Introduction
Open tibial shaft fractures represent a significant challenge in pediatric orthopedics. These injuries, characterized by bone exposure through a skin wound, necessitate a careful balance between achieving mechanical stability and managing soft tissue integrity to prevent infection. Historically, the External Fixator (EF) has been considered the "gold standard" for stabilizing these fractures, particularly in Gustilo-Anderson (GA) grade II and IIIA cases. However, EF is frequently associated with complications such as pin tract infections (PTI) and refractures following hardware removal.
In recent years, Elastic Stable Intramedullary Nail (ESIN) has emerged as a potential alternative. While ESIN is widely used for closed fractures, its application in open fractures has been a subject of debate due to concerns about internalizing hardware in a potentially contaminated environment. This study retrospectively compares the clinical outcomes of EF and ESIN in children with GA grade II and IIIA open tibial shaft fractures.
Comparative Study Design
The researchers analyzed 92 pediatric patients (aged 5–11 years) treated at Wuhan Union Hospital between 2008 and 2018. The cohort was divided into two groups: 55 patients treated with EF and 37 patients treated with ESIN. The study specifically focused on Gustilo-Anderson grade II and IIIA fractures, excluding the most severe grade IIIB/C injuries, as well as patients with metabolic disorders or those weighing over 50kg.
The EF group received hybrid external fixators, while the ESIN group underwent aggressive wound debridement followed by the insertion of flexible titanium or steel nails into the medullary canal. Post-operative care for both groups included standardized antibiotic protocols and monitoring for radiological union, alignment, and complications.
Clinical Outcomes
The study revealed several significant advantages for the ESIN group across multiple clinical metrics:
1. Accelerated Healing
Radiological union—the point at which the bone has sufficiently knitted back together—was achieved significantly faster in the ESIN group. Patients treated with ESIN healed in an average of 7.0 ± 0.9 weeks, compared to 9.0 ± 2.2 weeks for the EF group ($P < 0.001$). The authors attribute this to the "micro-motion" allowed by flexible nails, which stimulates callus formation more effectively than the rigid stabilization provided by an external frame.
2. Reduced Infection Rates
Despite concerns about internal fixation in open wounds, the ESIN group demonstrated a much lower rate of superficial infection (5.4%) compared to the EF group (36.3%). In EF treatment, the pins remain exposed to the environment for months, serving as potential conduits for bacteria. In contrast, once the initial surgical wound heals in ESIN patients, the hardware is entirely internal, reducing the long-term risk of contamination.
3. Superior Alignment and Stability
Alignment outcomes also favored ESIN. The limb length discrepancy (LLD) was significantly lower in the ESIN group (7.3 mm) than in the EF group (12.1 mm). Furthermore, the EF group exhibited higher residual angulation in both coronal and sagittal planes. This suggests that ESIN provides more consistent long-term structural maintenance in active pediatric patients.
Complications and Safety
The safety profile of the two procedures highlighted different trade-offs. The EF group suffered from three cases of refracture after the hardware was removed, a complication not seen in the ESIN group. This is often linked to the "stress shielding" effect of rigid external frames, which can lead to weaker bone structure at the fracture site.
However, ESIN was not without its own specific complication: implant prominence. Approximately 16% of ESIN patients experienced skin irritation or discomfort where the nail ends were tucked near the joint. This issue was absent in the EF group but is generally considered a minor complication that is resolved upon hardware removal.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings of this study suggest that ESIN is not only a viable alternative but may be the superior choice for GA grade II and IIIA open tibial fractures in children. By promoting faster biological healing through controlled micro-motion and significantly reducing the risk of persistent pin-tract infections, ESIN addresses the primary drawbacks of traditional external fixation.
While the retrospective nature of the study and the specific age/weight constraints of the cohort are limitations, the data provides a compelling argument for the use of internal flexible nailing in moderate-to-severe open pediatric fractures. Future prospective trials could further validate these results and explore the economic impact of reduced healing times and lower infection rates.
In conclusion, for selected pediatric patients, ESIN offers a more efficient recovery path with fewer significant complications than the traditional external fixator.
Summary updated