One-Dimensional Electron Liquid in an Antiferromagnetic Environment: Spin Gap from Magnetic Correlations

Mats Granath, Henrik JohannessonPhysical 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We study a one-dimensional electron liquid coupled by a weak spin-exchange interaction to an antiferromagnetic spin-$S$ ladder with $n$ legs. A perturbative renormalization group analysis in the semiclassical limit reveals the opening of a spin gap, driven by the local magnetic correlations on the ladder. The effect, which we argue is present for any gapful ladder or gapless ladder with $nS \gg 1$, is enhanced by the repulsive interaction among the conduction electrons but is insensitive to the sign of the spin exchange interaction with the ladder. Possible implications for the striped phases of the cuprates are discussed.

Introduction

In the study of high-temperature ($high-T_c$) superconductors like cuprates, researchers have identified "stripes": one-dimensional regions where doped holes concentrate, forming metallic wires embedded within an antiferromagnetic (AFM) Mott insulator. A major question in condensed matter physics is the origin of the "pseudogap"—a state where the material behaves as if it has a gap in its energy spectrum even before it becomes superconducting.

This paper investigates whether the simple exchange of spin between itinerant electrons in a stripe and localized spins in the surrounding AFM environment is sufficient to open an electronic spin gap. The authors explore how this mechanism behaves across different magnetic environments and how electron-electron interactions within the stripe influence the outcome.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors model the system as a Hubbard chain (the stripe) coupled to a neighboring spin-$S$ ladder (the environment) via a weak spin-exchange interaction ($J_K$). To determine the low-energy physics, they employ several sophisticated theoretical tools:

  • Semiclassical Approximation: Localized spins in the environment are treated semiclassically in the large-$S$ limit using a path-integral formalism.
  • Bosonization: The electron liquid is mapped from fermion operators to bosonic fields, allowing for the analysis of collective excitations.
  • Renormalization Group (RG) Analysis: Perturbative RG equations are used to track how coupling constants evolve across length scales. A flow toward infinity indicates the opening of a gap.

The Origin and Universality of the Spin Gap

A key finding is that the spin gap opens regardless of whether the coupling between the stripe and the environment is ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic. This universality occurs because the effect depends on the square of the coupling constant ($J_K^2$), making it insensitive to the sign.

Crucially, the gap is not caused by a static magnetic field but by local magnetic correlations within the environment. The authors argue that this effect is robust for most environment types (even-leg or odd-leg ladders), provided the environment itself is not at a critical point.

Interaction Synergy and the Role of Electron Repulsion

Perhaps the most significant insight is the synergy between the environment-induced gap and the internal interactions of the electron liquid. Repulsive electron-electron interactions ($U > 0$) within the stripe actually enhance the spin gap. Conversely, attractive interactions ($U < 0$) tend to frustrate the system and can reduce or even close the gap.

Dependence of the spin gap $\Delta$ on the interaction strength $g_U$.

As illustrated in Figure 1, the spin gap ($\Delta$) shows a clear dependence on the interaction strength $g_U$. For repulsive interactions ($g_U > 0$), the gap increases, while for attractive interactions, it decreases toward zero. This suggests that the natural repulsive forces between electrons in real materials play a constructive role in stabilizing the pseudogap phase.

Key Results and Analytical Predictions

The RG analysis yields an analytical expression for the spin gap: $$\Delta \approx \frac{v_s}{a} e^{-1/4|\lambda_0|}$$ where $v_s$ is the spin velocity and $\lambda_0$ is a dimensionless coupling constant. The system's behavior mirrors that of a 1D XXZ spin chain in an Ising-like phase, which is known to have a mass gap and Néel order. While the perturbative approach is most rigorous for environments with large spins or wide domains, the authors argue the underlying physics holds more broadly.

Limitations and Future Work

While providing a compelling mechanism for the spin gap, the study notes several limitations:

  • Semiclassical Limit: The derivation relies on the large-$S$ limit; a full non-perturbative treatment would be required for absolute certainty in the narrow-domain (spin-1/2) limit.
  • Static Stripes: The model assumes stripes are already formed and stable, rather than addressing the dynamical instability that causes them.
  • Dimensionality: The strictly 1D nature of the model may be influenced by 3D coupling or the 2D nature of CuO$_2$ planes in real materials.

Future extensions of this work will explore the specific implications for the "normal-state" pseudogap in underdoped cuprates, potentially bridging the gap between theoretical models and experimental observations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study a one-dimensional electron liquid coupled by a weak spin-exchange interaction to an antiferromagnetic spin- $S$ ladder with $n$ legs. A perturbative renormalization group analysis in the semiclassical limit reveals the opening of a spin gap, driven by the local magnetic correlations on the ladder. The effect, which we argue is present for any gapful ladder or gapless ladder with $\mathrm{nS}\ensuremath{\gg}1$, is enhanced by the repulsive interaction among the conduction electrons but is insensitive to the sign of the spin exchange interaction with the ladder. Possible implications for the striped phases of the cuprates are discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{granath1999one,
  author = {Mats Granath and Henrik Johannesson},
  title = {{One-Dimensional Electron Liquid in an Antiferromagnetic Environment: Spin Gap from Magnetic Correlations}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.83.199},
}
Figure