Abstract: Cylindrical multishell structure is one of the prevalent atomic arrangements in nanowires. Being multishell, the well-defined atomic periodicity is hardly realized in it because the periodic units of individual shells therein generally do not match except for very few cases, posing a challenge to understand its physical properties. Here we show that moiré patterns generated by superimposing atomic lattices of individual shells are decisive in determining its electronic structures. Double-walled carbon nanotubes (DWNTs), as an example, are shown to have spectacular variations in their electronic properties from metallic to semiconducting and further to insulating states depending on their moiré patterns, even when they are composed of only semiconducting nanotubes with almost similar energy gaps and diameters. Thus, aperiodic multishell nanowires can be classified into new one-dimensional moiré crystals with distinct electronic structures.
Introduction
In the field of nanotechnology, double-walled carbon nanotubes (DWNTs) represent a complex challenge. Composed of two concentric graphene cylinders, their electronic properties theoretically depend on the chirality (rolling angle) of each tube. However, most DWNTs are "incommensurate," meaning the atomic lattices of the inner and outer shells do not align in a repeating pattern over manageable distances. This lack of a simple unit cell makes standard ab initio computational methods difficult to apply, leaving a gap in our understanding of how inter-shell interactions dictate the overall electrical behavior of these nanowires.
Theoretical Framework: Mapping 2D Physics to 1D Tubes
To overcome the problem of incommensurability, the authors developed a continuum model that maps the 1D nanotube physics onto 2D bilayer graphene (BLG) structures. The process involves "unfolding" the DWNT into a bilayer sheet. Because the circumferences of the two tubes differ, one layer must undergo a specific rotation and uniaxial contraction to ensure the widths match perfectly in the flattened state.
Instead of tracking individual atoms, the model uses an effective Hamiltonian based on Bloch wave expansion. It focuses on how electronic states near the graphene Dirac points (K-points) are coupled by the Fourier components of the moiré potential. Finally, 1D quantization is re-imposed by "cutting" the 2D energy bands into 1D lines that satisfy the periodic boundary conditions around the tube's circumference.
The Moiré Paradigm and Electronic Regimes
The core insight of this research is that DWNTs should be viewed as 1D moiré crystals. The interference pattern between the two shells—rather than just the individual tube properties—is the primary determinant of the system's electronic state. The study identifies three distinct regimes based on the direction of the "mismatch vector" between the tubes:
- Strong Coupling (Armchair-like): When the difference between the tubes' chiral vectors is parallel to the armchair direction, the shells interact strongly. This interaction can reduce or even close the energy gap, potentially turning two semiconducting tubes into a metallic system.
- Weak Coupling: The tubes retain much of their individual character with minimal interference.
- Localized Insulating (Zigzag-like): If the mismatch vector is parallel to the zigzag direction, electrons become localized in specific regions of the moiré pattern. This creates flat energy bands, effectively turning the tube into a 1D array of quantum dots.
Key Results and Band Structure Analysis
The impact of these moiré patterns is most visible in the resulting band structures. For instance, in the (35,19) @ (40,24) DWNT configuration, the interlayer interaction reduces the energy gap significantly. Two semiconducting tubes with individual gaps of ~0.18 eV and ~0.15 eV combine to form a system that behaves as a metal due to gap closing.
Conversely, in the localized regime, the model predicts nearly flat bands, indicating that electrons are trapped within the moiré interference pattern. This suggests that the moiré pattern is a more decisive factor for the final electronic state than the diameters or energy gaps of the constituent tubes alone.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
By treating multishell nanowires as 1D moiré crystals, this work provides a unified framework for understanding aperiodic structures that were previously difficult to model. While the study focuses on carbon nanotubes, the authors suggest this approach is applicable to other multishell systems, such as Boron Nitride or MoS2 nanotubes. Future experimental validation through optical absorption or electrical transport measurements on structure-identified DWNTs will be crucial to confirming these theoretical predictions.
Summary updated