Operative Choice for Length-Unstable Femoral Shaft Fracture in School-Aged Children: Locking Plate vs. Monolateral External Fixator

Hong Pan, Saroj Rai, Xin Tang, Ruikang Liu, Jin LiFrontiers in Pediatrics 2022 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Pediatrics, compares two common surgical treatments for "length-unstable" femoral shaft fractures in children: locking plates (LP) and monolateral external fixators (EF). While both methods yield satisfactory functional results, the research highlights a trade-off between the surgical efficiency of external fixators and the superior anatomical alignment provided by locking plates.

TL;DR

Researchers compared locking plates and external fixators for treating unstable thigh bone fractures in school-aged children. They found that while locking plates offer better alignment and higher "excellent" functional scores, external fixators significantly reduce operative time and radiation exposure while avoiding the need for a second major surgery to remove hardware.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pediatric femoral shaft (thigh bone) fractures are common, but "length-unstable" varieties—those that are highly fragmented (comminuted) or have long, slanted break lines—pose a specific challenge. These fractures are prone to shortening or overlapping if not properly stabilized.

While Elastic Stable Intramedullary Nailing (ESIN) is a standard for many pediatric fractures, it often lacks the stability required for these unstable types. Surgeons typically choose between Locking Plates (LP), which are screwed directly onto the bone, and External Fixators (EF), where pins are inserted through the skin into the bone and connected to an external frame. The "gap" this paper addresses is the lack of clear comparative data on which of these two methods provides better clinical outcomes and fewer complications for children aged 5–11.

Methods

The authors conducted a retrospective review of 71 patients (aged 5–11) treated at their institute between 2014 and 2018.

  • LP Group (36 patients): Received submuscular locking plates. These plates are usually removed 9–12 months later via a second surgery under general anesthesia.
  • EF Group (35 patients): Received monolateral external fixators. These frames are typically removed in an outpatient setting 6–12 weeks after the initial surgery, without requiring a second major operation.

The study measured operative time, fluoroscopy (X-ray) frequency, length of hospital stay, complications (like limb length discrepancy and angulation), and functional outcomes using the Flynn scoring system.

Datasets

This was a clinical study based on a retrospective cohort from the hospital database of the Union Hospital, Tongji Medical College in Wuhan, China. No external or public machine learning datasets were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Second Trauma" Factor: A major advantage of the External Fixator is that it can be removed in a clinic setting. Locking plates require a second surgery under general anesthesia, which carries risks of hemorrhage, infection, and psychological stress for the child.
  • Efficiency vs. Precision: The EF procedure is significantly faster and requires less radiation, making it a "leaner" surgical choice. However, the LP group achieved better anatomical results, with less limb length discrepancy (LLD) and better angular alignment.
  • Functional Parity: Despite the differences in alignment and surgical complexity, 100% of patients in both groups achieved "Satisfactory" or "Excellent" functional outcomes. This suggests that the human body (especially in children) is remarkably resilient to minor misalignments.
  • Age Matters: The authors suggest that for older, heavier teenagers, locking plates might be superior because they handle weight-bearing better and don't require the daily pin-site care that external fixators demand.

Key Results

  • Surgical Speed: The EF group had significantly shorter operative times (45.4 min vs. 67.8 min for LP).
  • Radiation Exposure: The EF group required fewer fluoroscopy shots (13.9 vs. 16.5 for LP).
  • Alignment: The LP group showed superior results in preventing limb length discrepancy (7.5 mm vs. 11.2 mm for EF) and had lower degrees of frontal and sagittal angulation.
  • Flynn Scores: While both groups were successful, the LP group had a higher rate of "Excellent" scores (83.3%) compared to the EF group (54.3%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Study Design: As a retrospective study with a relatively small sample size (71 patients), there is a risk of allocation bias (surgeons may have chosen one method over the other based on personal preference).
  • Follow-up Duration: The 18-month follow-up may not be long enough to capture the full impact of "skeletal overgrowth," a phenomenon where a fractured bone grows faster than the uninjured side over several years.
  • Scope: The study did not include other emerging treatments, such as combining ESIN with external fixation.

Future research involving larger, randomized controlled trials is needed to definitively establish a "gold standard" for this specific fracture type.

Summary updated

Abstract

Both LP and EF produce satisfactory outcomes in school-aged children with length unstable femoral shaft fractures. External fixation remains a viable choice without the necessity of secondary surgery for hardware removal.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pan2022operative,
  author = {Hong Pan and Saroj Rai and Xin Tang and Ruikang Liu and Jin Li},
  title = {{Operative Choice for Length-Unstable Femoral Shaft Fracture in School-Aged Children: Locking Plate vs. Monolateral External Fixator}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pediatrics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fped.2021.799487},
}
Figure