Operative Choice for Displaced Proximal Humeral Fractures in Adolescents with Open Visible Physis: A Comparative Study of External Fixator vs. Kirschner Wire

Hong Pan, Saroj Rai, Huabing Qian, Ruikang Liu, Jin LiResearch Square 2020 · DOI

This retrospective study compares two surgical methods for treating severe shoulder fractures in adolescents: External Fixators (EF) and Kirschner wires (KW). The researchers found that while both methods lead to excellent functional recovery, the External Fixator approach is significantly faster, requires less radiation exposure, and avoids the need for invasive open surgery.

TL;DR

For adolescents with displaced proximal humeral fractures, using an external fixator is more efficient and less invasive than traditional Kirschner wiring. It offers shorter operative times and a 0% rate of open reduction while achieving comparable long-term shoulder function.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proximal humeral fractures (PHF)—fractures near the top of the arm bone—are relatively rare in children, accounting for less than 3% of pediatric fractures. Because younger children have incredible "remodeling potential" (the ability of growing bone to straighten itself out over time), most of these injuries are treated without surgery.

However, adolescents (ages 12–16) present a unique challenge. They have less remaining growth time for natural remodeling, yet they often have high physical demands due to sports. For severely displaced fractures in this age group, surgery is often necessary to ensure the shoulder regains its full range of motion. The standard "gold weight" has long been Kirschner wires (KW), which are cost-effective but can be difficult to manipulate and sometimes require opening the joint surgically (Open Reduction Internal Fixation, or ORIF) to achieve proper alignment. This paper investigates whether External Fixators (EF)—frames that sit outside the skin—offer a better alternative.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective study of 75 adolescent patients (ages 12–16) treated at Wuhan Union Hospital between 2008 and 2016. All patients had "open visible physis," meaning their growth plates had not yet fused.

  • The EF Group (35 patients): Surgeons used threaded Schanz pins and a "joystick technique" to manipulate bone fragments into place under fluoroscopy (real-time X-ray) before connecting them to an external frame.
  • The KW Group (40 patients): Surgeons attempted closed reduction (moving the bone without cutting the skin) followed by retrograde pinning. If the bone couldn't be aligned this way, they performed an open surgical approach (ORIF).

The team measured operative time, radiation frequency, the rate of open surgery, and functional outcomes using the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score at a 12-month follow-up.

Datasets

The study utilized a clinical dataset of 75 pediatric patients from the hospital’s database. Patients were classified using the Neer-Horwitz classification system, which grades the severity of displacement in humeral epiphyseal plate fractures. No external or public benchmarks were used, as this is a clinical comparative study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Joystick" Advantage: The most significant insight is the mechanical advantage of the EF. Because Schanz screws are threaded and sturdier than smooth K-wires, surgeons can use them like joysticks to precisely "steer" bone fragments into place. This explains why 0% of the EF group required open surgery, compared to 35% of the KW group.
  • Physis Preservation: In the EF group, pins did not need to penetrate the growth plate (physis) to achieve stability. This reduces the theoretical risk of iatrogenic (doctor-induced) growth disturbances, a major concern in pediatric orthopedics.
  • Efficiency and Safety: The EF method was not just more successful at avoiding open cuts; it was faster and reduced radiation exposure for both the patient and the surgical team.

Key Results

The quantitative data strongly favored the External Fixator:

  • Operative Time: EF procedures averaged 42.4 minutes, significantly faster than the 54 minutes required for KW (P < 0.001).
  • Radiation Exposure: The EF group required fewer fluoroscopy shots (12 vs. 17, P < 0.001).
  • Surgical Invasiveness: While 14 patients (35%) in the KW group required open surgery (ORIF), zero patients in the EF group required it.
  • Functional Outcomes: At the 12-month mark, both groups showed nearly identical shoulder function (ASES scores of 93.6 vs. 93.7), proving that the faster EF method does not compromise recovery.
  • Complications: There were no cases of nonunion or malunion in either group. Both groups experienced similar rates of minor pin-site infections (~37%), which were managed without major surgery.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Retrospective Nature: This was not a randomized controlled trial; the choice of hardware was left to the surgeon's preference, which could introduce bias.
  2. Sample Size: While 75 patients is substantial for this specific injury, larger multicenter studies would provide more robust data.
  3. Cost Analysis: External fixators are generally more expensive than K-wires. The authors suggest that future research should include a formal cost-benefit analysis to see if the shorter operative time and lack of open surgery offset the higher hardware costs.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold> For adolescents of severely displaced proximal humeral fracture (PHF), surgery is a good choice yielding excellent outcomes. Kirchner wire (KW) is a cost-effective choice for fixation, and this study aims to compare the clinical outcomes of external fixator (EF) vs. KW for the treatment of PHF in adolescents. To the best of our knowledge, it is the first report on external fixator for PHF in children and adolescents.<bold>Methods: </bold>Patients of PHF operated in our institute, from January 2008 to January 2016, were reviewed retrospectively. Demographic data, including sex, age at the time of surgery, operated side, and hardware choice, were collected from the hospital database. Preoperative radiographs were reviewed and classified according to Neer-Horwitz classification. Shoulder function was evaluated during 12<sup>th</sup> month follow-up using rating scale of the American shoulder and elbow surgeons (ASES). Complications, including infection, malunion, nonunion, stiffness of the shoulder joint, and failure of fixation were also recorded.<bold>Results: </bold>Thirty-five patients, including 23 males and 12 females, were included in the EF group, whereas 40 patients, including 25 males and 15 females, were included in the KW group (P = 0.867). The average age of patients in the EF group was 13.3 ± 1.7 years, and that of KW was 13.6 ± 1.8 years (P = 0.409). Patients in both groups were followed-up for at least 12 months. The operative time in the EF group (42.4 ± 11.2, min) was significantly shorter than those in the KW group (54 ± 13.6, min), P &lt; 0.001. The frequency of fluoroscopy in the EF group (12 ± 2.4) was significantly less than those in the KW group (17 ± 2.8), P &lt; 0.001. The rate of open reduction was significantly higher in KW (35%) group than those in the EF group (0%), P &lt; 0.001. There was no nonunion, malunion cases in both groups.<bold>Conclusion: </bold>External fixator is superior to Kirschner wire in the treatment of proximal humeral fractures in adolescents with shorter operative time, lower rate of ORIF and comparable clinical outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pan2020operative,
  author = {Hong Pan and Saroj Rai and Huabing Qian and Ruikang Liu and Jin Li},
  title = {{Operative Choice for Displaced Proximal Humeral Fractures in Adolescents with Open Visible Physis: A Comparative Study of External Fixator vs. Kirschner Wire}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-33678/v1},
}
Figure