Opposite Epigenetic Associations With Alcohol Use and Exercise Intervention

Jiayu Chen, Kent E. Hutchison, Angela D. Bryan, Francesca M. Filbey, Vince D. Calhoun, Eric D. Claus, Dongdong Lin, Jing Sui, Yuhui Du, Jingyu LiuFrontiers in Psychiatry 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how DNA methylation (epigenetic markers) changes in response to alcohol use and exercise. They found that exercise can induce DNA methylation changes that are opposite to those associated with alcohol consumption, suggesting a potential role for exercise in mitigating some of the epigenetic effects of drinking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD) is a significant public health issue influenced by both genetic and environmental factors. Epigenetic regulation, particularly DNA methylation, is increasingly recognized as a key mechanism by which environmental factors like alcohol exposure can alter brain function and contribute to AUD. While it's known that epigenetic patterns can be modified by various stimuli, including exercise, it's unclear if exercise can reverse the specific epigenetic changes linked to alcohol consumption. This paper aims to explore whether exercise can induce DNA methylation changes that are opposite to those observed in individuals who drink alcohol, potentially offering a new avenue for AUD prevention and intervention.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-cohort approach to compare DNA methylation patterns. They utilized:

  • Longitudinal Exercise Intervention Cohort: This cohort allowed them to track changes in DNA methylation in healthy individuals before and after a 12-month exercise intervention. Paired t-tests were used to identify significant DNA methylation alterations.
  • Cross-Sectional Case-Control Cohort: This group compared DNA methylation between hazardous drinkers and healthy controls matched for age and sex. Regression models were used to identify CpG sites with differential methylation.
  • Cross-Sectional Binge Drinking Cohort: This cohort was used to examine the association between DNA methylation and drinking behavior. A two-step analysis was performed: first, identifying group-difference CpG sites from the case-control cohort, and then assessing linear associations with behavioral scales in the binge drinking cohort.

A key analytical step involved comparing the DNA methylation sites identified in the exercise intervention with those associated with drinking. They specifically focused on sites that showed opposite directions of association between exercise and drinking. Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) was used to identify enriched signaling pathways associated with these sites. Additionally, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) was employed to explore multivariate associations between DNA methylation and behavioral measures.

Datasets

The study utilized three distinct human cohorts:

  1. Longitudinal Exercise Intervention Cohort: 53 healthy participants who underwent a 12-month exercise intervention. DNA methylation data was collected at baseline and follow-up.
  2. Cross-Sectional Case-Control Cohort: 81 hazardous drinkers and 81 healthy controls, matched for age and sex.
  3. Cross-Sectional Binge Drinking Cohort: 281 drinkers.

The DNA methylation profiling was performed using the Illumina HumanMethylation27 BeadChip. Behavioral assessments included measures like the Alcohol Dependence Scale (ADS), Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT), and Impaired Control Scale (ICS) for alcohol.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Exercise as a potential epigenetic counter-balance: The most striking finding is that exercise can induce DNA methylation changes that are in the opposite direction to those associated with alcohol consumption at specific sites. This suggests a potential mechanism by which exercise might counteract some of the epigenetic disruptions caused by heavy drinking.
  • Synaptic plasticity is a key pathway: Genes associated with the 15 CpG sites showing opposite effects were significantly enriched in signaling pathways related to synaptic plasticity. This is particularly relevant as synaptic plasticity is a fundamental process underlying neuroadaptation and is heavily implicated in addiction.
  • Impaired control links to neural function: The identified methylation sites were also significantly associated with impaired control over drinking. This suggests that these epigenetic markers might be relevant to neural functions that underpin the loss of control characteristic of AUD.
  • Saliva as a proxy for neural epigenetics: While the study used saliva for DNA methylation analysis, the findings related to impaired control over drinking suggest that peripheral epigenetic markers might reflect underlying neural processes relevant to AUD.

Key Results

  • Exercise-induced DNAm changes: 341 CpG sites showed significant DNA methylation alterations after the 12-month exercise intervention in the healthy cohort.
  • Drinking-associated DNAm changes: 906 CpG sites showed significant DNA methylation differences between drinkers and controls, and/or associations with drinking behavior.
  • Opposite associations: 32 CpG sites overlapped between the exercise and drinking analyses. Crucially, 15 of these sites exhibited opposite directions of DNA methylation association with exercise versus drinking.
  • Pathway enrichment: Genes annotated to these 15 sites were enriched in pathways like anandamide degradation, reelin signaling, and Wnt/β-catenin signaling.
  • Behavioral associations: Two specific CpG sites (cg06270401 and cg26825412) were associated with impaired control over drinking, with lower DNA methylation correlating with higher impaired control scores.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample size and power: While the study used multiple cohorts, some analyses were based on relatively small sample sizes, limiting definitive conclusions.
  • Assay limitations: The HumanMethylation27 assay primarily covers promoter regions, and it cannot distinguish between 5-methylcytosine (5mC) and 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC).
  • Tissue specificity: DNA methylation is tissue-specific, and findings from saliva may not perfectly reflect epigenetic patterns in the brain, which is directly involved in AUD.
  • Causality: The study identifies associations, not causal relationships. It's difficult to determine if DNA methylation precedes or follows drinking behavior and exercise.
  • Race matching: The case-control and binge drinking cohorts were not matched for race, although efforts were made to control for this in the analysis and a subset was further matched.

Future work should focus on:

  • Replication: Independent replication of these findings in larger, more diverse cohorts is essential.
  • Advanced techniques: Utilizing more comprehensive sequencing techniques and methods to differentiate between 5mC and 5hmC.
  • Longitudinal high-risk studies: Investigating epigenetic changes in individuals at high risk for AUD over time.
  • Animal models: Further exploring the causal mechanisms in animal models to understand the interplay between exercise, alcohol, and epigenetics.
  • Brain tissue analysis: Where ethically and practically feasible, examining DNA methylation in brain tissue would provide more direct insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alcohol use disorder (AUD) is a devastating public health problem in which both genetic and environmental factors play a role. Growing evidence supports that epigenetic regulation is one major mechanism in neuroadaptation that contributes to development of AUD. Meanwhile, epigenetic patterns can be modified by various stimuli including exercise. Thus, it is an intriguing question whether exercise can lead to methylation changes that are opposite to those related to drinking. We herein conducted a comparative study to explore this issue. Three cohorts were profiled for DNA methylation (DNAm), including a longitudinal exercise intervention cohort (53 healthy participants profiled at baseline and after a 12-months exercise intervention), a cross-sectional case-control cohort (81 hazardous drinkers and 81 healthy controls matched in age and sex), and a cross-sectional binge drinking cohort (281 drinkers). We identified 906 methylation sites showing significant DNAm differences between drinkers and controls in the case-control cohort, as well as, associations with drinking behavior in the drinking cohort. In parallel, 341 sites were identified for significant DNAm alterations between baseline and follow-up in the exercise cohort. Thirty-two sites overlapped between these two set of findings, of which 15 sites showed opposite directions of DNAm associations between exercise and drinking. Annotated genes of these 15 sites were enriched in signaling pathways related to synaptic plasticity. In addition, the identified methylation sites significantly associated with impaired control over drinking, suggesting relevance to neural function. Collectively, the current findings provide preliminary evidence that exercise has the potential to partially reverse DNAm differences associated with drinking at some CpG sites, motivating rigorously designed longitudinal studies to better characterize epigenetic effects with respect to prevention and intervention of AUD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2018opposite,
  author = {Jiayu Chen and Kent E. Hutchison and Angela D. Bryan and Francesca M. Filbey and Vince D. Calhoun and Eric D. Claus and Dongdong Lin and Jing Sui and Yuhui Du and Jingyu Liu},
  title = {{Opposite Epigenetic Associations With Alcohol Use and Exercise Intervention}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00594},
}
Figure