Opportunistic Beamforming using Dumb Basis Patterns in Multiple Access Cognitive Channels

Ahmed M. Alaa, Mahmoud H. Ismail, Hazim TawfikarXiv 2014 · OpenReview

Abstract: In this paper, we investigate multiuser diversity in interference-limited Multiple Access (MAC) underlay cognitive channels with Line-of-Sight interference (LoS) from the secondary to the primary network. It is shown that for $N$ secondary users, and assuming Rician interference channels, the secondary sum capacity scales like $\log\left(\frac{K^{2}+K}{\mathcal{W}\left(\frac{K e^{K}}{N} ight)}\right)$, where $K$ is the $K$-factor of the Rician channels, and $\mathcal{W}(.)$ is the Lambert W function. Thus, LoS interference hinders the achievable multiuser diversity gain experienced in Rayleigh channels, where the sum capacity grows like $\log(N)$. To overcome this problem, we propose the usage of single radio Electronically Steerable Parasitic Array Radiator (ESPAR) antennas at the secondary mobile terminals. Using ESPAR antennas, we induce artificial fluctuations in the interference channels to restore the $\log(N)$ growth rate by assigning random weights to orthogonal basis patterns. We term this technique as Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB). While LoS interference is originally a source of capacity hindrance, we show that using RAB, it can actually be exploited to improve multiuser interference diversity by boosting the effective number of users with minimal hardware complexity.

The Challenge of Line-of-Sight Interference

In "underlay" cognitive radio networks, Secondary Users (SUs) transmit on the same frequency as Primary Users (PUs), provided they keep their interference below a certain threshold. To maximize efficiency, the system uses Multiuser Interference Diversity (MID): it schedules the SU that happens to have the weakest interference link to the PU at that moment.

System model of the cognitive radio network showing secondary transmitters (SUs) and their interference links to the primary receiver.

The "gold standard" for capacity growth in these networks is $\log(N)$, where $N$ is the number of users. However, this relies on Rayleigh fading (high fluctuations). When a Line-of-Sight (LoS) component exists—modeled as Rician fading—the channel becomes "harder" and less variable. As the LoS component (the $K$-factor) increases, the sum capacity scaling degrades toward $\log(\log(N))$, effectively behaving like a standard non-cognitive network where the benefits of opportunistic scheduling vanish.

Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB)

The authors propose Random Aerial Beamforming (RAB) to combat this diversity hindrance using low-cost hardware:

  1. ESPAR Antennas: Instead of expensive multiple-antenna arrays, they use an Electronically Steerable Parasitic Array Radiator. This consists of a single active element surrounded by parasitic elements. By tuning reactive loads on the parasitic elements, the antenna's radiation pattern can be changed dynamically.
  2. Artificial Fluctuations: The SU assigns random weights to the antenna's orthonormal basis patterns. This creates a "dumb" beamforming effect that induces fluctuations in the interference channel, mimicking the behavior of Rayleigh fading.
  3. Mathematical Restoration: Using extreme value theory and the Lambert W function, the authors prove that RAB restores the $\log(N)$ scaling regardless of the $K$-factor.

Key Insights and Results

The most counter-intuitive finding is that with RAB, LoS interference actually becomes better than Rayleigh fading. Because the LoS component is stable, the artificial randomization applied by the ESPAR antenna can create deeper and more frequent "nulls" toward the PU.

Ergodic sum capacity vs. number of SUs, demonstrating how RAB restores log(N) scaling and boosts the effective number of users.

As shown in the capacity results, RAB provides a significant "Effective User Boost." In a high-LoS environment ($K=20$ dB), applying RAB with just two basis patterns makes 200 physical users behave like 800 users in terms of capacity gain. This multiplier grows as the LoS component ($K$) increases, showing that the system performs better as the LoS becomes stronger.

Conclusion

RAB offers a hardware-efficient way to exploit LoS components that were previously considered detrimental to cognitive radio performance. By using a single RF chain and parasitic elements, mobile devices can achieve high multiuser diversity gains with minimal complexity. Future research may focus on the feedback overhead required for scheduling and the impact of non-ideal hardware components in real-world deployments.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate multiuser diversity in interference-limited Multiple Access (MAC) underlay cognitive channels with Line-of-Sight interference (LoS) from the secondary to the primary network. It is shown that for $N$ secondary users, and assuming Rician interference channels, the secondary sum capacity scales like $\log\left(\frac{K^{2}+K}{\mathcal{W}\left(\frac{K e^{K}}{N}\right)}\right)$, where $K$ is the $K$-factor of the Rician channels, and $\mathcal{W}(.)$ is the Lambert W function. Thus, LoS interference hinders the achievable multiuser diversity gain experienced in Rayleigh channels, where the sum capacity grows like $\log(N)$. To overcome this problem, we propose the usage of single radio Electronically Steerable Parasitic Array Radiator (ESPAR) antennas at the secondary mobile terminals. Using ESPAR antennas, we induce artificial fluctuations in the interference channels to restore the $\log(N)$ growth rate by assigning random weights to orthogonal {\it basis patterns}. We term this technique as {\it Random Aerial Beamforming} (RAB). While LoS interference is originally a source of capacity hindrance, we show that using RAB, it can actually be exploited to improve multiuser interference diversity by boosting the {\it effective number of users} with minimal hardware complexity.
BibTeX
@misc{alaa2014opportunistic,
  author = {Ahmed M. Alaa and Mahmoud H. Ismail and Hazim Tawfik},
  title = {{Opportunistic Beamforming using Dumb Basis Patterns in Multiple Access Cognitive Channels}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1407.1383},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1407.1383},
}
Figure