One-loop matrix elements of effective superstring interactions: $\alpha'$-expanding loop integrands

Alex Edison, Max Guillen, Henrik Johansson, Oliver Schlotterer, Fei TengarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to calculate one-loop corrections to the effective actions of superstring theories. By leveraging insights from ambitwistor string theory and expanding in powers of the string tension ($\alpha'$), the authors provide a systematic way to compute these corrections, which are crucial for understanding the low-energy behavior of strings. Their approach offers a new tool for exploring connections between string theory, number theory, and algebraic geometry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The low-energy effective actions of superstring theories, which describe the behavior of fundamental particles at low energies, are known to contain an infinite series of higher-dimension operators. These operators, involving derivatives of gauge fields ($F$) and curvature ($R$), are organized in powers of the inverse string tension ($\alpha'$). While tree-level amplitudes are well-understood, calculating one-loop corrections to these effective actions, especially those involving these higher-dimension operators, is a formidable challenge. This paper tackles the problem of systematically constructing and understanding these one-loop matrix elements, particularly focusing on their $\alpha'$-expansion and their connection to ultraviolet (UV) divergences.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in a novel approach inspired by ambitwistor string theories. The authors propose using forward limits of moduli-space integrals of string tree-level amplitudes. This technique, when expanded in powers of $\alpha'$, allows them to construct one-loop matrix elements for operators like $D^{2k}F^n$ and $D^{2k}R^n$. A key feature of their method is the use of non-standard linearized Feynman propagators in intermediate steps, which are shown to recombine into conventional quadratic propagators. This recombination is facilitated by a criterion related to the underlying genus-one correlation functions. The authors also leverage chiral splitting and homology invariance to connect linearized and quadratic propagators, and they utilize disk and sphere integrals as building blocks. The UV divergences of their calculated matrix elements are then cross-checked against the degeneration of genus-one string integrals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Ambitwistor and Conventional String Theory: The paper successfully exports techniques from ambitwistor string theory (specifically, forward limits of loop integrands) to the realm of conventional open and closed superstring theories, providing a unified framework.
  • Systematic $\alpha'$-Expansion: The method offers a systematic way to compute one-loop corrections organized by powers of $\alpha'$, which is essential for understanding the low-energy effective field theory expansion of string theory.
  • Linearized to Quadratic Propagators: The paper demonstrates a crucial step in simplifying loop calculations by showing how non-standard linearized propagators can be systematically recombined into familiar quadratic propagators, a process that is key to making calculations tractable.
  • Connection to Number Theory: The results offer a constructive method to study degenerations of elliptic multiple zeta values and modular graph forms, highlighting a deep connection between string theory and advanced mathematical concepts.
  • UV Divergence as a Probe: The paper establishes a strong link between the UV divergences of one-loop matrix elements and the degeneration of genus-one string integrals, using UV divergences as a tool to understand string theory amplitudes.

Key Results

  • The paper proposes a new method for constructing one-loop matrix elements for higher-dimension operators in the effective actions of type-I and type-II superstrings.
  • Explicit four- and five-point examples of these one-loop matrix elements are calculated and expressed in terms of quadratic propagators.
  • A criterion is formulated for the recombination of linearized propagators to quadratic ones, applicable at all orders in $\alpha'$.
  • The UV divergences of the calculated one-loop matrix elements are shown to be consistent with the degeneration of genus-one string integrals.
  • The results provide a constructive method for studying degenerations of elliptic multiple zeta values and modular graph forms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Massless States: The current method focuses on the effective field theory of massless states and does not directly address Kaluza-Klein or winding modes, which are important for the analytic part of one-loop string amplitudes.
  • Higher Loops: The work is focused on one-loop matrix elements; extending the method to two loops and beyond is suggested as a promising avenue for future research.
  • Non-Planar Amplitudes: The proposal for non-planar or double-trace matrix elements calls for explicit examples and consistency checks.
  • Higher Multiplicities: While the method is general, explicit calculations for higher-point matrix elements (n ≥ 6) are left for future work.
  • Color-Kinematics Duality: Manifesting the color-kinematics duality for higher-loop integrands and finding local numerators with kinematic Jacobi relations for challenging cases like the five-loop integrand of maximal supergravity are identified as important future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the low-energy effective action of string theories, non-abelian gauge interactions and supergravity are augmented by infinite towers of higher-mass-dimension operators. We propose a new method to construct one-loop matrix elements with insertions of operators $D^{2k} F^n$ and $D^{2k} R^n$ in the tree-level effective action of type-I and type-II superstrings. Inspired by ambitwistor string theories, our method is based on forward limits of moduli-space integrals using string tree-level amplitudes with two extra points, expanded in powers of the inverse string tension $\alpha'$. Similar to one-loop ambitwistor computations, intermediate steps feature non-standard linearized Feynman propagators which eventually recombine to conventional quadratic propagators. With linearized propagators the loop integrand of the matrix elements obey one-loop versions of the monodromy and KLT relations. We express a variety of four- and five-point examples in terms of quadratic propagators and formulate a criterion on the underlying genus-one correlation functions that should make this recombination possible at all orders in $\alpha'$. The ultraviolet divergences of the one-loop matrix elements are crosschecked against the non-separating degeneration of genus-one integrals in string amplitudes. Conversely, our results can be used as a constructive method to determine degenerations of elliptic multiple zeta values and modular graph forms at arbitrary weight.
BibTeX
@misc{edison2021one,
  author = {Alex Edison and Max Guillen and Henrik Johansson and Oliver Schlotterer and Fei Teng},
  title = {{One-loop matrix elements of effective superstring interactions: $\textbackslash\{\}alpha'$-expanding loop integrands}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2107.08009},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.08009},
}
Figure