On unconventional fall of rainbow spring

Jie Liu, Xing Wang, Jiongzhao Liang, Bing Liu, Wei Wei, Huimin Shi, Guilin Wen, Yi XiearXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this study we experimentally show that a stretched rainbow spring under gravity or extra weight may exhibit unconventional fall motion. Specially, when the rainbow spring is released from a high place, its lower end remains stationary until the spring wires stack together and then all the parts of the rainbow spring falls down together. We utilize a high-speed camera to record the fall process of one plastic and one metal rainbow spring under different loading conditions to systematically investigate this unconventional physical phenomenon. We use the time of the elastic wave propagating the length of the spring to predict the duration of the lower end of the rainbow spring remaining still. The findings from this study elucidate this physical phenomenon which has potential for the areas requiring temporary absolute space positioning.

Introduction

In classical mechanics, rigid bodies are expected to accelerate uniformly under gravity upon release. However, deformable structures like the "rainbow spring" (or Slinky) exhibit a counterintuitive behavior: when a stretched spring is dropped, its bottom end remains stationary in mid-air until the top of the spring collapses onto it. This "unconventional fall" has long been a popular physics demonstration, but a systematic quantitative analysis across different materials and loading conditions is necessary to fully understand the underlying mechanics and explore potential applications in "temporary absolute space positioning."

Methods

The experimental setup was designed to capture the rapid dynamics of the spring's collapse with high precision. A high-speed camera (model 5F04M) was positioned to record the fall of two distinct spring types: one plastic and one metal.

Experimental setup for capturing the fall of rainbow springs.

To investigate the effect of mass on the "hover" duration, each spring was tested under three loading conditions: no external weight, a 50g weight attached to the bottom, and a 100g weight attached to the bottom. Theoretical predictions for the stationary duration ($t_w$) were derived using Hooke’s Law and the physics of axial elastic wave propagation. The time $t_w$ is defined as the interval required for the relaxation wave to travel from the released top end to the bottom:

$$t_w = \sqrt{\frac{\Delta L}{g}}$$

where $\Delta L$ represents the total extension of the spring beyond its natural compressed length and $g$ is the acceleration due to gravity.

Results and Discussion

The high-speed footage confirmed that both plastic and metal springs exhibit the stationary lower-end phenomenon, indicating it is a structural mechanical property independent of the specific material.

Time-lapse sequence demonstrating the stationary lower end during the spring's collapse.

The Physics of Information Delay

The bottom of the spring remains stationary because the upward tension force at that point continues to perfectly balance the downward force of gravity (and any attached weight) until the elastic relaxation wave reaches it. This wave carries the "information" that the top has been released.

Quantitative Analysis

The experimental results showed a strong correlation between initial extension and "hover" time. For the plastic spring without weight, the bottom remained still for 0.1667 seconds. Adding a 100g weight increased the extension $\Delta L$, thereby increasing the observed stationary time to 0.2103 seconds.

Interestingly, the measured time ($t$) was consistently slightly shorter than the theoretical prediction ($t_w$). For example, the base plastic spring's observed time of 0.1667s was just below the predicted 0.1684s. The researchers attribute this discrepancy to shock waves generated during the collapse, which travel faster than the linear elastic wave and accelerate the downward motion.

Conclusion

This study successfully quantifies the unconventional fall of rainbow springs, demonstrating that the duration of the stationary phase is primarily governed by elastic wave propagation. This principle of "temporary absolute space positioning" mirrors biological stabilization mechanisms, such as those seen in birds of prey. Future work could involve more rigorous mathematical modeling of the shock wave dynamics and exploring applications in high-resolution satellite positioning or stabilization platforms for sensors on moving vehicles.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study we experimentally show that a stretched rainbow spring under gravity or extra weight may exhibit unconventional fall motion. Specially, when the rainbow spring is released from a high place, its lower end remains stationary until the spring wires stack together and then all the parts of the rainbow spring falls down together. We utilize a high-speed camera to record the fall process of one plastic and one metal rainbow spring under different loading conditions to systematically investigate this unconventional physical phenomenon. We use the time of the elastic wave propagating the length of the spring to predict the duration of the lower end of the rainbow spring remaining still. The findings from this study elucidate this physical phenomenon which has potential for the areas requiring temporary absolute space positioning.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2019unconventional,
  author = {Jie Liu and Xing Wang and Jiongzhao Liang and Bing Liu and Wei Wei and Huimin Shi and Guilin Wen and Yi Xie},
  title = {{On unconventional fall of rainbow spring}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1902.05815},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1902.05815},
}
Figure