Opportunities for Nuclear Physics & Quantum Information Science

Ian C. Cloët, Matthew R. Dietrich, J. Arrington, Alexei Bazavov, Michael Bishof, Adam Freese, Alexey V. Gorshkov, Anna Grassellino, Kawtar Hafidi, Zubin Jacob, Michael R. McGuigan, Yannick Meurice, Z.-e. Meziani, Peter R. Müeller, Christine A. Muschik, Xiao-Yong Jin, Matthew Otten, Péter Petreczky, Tomas Polakovic, A. W. P. Poon, Raphael C. Pooser, Alessandro Roggero, M. Saffman, B. A. VanDevender, Jiehang Zhang, Erez ZohararXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This whitepaper is an outcome of the workshop Intersections between Nuclear Physics and Quantum Information held at Argonne National Laboratory in March 2018. The workshop brought together 116 national and international experts in nuclear physics (NP) and quantum information science (QIS) to explore opportunities for collaboration. Topics discussed included quantum computation, simulation, sensing, nuclear detectors, the nuclear many-body problem, entanglement at collider energies, and lattice gauge theories. This report outlines a strategic roadmap for the synergy between these two fields, emphasizing mutual benefits for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and broader society.

The conceptual intersection of Nuclear Physics (NP) and Quantum Information (QI).

Introduction: Overcoming the "Classical Wall"

Nuclear physics is currently approaching a "classical wall." Two of the field's most fundamental challenges—the nuclear many-body problem (understanding how nucleons interact to form nuclei) and Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) at finite density—are computationally overwhelming for even the most powerful classical supercomputers. These problems suffer from the "fermion sign problem," where the complexity of calculations grows exponentially with the number of particles involved.

Simultaneously, the field of QIS is navigating the "NISQ" (Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum) era. While quantum bits (qubits) exist, they remain fragile and error-prone. The QIS community requires advanced materials, more precise sensors, and specialized isotopes to improve coherence times and scale hardware. This paper argues that a formal bridge between these two communities is essential to solving these mutual bottlenecks.

Methodologies for Synergy

The proposed research avenues focus on merging the theoretical and experimental strengths of both fields. Key technical approaches include:

  • Digital Quantum Computing: Utilizing algorithms such as the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and the Unitary Coupled-Cluster (UCC) ansatz to calculate nuclear binding energies on existing quantum hardware.
  • Analog Quantum Simulation: Employing trapped ions or neutral atoms in optical lattices to mimic the Hamiltonians of lattice gauge theories, bypassing the limitations of universal digital gates.
  • Quantum Sensing: Deploying Transition Edge Sensors (TESs) and Superconducting Nanowire Single-Photon Detectors (SNSPDs)—technologies often refined for QIS—to enhance nuclear physics experiments, such as searches for dark matter or neutrinoless double beta decay.
  • Cross-Pollination of Theory: Applying QIS concepts like entanglement entropy to interpret the quark-gluon structure of matter in high-energy collider experiments.
Complex experimental infrastructure required for high-precision nuclear and quantum research.

Strategic Insights and Hardware Innovation

A primary insight of the report is that nuclear physics is not merely a beneficiary of QIS; it is one of its most natural applications. Because nuclear systems are inherently quantum and many-body, they serve as ideal testbeds for demonstrating "quantum advantage."

Furthermore, NP facilities are uniquely positioned to provide the "ingredients" for QIS hardware. This includes the production of highly enriched isotopes (e.g., Calcium-43 or Silicon-28) that serve as ultra-stable qubits, and the adaptation of high-Q superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities to significantly extend qubit coherence times.

Beyond hardware, the report highlights a shift in theoretical perspective: researchers are now using QIS entropy measures to interpret data from particle colliders. This suggests that the "thermal" properties of particles produced in high-energy collisions may actually be a manifestation of quantum entanglement.

Results and High-Priority Opportunities

The workshop concluded with five high-priority research opportunities to guide future investment:

  1. Collaborative Funding: Joint projects between universities, national labs, and industry.
  2. Broad Theory Program: Developing quantum algorithms specifically tailored for nuclear Hamiltonians.
  3. Hardware/Sensor Synergy: Capitalizing on NP's detector expertise to build superior quantum sensors.
  4. Workforce Development: Funding graduate students and postdocs to become "bilingual" in both subatomic physics and quantum circuits.
  5. Community Building: Establishing an NP-QIS alliance to share resources and pedagogical tools.

On the technical front, the report notes a successful proof-of-concept: researchers used IBM and Rigetti quantum processors to calculate the deuteron binding energy to within a few percent of the empirical value—a significant first step toward simulating larger nuclei.

Limitations and Future Outlook

The transition to full-scale quantum advantage faces significant hurdles. Current hardware has low circuit depth and lacks robust error correction. Many proposed QCD simulations are currently limited to "1+1" dimensions and require scaling to the 3+1 dimensions of reality. Future work will focus on "gate-compiling"—optimizing the translation of nuclear equations into quantum code—and improving materials science to move beyond current 100-microsecond coherence barriers.

Summary updated

Abstract

This whitepaper is an outcome of the workshop Intersections between Nuclear Physics and Quantum Information held at Argonne National Laboratory on 28-30 March 2018 [www.phy.anl.gov/npqi2018/]. The workshop brought together 116 national and international experts in nuclear physics and quantum information science to explore opportunities for the two fields to collaborate on topics of interest to the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, and more broadly to U.S. society and industry. The workshop consisted of 22 invited and 10 contributed talks, as well as three panel discussion sessions. Topics discussed included quantum computation, quantum simulation, quantum sensing, nuclear physics detectors, nuclear many-body problem, entanglement at collider energies, and lattice gauge theories.
BibTeX
@misc{cloet2019opportunities,
  author = {Ian C. Cloët and Matthew R. Dietrich and J. Arrington and Alexei Bazavov and Michael Bishof and Adam Freese and Alexey V. Gorshkov and Anna Grassellino and Kawtar Hafidi and Zubin Jacob and Michael R. McGuigan and Yannick Meurice and Z.-E. Meziani and Peter R. Müeller and Christine A. Muschik and Xiao-Yong Jin and Matthew Otten and Péter Petreczky and Tomas Polakovic and A. W. P. Poon and Raphael C. Pooser and Alessandro Roggero and M. Saffman and B. A. VanDevender and Jiehang Zhang and Erez Zohar},
  title = {{Opportunities for Nuclear Physics \& Quantum Information Science}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1903.05453},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1903.05453},
}
Figure