ONION: Physics-Informed Deep Learning Model for Line Integral Diagnostics Across Fusion Devices

Cong Wang, Weizhe Yang, Haiping Wang, Renjie Yang, Jing Li, Zhijun Wang, Xinyao Yu, Yixiong Wei, Xianli Huang, Zhaoyang Liu, Changqing Zou, Zhifeng ZhaoarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In nuclear fusion research, understanding the internal state of plasma—its "profile"—is critical for maintaining stability and achieving control. However, the interior of a tokamak cannot be observed directly. Instead, researchers rely on diagnostics like soft X-rays (SXR), which provide "line-integral" measurements. These measurements are essentially the sum of emissivity along various lines of sight across the plasma volume.

Soft X-ray (SXR) diagnostic geometries for the EAST (a) and HL-2A (b) tokamaks, showing the complex lines of sight used for line-integral measurements.

Traditionally, reconstructing a 2D image from these 1D sums requires complex inversion algorithms, such as Fourier-Bessel or Gaussian process tomography. While accurate, these methods are computationally expensive and far too slow for real-time reactor control. Standard deep learning models offer the necessary speed but are often "physics-blind," potentially producing results that violate the underlying geometric and physical principles of the diagnostic system.

The ONION Architecture

The authors propose the Onion model, a novel physics-informed deep learning architecture designed to bridge the gap between speed and physical fidelity. The model is named for its layered approach to integrating information through several key innovations:

  • Physical Information (PI) Side-Chain: The model incorporates a simplified VGG-style network to process the "response matrix," which contains the geometric path lengths of the diagnostic lines of sight.
  • Element-wise Multiplication Fusion: Rather than simple concatenation, the model uses element-wise multiplication to fuse physical features with the backbone network (e.g., VGG or ResNet). This approach better captures the multiplicative relationship between device geometry and measured signals.
  • Physics-Informed Loss Function (PILF): The loss function penalizes the model not just for pixel-wise differences from the target, but also for physical inconsistency. It performs a "back-projection" to calculate what the measurements should have been based on the predicted 2D profile, ensuring they match the actual inputs.
  • Softplus Activation: By replacing standard ReLU activation with Softplus in the final layers, the model ensures smooth, continuous, and strictly positive emissivity profiles, avoiding unphysical "jagged" edges.

Datasets and Validation

The model was validated using four distinct datasets covering both synthetic and experimental conditions from the EAST and HL-2A tokamaks. Synthetic datasets provided a perfectly known "ground truth," while experimental datasets tested the model's robustness against real-world noise and the inherent errors of traditional inversion codes used for labeling.

A sample 2D target plasma emissivity profile for the HL-2A tokamak, representing the ground truth for reconstruction tasks.

Key Results and Insights

The Onion model demonstrates significant improvements over physics-blind deep learning approaches:

  • Accuracy and Consistency: The inclusion of physical information reduced average relative error by approximately 52% on synthetic data. Crucially, the PILF reduced back-projection error by up to 85.4% in experimental cases, suggesting the model can sometimes surpass the quality of its own training labels by enforcing physical consistency.
  • Real-Time Performance: Running on an NVIDIA GPU, the model performs reconstructions in just 1–9 milliseconds. This is over 700 times faster than traditional inversion codes, making it a viable candidate for real-time feedback loops in fusion reactors.
  • Smoothness: The transition to Softplus activation was essential for reflecting the continuous nature of physical emissivity, preventing the "stepped" artifacts common in standard neural network outputs.

Future Directions

While highly effective, the current model does not yet account for measurement uncertainty or complex Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) phenomena like magnetic islands. Future work will focus on integrating more diverse physical knowledge and exploring "Mixture of Experts" (MOE) architectures to handle a wider variety of experimental discharge scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rapid reconstruction of 2D plasma profiles from line-integral measurements is important in nuclear fusion. This paper introduces a physics-informed model architecture called Onion, that can enhance the performance of models and be adapted to various backbone networks. The model under Onion incorporates physical information by a multiplication process and applies the physics-informed loss function according to the principle of line integration. Prediction results demonstrate that the additional input of physical information improves the deep learning model's ability, leading to a reduction in the average relative error E_1 between the reconstruction profiles and the target profiles by approximately 0.84x10^(-2) on synthetic datasets and about 0.06x10^(-2) on experimental datasets. Furthermore, the implementation of the Softplus activation function in the final two fully connected layers improves model performance. This enhancement results in a reduction in the E_1 by approximately 1.06x10^(-2) on synthetic datasets and about 0.11x10^(-2) on experimental datasets. The incorporation of the physics-informed loss function has been shown to correct the model's predictions, bringing the back-projections closer to the actual inputs and reducing the errors associated with inversion algorithms. Besides, we have developed a synthetic data model to generate customized line-integral diagnostic datasets and have also collected soft x-ray diagnostic datasets from EAST and HL-2A. This study achieves reductions in reconstruction errors, and accelerates the development of surrogate models in fusion research.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2024onion,
  author = {Cong Wang and Weizhe Yang and Haiping Wang and Renjie Yang and Jing Li and Zhijun Wang and Xinyao Yu and Yixiong Wei and Xianli Huang and Zhaoyang Liu and Changqing Zou and Zhifeng Zhao},
  title = {{ONION: Physics-Informed Deep Learning Model for Line Integral Diagnostics Across Fusion Devices}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2412.00087},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.00087},
}
Figure