Open Development and Clinical Validation Of Multiple 3D-Printed Sample-Collection Swabs: Rapid Resolution of a Critical COVID-19 Testing Bottleneck

Cody Callahan, Rose Lee, Katelyn E. Zulauf, Lauren Tamburello, Kenny Smith, Joe Previtera, Annie Cheng, Alexander L. Green, Ahmed Abdul Azim, Amanda Yano, Nancy Doraiswami, James E. Kirby, Ramy ArnaoutmedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic caused a severe international shortage of nasopharyngeal (NP) swabs, creating a critical bottleneck for high-sensitivity virological testing. To address this, we executed a radically cooperative, rapid-response translational-research program involving healthcare workers, manufacturers, and scientists to develop and clinically validate 3D-printed swabs. We performed preclinical evaluations on 160 designs and 48 materials, sharing results via a public repository. Four prototypes were validated through an IRB-approved clinical trial with 276 volunteers. All prototypes showed excellent concordance with standard flocked swabs (κ=0.85-0.89) and non-inferiority in cycle-threshold (Ct) values (MWU p>0.05). The transition from problem identification to clinical validation took only 22 days, offering a model for rapid technology deployment during a crisis.

Introduction

Early in the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, the global supply chain for nasopharyngeal (NP) swabs—the "gold standard" for specimen collection—collapsed. Traditional NP swabs are complex to manufacture, typically requiring a "flocking" process where synthetic fibers are glued to a plastic tip. This specialized process became a primary bottleneck in expanding COVID-19 testing capacity.

To bypass this bottleneck, our team investigated 3D printing as a means to create complex, high-surface-area geometries in a single manufacturing step. However, medical-grade swabs must meet rigorous standards: they must be flexible enough to navigate the nasal cavity without fracturing, capable of absorbing sufficient viral material, and chemically inert to avoid inhibiting Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) assays.

Methodology

We established a three-phase translational-research pipeline to move from concept to clinical use rapidly:

  1. Phase I (Preclinical Evaluation): 160 designs and 48 materials from 24 different entities were vetted. Testing included mechanical stress (bending 90° without failure), collection efficiency (using Gram stains of cheek cells as a proxy), and PCR compatibility to ensure resins did not interfere with viral detection.
  2. Phase II (Production and Scalability): Successful prototypes were tested for autoclave stability (sterilization) and the manufacturer's ability to scale production to a minimum of 10,000 swabs per day.
  3. Phase III (Clinical Validation): An IRB-approved trial was conducted with 276 symptomatic volunteers at a drive-through testing center. Each participant received a standard control swab and a 3D-printed prototype to compare SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR results.

Central to this methodology was the Covidswab Repository, a public GitHub database where we shared high-resolution images and performance data in real-time, allowing manufacturers to iterate designs based on immediate clinical feedback.

Key Insights

Radically Cooperative Development

By treating medical hardware development like an open-source software project, we nucleated a network of 24 manufacturers and laboratories. This approach allowed for unprecedented speed, including 28 iterations of a single prototype in less than a month.

Geometry vs. Flocking

This study demonstrated that the traditional "flocked" tip is not a requirement for effective viral collection. 3D-printed lattices, polygonal matrices, and spiral designs provided sufficient surface area to collect diagnostic-quality samples, proving that geometric innovation can replace complex material processes.

Non-Inferiority Framework

In a public health crisis, the objective for new tools is often non-inferiority rather than superiority. By focusing on proving that 3D-printed swabs were "not significantly worse" than the gold standard, we cleared a pragmatic path for emergency use authorization.

Results

Four prototypes—developed by Resolution Medical/Carbon3D, EnvisionTec, Origin.io, and HP Inc.—successfully passed all validation phases.

  • High Concordance: The 3D-printed swabs showed excellent agreement with control swabs, with Cohen’s kappa values ranging from 0.85 to 0.89.
  • Viral Load Consistency: There was no statistically significant difference in Cycle threshold (Ct) values between the prototypes and the controls (Mann-Whitney U p > 0.05), indicating consistent viral load recovery.
  • Rapid Deployment: The total time elapsed from identifying the shortage to validating the first prototype was 22 days.
  • User Preference: Interestingly, clinical staff preferred one of the 3D-printed prototypes (Prototype 4) over the standard control swab regarding ease of use and perceived collection quality.

Discussion and Limitations

While the program was a success, several factors must be considered for future applications. The clinical trial utilized a "first-swab" protocol where the control was always administered first, potentially depleting material for the second (prototype) swab; however, statistical analysis suggested this did not skew the results. Additionally, while 3D printing solved the immediate crisis, the long-term viability of these swabs compared to emerging high-volume injection-molded designs remains to be seen.

Our experience demonstrates that open-source collaboration and rapid clinical validation can effectively resolve critical medical supply chain failures during a global health emergency.

Summary updated

Abstract

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has caused a severe international shortage of the nasopharyngeal swabs that are required for collection of optimal specimens, creating a critical bottleneck in the way of high-sensitivity virological testing for COVID-19. To address this crisis, we designed and executed an innovative, radically cooperative, rapid-response translational-research program that brought together healthcare workers, manufacturers, and scientists to emergently develop and clinically validate new swabs for immediate mass production by 3D printing. We performed a rigorous multi-step preclinical evaluation on 160 swab designs and 48 materials from 24 companies, laboratories, and individuals, and shared results and other feedback via a public data repository (http://github.com/rarnaout/Covidswab/). We validated four prototypes through an institutional review board (IRB)-approved clinical trial that involved 276 outpatient volunteers who presented to our hospital's drive-through testing center with symptoms suspicious for COVID-19. Each participant was swabbed with a reference swab (the control) and a prototype, and SARS-CoV-2 reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) results were compared. All prototypes displayed excellent concordance with the control (κ=0.85-0.89). Cycle-threshold (Ct) values were not significantly different between each prototype and the control, supporting the new swabs' non-inferiority (Mann-Whitney U [MWU] p>0.05). Study staff preferred one of the prototypes over the others and the control swab overall. The total time elapsed between identification of the problem and validation of the first prototype was 22 days. Contact information for ordering can be found at http://printedswabs.org. Our experience holds lessons for the rapid development, validation, and deployment of new technology for this pandemic and beyond.
BibTeX
@misc{callahan2020open,
  author = {Cody Callahan and Rose Lee and Katelyn E. Zulauf and Lauren Tamburello and Kenny Smith and Joe Previtera and Annie Cheng and Alexander L. Green and Ahmed Abdul Azim and Amanda Yano and Nancy Doraiswami and James E. Kirby and Ramy Arnaout},
  title = {{Open Development and Clinical Validation Of Multiple 3D-Printed Sample-Collection Swabs: Rapid Resolution of a Critical COVID-19 Testing Bottleneck}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.04.14.20065094},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure