Op18 reveals the contribution of nonkinetochore microtubules to the dynamic organization of the vertebrate meiotic spindle

Benjamin R. Houghtaling, Ge Yang, Alexandre Matov, Gaudenz Danuser, Tarun M. KapoorProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the role of non-kinetochore microtubules (non-kMTs) in vertebrate meiotic spindles, which are largely composed of these structures unlike their mitotic counterparts. By selectively depleting the "barrel" array of non-kMTs using Op18, researchers found that kinetochore microtubules (kMTs) still function, but with altered dynamics and increased chromosome oscillation, suggesting non-kMTs are crucial for stable chromosome positioning and spindle organization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate chromosome segregation during meiosis is critical for development, and this accuracy relies on the proper assembly and function of the meiotic spindle. While mitotic spindles have a relatively balanced mix of kinetochore microtubules (kMTs) and non-kinetochore microtubules (non-kMTs), vertebrate meiotic spindles are overwhelmingly dominated by non-kMTs, forming a prominent antiparallel "barrel" array at the spindle equator. The precise contribution of these non-kMTs to spindle organization and chromosome segregation has remained largely mysterious, despite the known importance of kMTs for chromosome attachment and movement. This paper aims to dissect the specific roles of the non-kMT barrel array by selectively perturbing it and observing the consequences for spindle dynamics and function.

Methods

The researchers utilized Xenopus laevis egg extracts to assemble meiotic spindles in vitro. Their primary experimental strategy involved manipulating the concentration of Op18/stathmin, a protein known to destabilize microtubules. By increasing Op18 levels, they aimed to selectively deplete the non-kMT barrel array.

Key techniques employed include:

  • Fluorescent Microscopy: Standard widefield and confocal microscopy were used to visualize spindle structures labeled with X-rhodamine tubulin and DNA.
  • Quantitative Fluorescent Speckle Microscopy (qFSM): This technique was crucial for observing the dynamic behavior of microtubules. By labeling tubulin with fluorescent speckles, researchers could track the movement and polymerization of individual microtubules.
  • EB1 Comet Tracking: EB1 is a protein that binds to the plus ends of growing microtubules. Tracking EB1 "comets" allowed the researchers to visualize and quantify microtubule polymerization dynamics, including their velocity and direction.
  • Kinetochore Labeling: An antibody against CENP-A was used to specifically label kinetochores, enabling the assessment of kMT attachments and interkinetochore tension.
  • Motor Protein Inhibition: The kinesin-5 inhibitor monastrol was used to investigate the role of this motor protein in spindle bipolarity and flux.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using in vitro assembled spindles from Xenopus laevis egg extracts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Op18 as a Selective Depleter: The study demonstrates that increasing Op18 concentration is a powerful tool to specifically reduce the non-kMT barrel array in meiotic spindles, without completely abolishing spindle structure or kMT function. This offers a way to probe the specific contributions of the barrel array.
  • Non-kMT Barrel's Role in Stability and Positioning: The absence of the barrel array leads to smaller spindles and increased chromosome oscillation, indicating that the barrel non-kMTs are essential for maintaining stable chromosome positioning and overall spindle size.
  • Kinesin-5's Non-Essential Role in Bipolarity Without the Barrel: Surprisingly, inhibiting kinesin-5, a protein typically required for spindle bipolarity, does not cause spindle collapse when the non-kMT barrel is absent. This suggests that the barrel array's interaction with kinesin-5 is critical for maintaining bipolarity in normal meiotic spindles.
  • Meiotic Spindles Resemble Mitotic Spindles Without the Barrel: The paper proposes that meiotic spindles lacking the barrel array become more akin to mitotic spindles, which rely on different mechanisms to maintain organization in the absence of extensive antiparallel microtubule overlap.

Key Results

  • Spindle Size Reduction: Increasing Op18 concentration led to a dose-dependent decrease in spindle size, with structures remaining stable at steady state.
  • KMT Dynamics Altered, Not Abolished: While kMTs continued to flux poleward in Op18-treated spindles, the flux rate was approximately 30% slower.
  • Increased Chromosome Oscillation: Despite maintained interkinetochore tension (a measure of kMT force), chromosomes oscillated more in Op18-treated spindles, suggesting that non-kMTs normally suppress these oscillations.
  • Kinesin-5 Inhibition Doesn't Affect Bipolarity in Op18-Treated Spindles: Spindles treated with excess Op18 maintained bipolarity even when kinesin-5 was inhibited, a stark contrast to control spindles which collapsed into monopolar structures.
  • Flux Rate Unaffected by Kinesin-5 Inhibition in Op18 Spindles: The poleward flux rate in spindles treated with both Op18 and a kinesin-5 inhibitor was similar to spindles treated with Op18 alone, further supporting the idea that kinesin-5's role in flux is primarily linked to the barrel array.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Op18 Depletion Specificity: While Op18 effectively reduced the barrel array, the paper acknowledges that other parameters of microtubule dynamics (e.g., minus-end depolymerization rates) were not directly measured, leaving room for subtle effects.
  • Antibody for Op18 Depletion: The authors note the lack of an antibody to directly deplete Op18, which would be useful for further investigating the dose-dependent relationship between Op18 and spindle size.
  • Mechanisms of Polar Array Stability: The stability of the polar non-kMT arrays in the absence of the barrel array is not fully explained and warrants further investigation.
  • Role in Suppressing Oscillations: The precise mechanism by which the barrel array suppresses chromosome oscillations needs further exploration.
  • Comparison to Mitotic Spindles: While a comparison is drawn, a direct experimental comparison of Op18-treated meiotic spindles to actual mitotic spindles could provide further validation.

The study opens avenues for exploring how the non-kMT barrel array contributes to the mechanical stability of the spindle and how it actively suppresses chromosome oscillations, potentially by generating forces on chromosome arms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accuracy in chromosome segregation depends on the assembly of a bipolar spindle. Unlike mitotic spindles, which have roughly equal amounts of kinetochore microtubules (kMTs) and nonkinetochore microtubules (non-kMTs), vertebrate meiotic spindles are predominantly comprised of non-kMTs, a large subset of which forms an antiparallel "barrel" array at the spindle equator. Though kMTs are needed to drive chromosome segregation, the contributions of non-kMTs are more mysterious. Here, we show that increasing the concentration of Op18/stathmin, a component of the chromosome-mediated microtubule formation pathway that directly controls microtubule dynamics, can be used to deplete non-kMTs in the vertebrate meiotic spindle assembled in Xenopus egg extracts. Under these conditions, kMTs and the spindle pole-associated non-kMT arrays persist in smaller spindles. In excess Op18, distances between sister kinetochores, an indicator of tension across centromeres, remain unchanged, even though kMTs flux poleward with a approximately 30% slower velocity, and chromosomes oscillate more than in control metaphase spindles. Remarkably, kinesin-5, a conserved motor protein that can push microtubules apart and is required for the assembly and maintenance of bipolar meiotic spindles, is not needed to maintain spindle bipolarity in the presence of excess Op18. Our data suggest that non-kMTs in meiotic spindles contribute to normal kMT dynamics, stable chromosome positioning, and the establishment of proper spindle size. We propose that without non-kMTs, metaphase meiotic spindles are similar to mammalian mitotic spindles, which balance forces to maintain metaphase spindle organization in the absence of extensive antiparallel microtubule overlap at the spindle equator or a key mitotic kinesin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{houghtaling2009op,
  author = {Benjamin R. Houghtaling and Ge Yang and Alexandre Matov and Gaudenz Danuser and Tarun M. Kapoor},
  title = {{Op18 reveals the contribution of nonkinetochore microtubules to the dynamic organization of the vertebrate meiotic spindle}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.0902317106},
}
Figure