TL;DR
This paper tackles a fundamental limitation in one-bit compressive sensing: the inability to recover the signal's norm. By introducing affine shifts to the measurements, the authors enable accurate norm estimation alongside signal recovery. They propose two novel methods, one based on augmented convex programming and another on empirical distribution functions, providing theoretical guarantees for their effectiveness.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Compressive sensing (CS) aims to reconstruct a sparse signal from fewer measurements than traditional methods require. A significant challenge arises when these measurements are quantized to a single bit, meaning we only know the sign of the measurement, not its magnitude. This "one-bit compressive sensing" (1-bit CS) setting, while attractive for its simplicity and low-power hardware implementation, inherently loses information about the signal's norm. Consequently, existing 1-bit CS methods typically assume the signal's norm is known (e.g., normalized to 1), which is often an unrealistic constraint in practical applications. This paper addresses this critical gap by developing methods that can recover both the direction and the norm of a sparse signal from one-bit measurements, even when the norm is initially unknown.
Methods
The paper introduces two primary approaches to overcome the norm estimation challenge in 1-bit CS:
- Augmented Convex Programming: This method extends the standard one-bit CS recovery framework by incorporating affine shifts ($b_i$) into the measurements. The measurements become $y_i = \text{sign}((a_i, x) + b_i)$. By treating the affine shifts as random variables (specifically, Gaussian), the problem can be reformulated as an augmented linear measurement problem. This allows existing 1-bit CS recovery algorithms, like the one proposed by Plan and Vershynin, to be applied to an augmented vector $(x, t)$, where $t$ is related to the affine shifts. This approach yields an estimate of the signal $x$ and its norm simultaneously.
- Empirical Distribution Function (EDF) Approach: This method focuses on estimating the signal's norm directly. When the affine shifts $b_i$ are set to a common, non-random value $\tau$, the measurements $y_i = \text{sign}((a_i, x) - \tau)$ provide information about the cumulative distribution function (CDF) of the Gaussian random variable $(a_i, x)$. The paper leverages the Dvoretzky-Kiefer-Wolfowitz (DKW) inequality to bound the difference between the empirical CDF and the true CDF. By inverting the Gaussian CDF, an estimator for the signal's norm is derived. This method is computationally efficient, requiring only a single evaluation of the inverse Gaussian error function.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce or use specific datasets. Instead, it focuses on theoretical guarantees for recovery from synthetic measurements generated according to the described models. The performance of the proposed methods is evaluated through numerical experiments using synthetically generated sparse signals and random measurement vectors.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Affine Shifts as a Key to Norm Recovery: The core insight is that introducing affine shifts ($b_i$) to the one-bit measurements, even if random, provides the necessary information to recover the signal's norm, which is otherwise lost in standard $y_i = \text{sign}((a_i, x))$ measurements.
- Bridging 1-bit CS and Augmented Measurements: The augmented convex programming approach elegantly transforms the problem into a known framework by treating the signal and affine shifts as a single augmented vector, allowing existing powerful recovery algorithms to be leveraged.
- EDF for Efficient Norm Estimation: The EDF approach offers a computationally attractive alternative for norm estimation, relying on statistical properties of the measurements and a single evaluation of a special function, making it potentially very practical.
- Universal Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical guarantees that hold "universally" for sparse vectors within a certain ball, meaning a single set of measurements and thresholds can recover many different sparse signals with high probability.
Key Results
- Theoretical Guarantees for Norm Recovery: The paper provides rigorous theoretical bounds on the recovery error for both the augmented convex programming and EDF methods. These bounds show that the error decays as the number of measurements increases.
- Augmented Convex Programming Performance: The error for this method scales similarly to existing 1-bit CS methods, approximately as $m^{-1/5}$, where $m$ is the number of measurements.
- EDF Norm Estimation Accuracy: The EDF method can estimate the norm with additive error $\delta$ using $m \gtrsim R^4 r^{-2} \delta^{-2}$ measurements, where $r$ and $R$ are lower and upper bounds on the signal norm. This method is shown to be efficient and can achieve error decay rates of $O(m^{-1/2})$ in certain regimes.
- Numerical Experiments: Simulations confirm the theoretical findings, showing that the augmented convex programming method generally outperforms the EDF method in terms of signal recovery accuracy, though at a higher computational cost. The EDF method is shown to be sensitive to the choice of the threshold parameter $\tau$.
Limitations and Future Work
- Known Bounds on Norm: Both proposed methods require prior knowledge of an upper bound on the signal norm ($R$), and the EDF method also requires a lower bound ($r$). The paper acknowledges that in some applications, these bounds might not be readily available.
- Random Shifts for Convex Programming: The theoretical guarantees for the augmented convex programming approach rely on the affine shifts being independently randomly generated. The authors suggest that this might be an artifact of the proof and that constant shifts might also work, which would be an interesting direction for future research.
- Directional Information from EDF: The EDF method primarily estimates the norm and does not directly provide the signal's direction. While Corollary 12 shows how to combine it with other methods to recover the full signal, a unified approach that directly yields both norm and direction from the EDF framework would be valuable.
- Practical Implementation: While the paper discusses the potential for hardware implementation, further research into the practical trade-offs and challenges of implementing these methods in real-world systems would be beneficial.
Summary updated