TL;DR
This paper introduces an extended Continuous Scanning Laser Doppler Vibrometry (CSLDV) technique to accurately measure the operational deflection shapes (ODSs) of bladed disks, which are notoriously difficult to analyze due to their discontinuous surfaces. By developing a novel scanning path and a phase identification method, the researchers can efficiently reconstruct the complete ODS of the entire bladed disk, overcoming limitations of traditional methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Bladed disks are critical components in rotating machinery like aeroengines and turbines. Understanding their dynamic behavior, specifically their operational deflection shapes (ODSs), is crucial for preventing vibration-induced cracks and failures. Traditional methods for measuring ODSs, such as manual point-by-point laser Doppler vibrometry (LDV), are time-consuming and labor-intensive, especially for complex geometries. While Continuous Scanning Laser Doppler Vibrometry (CSLDV) offers a faster, full-field measurement approach, it's primarily designed for continuous surfaces. Bladed disks, with their distinct blades and gaps, present a challenge: a continuous scan can lead to laser leakage and invalid data, compromising accuracy. Furthermore, existing CSLDV methods struggle to determine the relative vibration phases between individual blades, making it impossible to reconstruct the complete ODS of the entire bladed disk assembly. This paper aims to bridge this gap by adapting CSLDV for bladed disks and developing a method to accurately capture their full ODS.
Methods
The core innovation lies in extending the CSLDV technique to handle the discontinuous nature of bladed disks.
- Extended CSLDV with Custom Scanning Path: The authors designed a specific continuous scanning path that precisely follows the contours of the bladed disk, including the fan-shaped blades. This path is generated using sinusoidal trajectories and adjusted for each blade by modifying the initial phase angle. This ensures the laser stays on the structure, minimizing invalid data.
- Phase Identification Method: To overcome the challenge of determining relative vibration phases between blades, the researchers proposed a method based on Operational Deflection Shape Frequency Response Functions (ODS FRFs). This involves:
- Selecting a fixed reference point on the bladed disk.
- Using two laser beams to simultaneously measure the response at the reference point and at corresponding measurement points on each blade.
- Calculating the ODS FRF, which captures both amplitude and phase information relative to the reference point. This method is particularly useful when the excitation source is unknown, a common scenario for rotating machinery.
- ODS Reconstruction: By combining the individual blade ODSs obtained from the extended CSLDV measurements with the relative phase information derived from the ODS FRF method, the complete ODS of the entire bladed disk is reconstructed.
Datasets
The paper utilizes a 16-blade disk as the experimental subject. The authors also compare their results with a finite element model (FEM) of a single sector of the bladed disk. No specific external datasets were used for training or evaluation; the data was generated through their experimental setup.
Key Insights and Ideas
- CSLDV is Adaptable: The study demonstrates that CSLDV, traditionally used for continuous surfaces, can be effectively adapted for complex, discontinuous structures like bladed disks with careful path planning.
- Phase is Key for Assembly ODS: Simply measuring individual blade ODSs is insufficient. The relative phase information between blades is critical for reconstructing the overall dynamic behavior of the entire bladed disk assembly.
- ODS FRF for Phase: The ODS FRF method provides a robust way to extract relative vibration phases, even when the excitation source is not precisely known, which is a significant advantage for real-world rotating machinery.
- Efficiency Gain: The proposed method offers a substantial time saving compared to traditional discrete point measurements, making ODS analysis more practical.
Key Results
- The extended CSLDV method successfully measured the ODSs of individual blades of a 16-blade disk.
- The phase identification method using ODS FRF accurately determined the relative vibration phases between blades.
- The reconstructed ODS of the whole-bladed disk showed high consistency with a finite element model, with a Modal Assurance Criterion (MAC) value of 0.91.
- The entire measurement and reconstruction process using the proposed CSLDV method took only a few minutes, a significant improvement over the approximately 3 hours required for a conventional SLDV approach with a comparable number of measurement points.
Limitations and Future Work
- Boundary Conditions in FEM: The authors note that discrepancies between their experimental results and the FEM are partly attributed to the FEM's boundary conditions not perfectly matching the actual experimental setup.
- Two Laser Beams: The phase identification method requires two laser beams to simultaneously measure the reference and measurement points. While effective, this adds complexity to the experimental setup.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that the ODS FRF method, being applicable even with unknown excitation, is particularly promising for the ODS measurement of rotating bladed disks operating at high speeds where excitation is difficult to measure. Further application and validation of this method in real-world rotating scenarios would be a logical next step.
Summary updated