Opinion Dynamic Under Malicious Agent Influence in Multi-Agent Systems: From the Perspective of Opinion Evolution Cost

Yuhan Suo, Runqi Chai, Senchun Chai, Ishrak Md Farhan, Xudong Zhao, Yuanqing XiaarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In decentralized multi-agent systems (MAS), achieving consensus is vital for coordinated action. However, these systems are vulnerable to malicious actors who inject extreme or false opinions to disrupt the collective state. Traditional consensus algorithms often fail to isolate these influences effectively. This paper explores a defense strategy inspired by the sociological "Boomerang Effect," where agents reject extreme inputs, and introduces a framework to manage the associated "opinion evolution cost."

The Boomerang Effect and the Cost of Resistance

The Boomerang Effect occurs when an individual strongly rejects a persuasive message that is perceived as too extreme, often moving their opinion in the opposite direction. While this provides a natural defense against radicalization in MAS, it introduces significant energy and control overhead. In physical systems like robot swarms, this "repulsion" leads to over-corrections, resulting in high "opinion evolution cost"—the control effort required to reach a target state. The challenge lies in maintaining resilience to malice without incurring prohibitive evolution costs.

Methodology

The researchers propose an Adversarial Fusion Rule that mathematically models this repulsion. To optimize the system, they utilize the Parametric Discrete-time Algebraic Riccati Equation (PDARE) to quantify the evolution cost.

The core innovation is a Cost-Aware Rate Adjustment mechanism (Algorithm 2) that adaptively tunes the evolution rate ($\gamma$). This allows the system to effectively "slow down" during periods of high malicious influence, providing time to identify and isolate bad actors without committing high-energy moves toward a false consensus. A "Peak Clipping" method (Algorithm 1) is further employed to ensure system stability during these rate transitions, preventing the robots from spiraling out of control due to rapid changes in their update frequency.

Experimental Results

The framework was validated using a simulated swarm of 10 robots, including a majority of malicious agents (6 malicious vs. 4 normal). The results demonstrate that the adaptive mechanism successfully drives the system toward the correct consensus despite heavy adversarial presence.

Figure 3: Agent opinion convergence under the proposed cost-aware mechanism, showing all agents eventually reaching the target state despite initial malicious interference.

Crucially, the proposed approach significantly reduces the energy footprint of the consensus process. In simulations, baseline models without cost-awareness exhibited high, sustained input costs (peaking around 1.1 units). In contrast, the adaptive algorithm minimized the peak cost (to approximately 0.065 units) and allowed it to drop toward zero as malicious agents were neutralized and isolated from the network.

Figure 5: Opinion evolution input cost over time using the adaptive rate adjustment, demonstrating a significant reduction in total control effort compared to fixed-rate baselines.

As noted in the study's performance benchmarks, the "Time-varying Period" approach achieved convergence nearly as fast as aggressive fixed-rate models but with only a fraction of the early-stage cost (1.11 vs. 5.00 units).

Conclusion

By integrating sociological insights with control theory, this research provides a robust method for MAS to resist malicious influence efficiently. The trade-off between security and energy consumption is managed through adaptive rate adjustment, ensuring that resilience does not come at the expense of system longevity. While the current model assumes a basic detection mechanism for flagging extreme opinions, future work will explore defenses against "stealthy" malicious agents and the application of these dynamics to Large Language Model (LLM)-based agent societies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{suo2024opinion,
  author = {Yuhan Suo and Runqi Chai and Senchun Chai and Ishrak MD Farhan and Xudong Zhao and Yuanqing Xia},
  title = {{Opinion Dynamic Under Malicious Agent Influence in Multi-Agent Systems: From the Perspective of Opinion Evolution Cost}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2412.01524},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.01524},
}
Figure