Online IS Education for the 21st Century

Wu He, Guandong Xu, S. E. KruckJ. Inf. Syst. Educ 2014 · OpenReview

Abstract

This paper synthesizes the current state of online Information Systems (IS) pedagogy, drawing from a special issue of the Journal of Information Systems Education. It examines the transition from physical to digital classrooms, identifying a 10–20% higher attrition rate in online environments compared to face-to-face settings. By applying the Community of Inquiry (CoI) framework, the paper underscores the necessity of social, teaching, and cognitive presence. Furthermore, it explores the potential of Learning Management System (LMS) data mining as an "early warning system" to improve student retention and engagement.

Introduction

As of 2013, online learning has become a cornerstone of higher education strategy, with over 6.7 million students enrolled in at least one online course. For Information Systems (IS) and Information Technology (IT) departments, this shift represents more than a change in delivery medium; it is a fundamental evolution in how knowledge is constructed. Despite its growth, online education faces persistent challenges regarding quality, faculty readiness, and student retention.

EDSIG: Serving Information Systems Educators

The Challenges of Digital Transformation

The transition to online IS education is marked by three primary hurdles:

  1. The Quality Debate: Research remains divided on student performance parity between online and face-to-face (F2F) formats. While some meta-analyses show no significant difference, others suggest online students may even outperform their F2F peers under specific conditions.
  2. Faculty Readiness: Technical expertise in IS/IT does not automatically translate to proficiency in online instructional design. Many instructors are novices in the pedagogical nuances of digital environments.
  3. The Retention Gap: A critical concern is the consistently higher dropout rate—typically 10–20% higher than traditional classrooms—which remains the field's most significant challenge.

Theoretical Framework: The Community of Inquiry (CoI)

To address these challenges, the authors utilize the Community of Inquiry (CoI) framework. This model suggests that a successful online learning experience emerges from the intersection of three core elements:

  • Social Presence: The ability of learners to project their personal characteristics into the community, creating a sense of belonging. This is crucial for overcoming the isolation often felt in digital spaces.
  • Teaching Presence: The active design, facilitation, and direction of cognitive and social processes to realize learning outcomes. It involves the instructor's role in guiding the discourse and providing timely feedback.
  • Cognitive Presence: The extent to which learners can construct and confirm meaning through sustained reflection and discourse.

The paper argues that "interaction" alone does not equate to "learning." Without strong teaching presence to facilitate deep cognitive engagement, online discussions often lack the depth required for mastery, leading to "surface learning" rather than the deep understanding required in Information Systems.

Data-Driven Pedagogy and Early Warning Systems

A significant innovation discussed is the use of Learning Management System (LMS) data mining. By analyzing "back-end" interaction logs—such as login frequency, post counts, and click patterns—educators can build predictive models for student success.

  • The Predictive Power of Engagement: Participation in discussion boards is among the strongest predictors of final grades. Conversely, "lurking" (observing without participating) is a major risk factor for failure.
  • Anchored Discussions: Research indicates that "anchored" asynchronous discussions, where students link comments to specific document sections, improve self-efficacy and exam scores more effectively than traditional threaded forums.

Key Findings and Results

The synthesis of research within this special issue yields several critical insights for IS educators:

  • Enrollment and Strategy: By 2013, 32% of higher education students had taken at least one online course, and 69% of institutions viewed online learning as a core long-term strategy.
  • Performance Parity: Meta-analyses (e.g., Jahng et al., 2007) generally find no significant difference in achievement between online and F2F formats. Interestingly, some studies (Means et al., 2009) suggest that online students may perform slightly better on average, likely due to the increased time-on-task required in digital environments.
  • Mobile Frontiers: The development of smartphone apps for course access is identified as a critical technical frontier for increasing student engagement in an increasingly mobile world.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While online IS education offers immense potential, its success depends on intentional design rather than the medium itself. Future research must focus on refining Early Warning Systems using real-time data and developing robust faculty training programs. As the 10–20% retention gap persists, the integration of social, teaching, and cognitive presence remains the most viable path toward high-quality digital IS education.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{he2014online,
  author = {Wu He and Guandong Xu and S. E. Kruck},
  title = {{Online IS Education for the 21st Century}},
  journal = {J. Inf. Syst. Educ.},
  year = {2014},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ycBxm21VIE},
}
Figure