Opportunities and Barriers for Agrivoltaics on Tribal Lands

Karli A. Moore, David B. LobellSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Agrivoltaics, the co-location of solar panels and agriculture, presents a promising avenue for Tribal lands to enhance food and energy sovereignty while fostering economic development. This study identifies significant potential (up to 15 million acres) for agrivoltaics on Tribal lands, but also highlights crucial technical, economic, siting, and socio-ecological barriers that must be addressed for successful adoption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Recent federal legislation in the US is driving a significant increase in solar energy development, particularly on Tribal lands. This surge in solar projects creates a potential conflict with existing agricultural land, raising concerns about competition for limited resources and the long-term implications for food production. Agrivoltaics offers a potential solution by integrating solar energy generation with agriculture, thereby maximizing land use. However, the specific opportunities and challenges of implementing agrivoltaics on Tribal lands, with their unique land tenure, cultural considerations, and existing infrastructure limitations, have not been thoroughly explored. This paper aims to fill that gap by investigating these aspects.

Methods

This research employed a mixed-methods approach:

  1. Scoping Study: A geospatial analysis using Google Earth Engine was conducted to identify Tribal lands suitable for agrivoltaics. This involved defining Tribal lands based on US Census Bureau data and then applying exclusion criteria related to land use (excluding non-agricultural land), crop type (excluding tall crops), and slope (excluding slopes greater than 5%).
  2. Qualitative Expert Interviews: Twenty-one semi-structured interviews were conducted with Tribal agriculture professionals. The interviews explored their experiences with Tribal agriculture, knowledge of energy production, perceptions of agrivoltaics (opportunities and barriers), and feedback on the scoping study's suitability map.
  3. Suitability Study: This phase integrated the qualitative insights with geospatial analysis. It assessed agricultural potential (based on NDVI for grassland productivity and a fixed value for cropland), solar energy generation potential (using global solar atlas data), and proximity to transmission lines. These factors were combined to create a weighted suitability score for agrivoltaics.

Datasets

  • Tribal Land Base: U.S. Census Bureau AIANNH Areas dataset.
  • Agricultural Land Use: USDA Cropland Data Layer (2022).
  • Slope: SRTM Digital Elevation Data V4.
  • Grassland Productivity: Median summer NDVI from Landsat 8 imaging (2013–2022).
  • Solar Energy Potential: Global Solar Atlas (PVOUT data).
  • Transmission Infrastructure: U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s Homeland Infrastructure Foundation-Level Database (for high-voltage transmission lines).

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study utilized existing datasets and established methodologies for geospatial analysis and qualitative research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual-Use Synergy: Agrivoltaics isn't just about co-locating; it's about creating synergistic benefits. Participants highlighted how shade from panels can protect crops in hot climates and improve livestock growth, while energy generation can power essential infrastructure like refrigeration for food preservation.
  • Holistic Sovereignty: The concept of agrivoltaics resonates deeply with Tribal goals of food and energy sovereignty. It offers a pathway for Tribes to gain greater control over their food systems and energy futures, moving away from reliance on external, often unsustainable, sources.
  • Land Tenure as a Major Hurdle: The complex nature of land ownership and leasing on Tribal lands (checkerboarding, fractionation, BIA leasing) presents significant administrative and legal challenges that could impede agrivoltaics development.
  • Economic Viability Concerns: While potential economic benefits are recognized, participants voiced concerns about who would truly benefit from revenue, the difficulty of securing financing on trust lands, and the potential for unequal contract negotiations with energy companies.
  • Prioritizing Less Productive Land: A strong sentiment emerged from participants that agrivoltaics should ideally be implemented on less productive agricultural lands to avoid sacrificing prime cropland, aligning with the goal of maximizing land productivity.

Key Results

  • Feasible Land: Approximately 15.2 million acres of Tribal land (21% of the total) were identified as feasible for agrivoltaics based on land use, crop type, and slope.
  • Grid-Tied Potential: Of the feasible land, about 7 million acres are within six miles of existing high-voltage transmission lines, making them suitable for grid-tied applications.
  • Leading States: South Dakota, Montana, and Arizona emerged as the top states with the most agrivoltaics-feasible Tribal land, largely due to their extensive Tribal land bases and agricultural economies.
  • Qualitative Themes: Key barriers identified by participants included:
  • Technical: Durability of equipment, operational complexity.
  • Economic: Financing challenges, market access for energy.
  • Siting: Land tenure complexities, checkerboarding, BIA leasing.
  • Socio-ecological: Community benefit, environmental impacts, wildlife concerns.
  • Opportunities: Participants saw agrivoltaics contributing to food sovereignty, energy sovereignty, and sustainable economic development.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that the non-random interview sampling means claims are not generalizable but rather theory-generating.
  • The geospatial analysis is a first approximation and does not account for detailed land tenure, zoning, or specific cultural values.
  • The assessment of photovoltaic technology is generalized, and future innovations could impact energy generation estimates.
  • The study did not deeply explore the impact of agricultural and energy policy.
  • Future Work:
    • Tailored questions to uncover more information on policy implications.
  • Direct collaboration with Tribes to create more detailed suitability maps incorporating land tenure, zoning, and cultural values.
  • Expanding the assessment of physical parameters (e.g., proximity to substations, water availability).
  • More complex modeling of agrivoltaics potential considering specific photovoltaic technologies.
  • Assessing the economic, policy, and governance landscape for agrivoltaics investment.
  • Exploring intertribal partnerships for financial capacity and resource endowment.
  • Additional research and extension efforts are needed to fully explore the potential and facilitate broader social decision-making processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent federal legislation, like the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, has led to a push for more solar energy on Tribal lands, increasing competition for already limited agricultural land. Agrivoltaics is an innovative technology with the potential to lessen the tradeoffs between agriculture production and solar energy generation. This study investigates the opportunities and barriers for agrivoltaics on Tribal lands through expert qualitative interviews with Tribal agriculture professionals that inform geospatial suitability analysis of physical characteristics. Qualitative results indicate agrivoltaics on Tribal lands could contribute positively to food sovereignty, energy sovereignty, and economic development goals for Tribes; on the other hand, Tribal agriculture professionals have technical, economic, siting, and socioecological concerns that should be addressed through future work. Quantitatively, we find up to 15 million acres of Tribal agricultural land may be feasible for micro-grid agrivoltaics, with 7 million acres in sufficient proximity to existing transmission lines to tie into the grid. The leading states for Tribal agrivoltaics by land area are South Dakota, Montana, and Arizona, each home to Tribes with large land bases and a strong agricultural economy. This work aims to inform Tribal land managers, policymakers, and researchers on the opportunities and barriers for agrivoltaics on Tribal lands.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moore2024opportunities,
  author = {Karli A. Moore and David B. Lobell},
  title = {{Opportunities and Barriers for Agrivoltaics on Tribal Lands}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16135414},
}
Figure