Operating experience and typical cases of Rare Metals: Power of young editorial board members

Shuang Qiao, Wen Ma, Ning Zhao, Ziyue Xu, Qinghe HuangEditing 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the strategies employed by the journal Rare Metals to enhance its academic influence and global standing. It highlights the crucial role of engaging young scientists and expanding the journal's scope to encompass emerging frontier areas in materials science.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, despite being a major contributor to scientific research, faces a challenge in establishing internationally influential scientific journals. Many high-quality research papers are published in foreign journals, limiting China's publishing rights and global academic voice. To address this, there's an urgent need to cultivate world-class scientific and technological journals within China. Rare Metals, a journal focusing on rare metals and their applications, shares its journey and strategies for improving its quality, influence, and competitiveness in this landscape.

Methods

The paper outlines several key strategies implemented by Rare Metals:

  • Targeting Young Scientists: Actively recruiting and engaging young editorial board members (under 45) who possess strong research capabilities and a willingness to contribute. This involves global open recruitment, regular communication, and performance assessment.
  • Expanding Scope to Frontier Areas: Moving beyond the traditional definition of "rare metals" to encompass "advanced, innovative, essential, and nonferrous related materials and applications." This involves identifying and focusing on emerging fields like energy storage, catalysis, and two-dimensional materials.
  • Organizing Special Issues and Topics: Strategically planning and executing special issues and thematic topics to showcase academic progress in specific, cutting-edge areas and attract high-quality submissions.
  • Enhancing Service and Promotion: Leveraging young editorial board members for active promotion of the journal at academic conferences through various materials and initiatives, including promotional videos, leaflets, and even custom playing cards.
  • Strengthening Content Quality: Emphasizing the importance of academic quality as the journal's lifeblood, employing academic editors for pre-screening, and maintaining a high manuscript return rate for peer review.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Youth: Young editorial board members are not just contributors but active drivers of journal development, bringing fresh perspectives, energy, and a willingness to promote the journal.
  • Adaptability is Key: To remain relevant and influential, journals must be willing to redefine their scope and embrace emerging, interdisciplinary fields, rather than sticking to rigid, traditional definitions.
  • Strategic Thematic Focus: Special issues and curated topics are powerful tools for showcasing a journal's strengths, attracting high-impact research, and increasing overall academic influence.
  • Proactive Promotion Matters: Simply publishing good research isn't enough; journals need to actively engage in promotion and outreach to increase their visibility and impact.
  • Quality as the Foundation: Despite all efforts in promotion and scope expansion, the core quality of published research remains paramount for long-term success.

Key Results

  • The journal's impact factor has steadily increased over the past decade, reaching 8.8 in 2022, ranking fourth in its field.
  • Rare Metals is indexed in major international databases like SCIE, EI, CAS, and SCOPUS.
  • The number of published articles has doubled between 2015-2016 and 2021-2022, reflecting an expanded scope.
  • The journal has received numerous accolades, including being part of the "China Science and Technology Journal Excellence Action Plan" and being recognized as a "Top 100 Newspapers and Periodicals."
  • A specific case highlighted is the rapid publication of a breakthrough paper on nickel-based superconducting materials, which was published within a month of submission and quickly garnered citations.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper primarily focuses on the strategies and experiences of Rare Metals. While it provides a strong case study, the generalizability of these specific methods to all journals might vary. Future work could involve comparative studies with other journals or more in-depth quantitative analysis of the impact of each specific strategy. The authors aim to continue strengthening content construction, actively promoting special issues, and further improving the journal's impact to become a leading platform for rare metal science and technology globally.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an English-language science and technology journal reporting the research of rare metals and their compounds, Rare Metals has always adhered to the tenet of “publication quality is the core, content is the key, and enhancement of influence is the goal”. It focuses on new energy, new materials, and other cutting-edge and interdisciplinary fields of rare metals that are “oriented to the world‘s scientific and technological frontiers and the country’s major needs”. Rare Metals has built a high-end academic exchange platform by publishing high-level papers. After more than 40 years of development, Rare Metals has continuously explored and practiced on the path of being a first-class scientific and technological journal and a first-class academic platform. The influence of the journal has been continuously increasing. This article is based on the journal itself, introducing the experience of the journal publication and relevant classic cases to provide reference for peers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiao2023operating,
  author = {Shuang Qiao and Wen Ma and Ning Zhao and Ziyue Xu and Qinghe Huang},
  title = {{Operating experience and typical cases of Rare Metals: Power of young editorial board members}},
  booktitle = {Editing},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.54844/ep.2023.0504},
}
Figure