Only the Fastest Corticospinal Fibers Contribute to β Corticomuscular Coherence

Jaime Ibáñez, Alessandro Del Vecchio, John C. Rothwell, Stuart N. Baker, Dario FarinaJournal of Neuroscience 2021 · DOI

Abstract

A common way to study human corticospinal transmission is with transcranial magnetic stimulation. However, this is biased to activity in the fastest conducting axons. It is unclear whether conclusions obtained in this context are representative of volitional activity in mild-to-moderate contractions. A possible alternative to overcome this limitation is to study the corticospinal transmission of endogenously generated brain activity. Here we study the transmission speeds of cortical beta rhythms travelling to the muscles during steady contractions. To do this, we introduce new methods to improve delay estimates in the corticomuscular transmission of beta rhythms, and which we validate both in simulations and experimentally. Applying these approaches to experimental data from humans, we show that corticomuscular beta transmission delays are only 1-2ms longer than expected from the fastest corticospinal pathway. Simulations using realistic distributions of the conduction velocities for descending axons projecting to lower motoneurons suggest two scenarios that can explain these results: either a very small fraction of only the fastest corticospinal axons selectively transmit beta activity, or else the entire pool does. The implications that these two scenarios have for our understanding of corticomuscular interactions are discussed in the final part of this manuscript.

Introduction

The human corticospinal tract—the primary neural pathway connecting the motor cortex to the spinal cord—comprises a diverse bundle of axons with varying diameters and conduction velocities. While Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) has been a staple for studying this pathway, it is inherently biased toward the largest, fastest-conducting fibers. It has remained unclear whether the brain’s endogenous, volitional signals, such as the 15-30 Hz "beta" oscillations observed during steady muscle contractions, utilize these same high-speed channels or are distributed across the slower fibers that constitute the majority of the tract.

Previous attempts to measure "corticomuscular delay" using directed coherence often yielded highly variable results, suggesting delays significantly longer than physical limits. This study investigates whether these discrepancies arise from biological reality or methodological artifacts, introducing refined techniques to measure the transmission speed of cortical beta rhythms.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers employed a multi-modal approach combining high-density recordings with advanced signal processing:

  1. High-Density EMG (HD-EMG) & Decomposition: To avoid the interference inherent in raw EMG, 64-channel electrode grids were placed on the tibialis anterior (shin muscle). These signals were decomposed into the firing patterns of individual Single Motor Units (SMUs), providing a high-fidelity representation of the neural drive.
  2. EEG Integration: Accounting for the fact that pyramidal neurons act as integrators, the researchers mathematically integrated the EEG signals to correct for a 90-degree ($\pi/2$) phase shift relative to neuronal firing.
  3. Time-Domain Analysis: Moving away from frequency-domain measures (like directed coherence), which can be unreliable for narrow-band signals, the team utilized cumulant density to identify precise correlation peaks in the time domain.
Experimental setup (B) and the signal processing model (A) used to estimate corticomuscular transmission delays.

The study involved 19 healthy subjects performing sustained ankle contractions. Additionally, a large-scale computational model of one million axons was developed, using anatomical data on human-scaled axon diameter distributions to simulate signal propagation and summation at the muscle.

Key Results

The refined methodology revealed that corticomuscular communication is remarkably efficient:

  • Ultra-Fast Transmission: The estimated delay from the motor cortex to the muscle was 28.6 ± 3.1 ms.
  • Minimal Latency Gap: This delay is only ~1.14 ms longer than the absolute fastest response evoked by a magnetic pulse (MEP latency), suggesting that beta oscillations are carried by the fastest 0.1% to 3% of the corticospinal tract.
  • Physical Correlation: Measured delays correlated significantly with subject height ($R = 0.651$), validating the method's accuracy in capturing physical travel time.
  • SMU Precision: Individual motor unit spikes provided more stable and accurate estimates than traditional raw EMG, which is often distorted by muscle fiber potential shapes.

Insights: The Cancellation Effect

A critical finding of the study concerns why the measured delay is so short. The computational model suggests two primary scenarios: either the brain selectively recruits only the fastest fibers for beta transmission, or the entire pool of axons carries the signal, but a "phase cancellation" mechanism occurs.

Schematic of the 'Cancellation Effect' model: beta rhythms are transmitted through axons of varying diameters, with slower signals potentially cancelling out at the summation point.

Because axons of different diameters have different conduction speeds, signals arriving via slower fibers are delayed relative to the fastest ones. For oscillatory signals like beta rhythms, these lagging signals can arrive out of phase, leading to destructive interference. Consequently, only the signal from the fastest fibers emerges clearly at the muscle level, effectively "ignoring" the slower components of the tract.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study demonstrates that beta corticomuscular coherence is mediated by the fastest available neural pathways. By correcting for the "math traps" of frequency-domain analysis and the phase shifts of cortical integration, the researchers aligned endogenous signal delays with the physical limits of the corticospinal tract.

While focused on the tibialis anterior, this methodology offers a potential biomarker for neurodegenerative diseases like ALS or stroke, where the degradation of large, fast-conducting neurons is a hallmark. Future research will explore whether these findings hold for muscles with more complex, polysynaptic cortical connections.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human corticospinal transmission is commonly studied using brain stimulation. However, this approach is biased to activity in the fastest conducting axons. It is unclear whether conclusions obtained in this context are representative of volitional activity in mild-to-moderate contractions. An alternative to overcome this limitation may be to study the corticospinal transmission of endogenously generated brain activity. Here, we investigate in humans (<i>N</i> = 19; of either sex), the transmission speeds of cortical β rhythms (∼20 Hz) traveling to arm (first dorsal interosseous) and leg (tibialis anterior; TA) muscles during tonic mild contractions. For this purpose, we propose two improvements for the estimation of corticomuscular β transmission delays. First, we show that the cumulant density (cross-covariance) is more accurate than the commonly-used directed coherence to estimate transmission delays in bidirectional systems transmitting band-limited signals. Second, we show that when spiking motor unit activity is used instead of interference electromyography, corticomuscular transmission delay estimates are unaffected by the shapes of the motor unit action potentials (MUAPs). Applying these improvements, we show that descending corticomuscular β transmission is only 1-2 ms slower than expected from the fastest corticospinal pathways. In the last part of our work, we show results from simulations using estimated distributions of the conduction velocities for descending axons projecting to lower motoneurons (from macaque histologic measurements) to suggest two scenarios that can explain fast corticomuscular transmission: either only the fastest corticospinal axons selectively transmit β activity, or else the entire pool does. The implications of these two scenarios for our understanding of corticomuscular interactions are discussed.<b>SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT</b> We present and validate an improved methodology to measure the delay in the transmission of cortical β activity to tonically-active muscles. The estimated corticomuscular β transmission delays obtained with this approach are remarkably similar to those expected from transmission in the fastest corticospinal axons. A simulation of β transmission along a pool of corticospinal axons using an estimated distribution of fiber diameters suggests two possible mechanisms by which fast corticomuscular transmission is achieved: either a very small fraction of the fastest descending axons transmits β activity to the muscles or, alternatively, the entire population does and natural cancellation of slow channels occurs because of the distribution of axon diameters in the corticospinal tract.
BibTeX
@article{ibanez2021only,
  author = {Jaime Ibáñez and Alessandro Del Vecchio and John C. Rothwell and Stuart N. Baker and Dario Farina},
  title = {{Only the Fastest Corticospinal Fibers Contribute to β Corticomuscular Coherence}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.2908-20.2021},
}
Figure