One-time fertilization of controlled-release urea with compound fertilizer and rapeseed cake maintains rice grain yield and improves nitrogen use efficiency under reduced nitrogen conditions

Yajie Hu, Qin Cai, Yi Xu, Jiantao Xue, Enwei Yu, Haiyan Wei, Ke Xu, Zhong-Yang Huo, Hongcheng ZhangFrontiers in Plant Science 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Nitrogen (N) rate reduction and simplified fertilization can mitigate environmental impacts and reduce manual labor in rice (Oryza sativa L.) production. This study evaluates a one-time fertilization strategy using controlled-release bulk blending fertilizer (CRF) combined with increased plant density (ID) or rapeseed cake (RC) under a 20% chemical N reduction. Results indicate that the CRF+RC treatment maintained grain yields comparable to conventional split-application (CK) while significantly improving nitrogen use efficiency (NUE). CRF+ID also outperformed standard CRF and reduced N fertilizer (RNF) treatments. This approach demonstrates the potential for sustainable, labor-efficient rice production.

Introduction

Rice production faces the dual challenge of maintaining high yields for food security while minimizing the environmental footprint of excessive nitrogen (N) use. Traditional fertilization involves multiple split-applications, which are labor-intensive and prone to nutrient loss through leaching and volatilization. Controlled-release urea (CRU) offers a "one-time" application alternative; however, reducing total N often leads to yield penalties. This research investigates whether combining CRU with organic supplements (rapeseed cake) or increased planting density can sustain yields under a 20% N reduction regime.

Methods

The study was conducted over two years (2019–2020) in Jiangsu, China. Researchers compared a conventional control (CK, 300 kg ha⁻¹ N in split applications) against four 20% reduced-N strategies (240 kg ha⁻¹ N):

  • RNF: Reduced N fertilizer using traditional split-applications.
  • CRF: One-time basal application of a bulk-blended fertilizer (CRU with 40-day and 100-day release periods mixed with compound fertilizer).
  • CRF+ID: CRF combined with a ~20% increase in planting density.
  • CRF+RC: CRF combined with rapeseed cake (adding 20% organic N).

Key metrics included grain yield, tiller counts, biomass accumulation, and various Nitrogen Use Efficiency (NUE) parameters.

Results and Discussion

The experimental results highlighted the synergy between controlled-release technology and organic amendments.

Yield Stability and Growth Dynamics

The CRF+RC treatment was the only reduced-N strategy to achieve grain yields statistically equivalent to the high-input CK treatment across both years. As shown in Figure 5, while RNF and standard CRF saw significant yield drops, the addition of rapeseed cake bridged the gap.

Figure 5: Grain yield (t ha⁻¹) of rice under different nitrogen treatments in 2019 and 2020.

The success of CRF+RC is attributed to its ability to match the rice plant's N demand curve. By blending different CRU release profiles with organic matter, the treatment supported robust tillering and biomass accumulation. Figure 6 illustrates that CRF+RC maintained higher tiller numbers through the mid-to-late growth stages compared to other reduced-N treatments, which is critical for final panicle formation.

Figure 6: Number of stems and tillers at different growth stages in 2020.

Resource Efficiency and Labor Savings

Beyond yield, the CRF+RC strategy significantly improved NUE metrics, including Nitrogen Partial Factor Productivity (PFN) and Recovery Efficiency (NRE). Furthermore, reducing fertilization from five applications to one basal application represents a substantial reduction in manual labor requirements, addressing the growing labor shortage in rural agricultural sectors.

Conclusion

One-time fertilization using a blend of controlled-release urea and rapeseed cake (CRF+RC) effectively maintains rice yields while reducing chemical nitrogen input by 20%. This strategy optimizes nutrient delivery, improves soil-plant nitrogen dynamics, and offers a practical pathway toward more sustainable and less labor-intensive rice cultivation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nitrogen (N) rate reduction and simplified fertilization can mitigate environmental impacts and reduce the involvement of manual labor in rice (<i>Oryza sativa</i> L.) production. Controlled-release urea (CRU) has been recommended as an effective alternative technique to conventional urea fertilization, and it can improve rice yield and N use efficiency (NUE) and reduce labor costs. However, the information on the effects of one-time fertilization with CRU on maintaining yield and improving NUE under reduced chemical N conditions is limited. In this study, controlled-release bulk blending fertilizer (CRF), consisting of CRU with release periods of 40 and 100 days, mixed with compound fertilizer, was applied as basal fertilizer. Increased ~20% plant density (ID) and rapeseed cake fertilizer (RC, increase 20% organic N) were combined with CRF, respectively. The N treatments with 20% chemical N reduction were as follows: reduced N fertilizer (RNF), CRF, CRF+ID, and CRF+RC. In addition, a conventional split fertilizer application with 300 kg ha<sup>-1</sup> N was applied as the control (CK). Rice yield and its components, dry matter accumulation, N uptake, and NUE were investigated to evaluate whether one-time N fertilization realized stable yield and high NUE under reduced 20% chemical N conditions. Compared with CK, the CRF+RC treatment exhibited a comparable grain yield, while the other reduced N treatments (RNF, CRF, and CRF+ID) had a lower grain yield. Moreover, CRF+ID exhibited a higher rice grain yield than RNF or CRF under the same N level. Irrespective of exogenous organic N, CRF+RC exhibited significantly higher NUE than CK. The CRF+ID treatment showed a significantly higher N partial factor productivity (PFN) than CK but comparable N agronomic efficiency (NAE) and N recovery efficiency (NRE). Therefore, a one-time fertilizer application of CRF+RC maintained grain yield and improved the NUE while reducing the N rate and fertilization times, demonstrating its potential application in rice production.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2023one,
  author = {Yajie Hu and Qin Cai and Yi Xu and Jiantao Xue and Enwei Yu and Haiyan Wei and Ke Xu and Zhong-Yang HUO and Hongcheng Zhang},
  title = {{One-time fertilization of controlled-release urea with compound fertilizer and rapeseed cake maintains rice grain yield and improves nitrogen use efficiency under reduced nitrogen conditions}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2023.1281309},
}
Figure