO+ detector in the water phase with deployed sources}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/16/10/p10021},
}

Loading related content...

Figure