On Writing a Textbook on Natural Language Processing

Jacob EisensteinNAACL 2021

TL;DR

This paper reflects on the motivations, process, and lessons learned from writing a textbook on Natural Language Processing (NLP). It argues for the continued relevance of textbooks in a rapidly evolving field and offers practical advice for aspiring authors, emphasizing the importance of clarity, consistency, and a unique perspective.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the perceived gap in the availability of comprehensive, formal textbooks for Natural Language Processing (NLP), despite the field's explosion in popularity and the abundance of online resources. While blogs, tutorials, and online courses offer accessible entry points, the author posits that a well-structured textbook is crucial for providing a unified mathematical foundation, consistent terminology, and a curated overview of techniques and applications. The author also touches upon the challenge of convincing educators to adopt new textbooks in a field where materials can quickly become outdated.

Methods

The paper doesn't describe novel algorithmic methods in NLP itself. Instead, it focuses on the methodology of writing a textbook. The author details their approach to structuring the book, which progresses from foundational machine learning concepts (linear classification, neural networks) to advanced topics like structure prediction (sequences, trees) and semantics, culminating in primary application areas (machine translation, information extraction, text generation). The writing process involved synthesizing research papers, unifying notation, and seeking feedback from experts and students. The author also discusses the practical aspects of working with a publisher, including proposal writing, drafting, revision, and proofreading.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Textbooks as Unifiers: A key insight is that textbooks serve a vital role in unifying terminology and mathematical notation across a diverse and rapidly evolving field like NLP. This consistency is difficult to achieve through scattered online resources.
  • The "Why" of Textbook Writing: Beyond personal motivation (like improving teaching materials), writing a textbook forces a deep engagement with the field, clarifying the author's vision and identifying connections between disparate concepts.
  • Longevity and Quality: Despite the fast pace of NLP, a well-written textbook can offer enduring value, providing a stable reference point. The publication process itself, with editors and reviewers, inherently improves the quality and clarity of the material.
  • The "Impostor Syndrome" and Courage: The author candidly discusses overcoming the fear of competing with established "luminaries" in the field, suggesting that the need for new perspectives and comprehensive resources can be a powerful motivator.
  • Practicalities of Publishing: The paper offers practical advice on navigating the publishing process, from proposal writing to managing revisions and proofs, highlighting the collaborative nature of book creation.

Key Results

The paper's "results" are primarily reflective and advisory, rather than quantitative. The author's textbook, "Introduction to Natural Language Processing," has been published and is being used in courses. The author notes that the free online edition has been a significant factor in its adoption, especially given the availability of other resources. The exercises are reported to be particularly helpful for training graduate students.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges that the field of NLP is constantly evolving, and even a recently published textbook will inevitably have parts that become outdated. They specifically mention that topics like multilinguality, multimodality, and the rise of pretraining and prompt-based learning would require a fundamental rethinking for a second edition, potentially moving beyond a traditional textbook structure. The author also notes that while they initially planned to reuse existing course notes, the actual writing process involved significant rewriting to meet the standards of a textbook.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{eisenstein2021writing,
  author = {Jacob Eisenstein},
  title = {{On Writing a Textbook on Natural Language Processing}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2021},
}
Figure