Abstract
An additional shot of BPB for patients undergoing surgeries for elbow surgeries resulted in better postoperative pain response in younger children without significant BPB-related complications.
Introduction
Managing postoperative pain in young children is a perennial challenge in pediatric orthopedics. Children under 10 often struggle to communicate the nature of their pain, leading to potential undertreatment. Standard general anesthesia (GA) wears off quickly, often resulting in "emergence delirium" or intense distress—crying and screaming—in the post-anesthesia care unit (PACU). While regional anesthesia like the brachial plexus block (BPB) is common in adults, its routine application in younger children for elbow fractures has been less consistently evaluated. This study sought to determine if a "single shot" of BPB could provide a superior recovery experience compared to GA alone.
Methods
Researchers conducted a retrospective case-control study involving 300 pediatric patients (ages 3–10) treated between 2015 and 2019 at Union Hospital, Tongji Medical College. The cohort was split evenly: 150 received only GA, and 150 received GA plus an ultrasound-guided BPB.
The study evaluated four common elbow procedures: lateral condyle fractures (LC), medial epicondyle fractures (ME), supracondylar fractures (SC), and cubitus varus (CV) deformity corrections. Pain was assessed using a multi-modal scoring system: the FLACC scale (Face, Legs, Activity, Cry, Consolability) used by nurses, the Faces Pain Scale-Revised (FPS-R) used by the children, and the Numeric Rating Scale (NRS) used by caregivers.
Key Results
The quantitative differences between the groups were stark across several metrics:
- Pain Scores (FLACC): In the PACU, GA-only patients averaged scores between 6.0 and 6.7 (severe discomfort), while the GA + BPB group averaged between 1.5 and 2.1 (mild to no pain).
- Rescue Analgesics: In the LC and ME groups, 0% of the children in the BPB group required rescue analgesics in the recovery room, compared to 100% of the children in the GA-only group.
- Sleep Quality: Children with the block were far more likely to sleep through the first night, whereas the majority of GA-only patients woke up three or more times due to pain.
- Safety: By using ultrasound to guide the needle, surgeons reported zero BPB-related complications (such as nerve damage or accidental lung puncture).
Discussion and Conclusion
The benefit of the BPB was not procedure-specific; pain reduction was statistically significant across all fracture types and deformity corrections. Caregivers also rated the pain significantly lower in the BPB group (NRS ~2.3–2.7) compared to the GA group (NRS ~4.0–4.8).
While this study is limited by its retrospective design and single-center focus, the results suggest that adding a single ultrasound-guided BPB to general anesthesia significantly slashes postoperative pain and the need for rescue analgesics in children. This simple intervention leads to smoother recoveries, better sleep for patients, and reduced workload for nursing staff without increasing complication rates. Future research should include prospective randomized trials and formal cost-benefit analyses to further validate these findings.
Summary updated