On the velocity‐strengthening behavior of dry friction

Yohai Bar‐Sinai, Robert Spatschek, Efim A. Brener, Eran BouchbinderJournal of Geophysical Research Solid Earth 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The onset of frictional instabilities, such as earthquake nucleation, is closely linked to velocity-weakening friction. While this has been studied extensively, steady-state velocity-strengthening (SVS) friction—which influences rupture propagation speed and energy release—has received less attention. This paper suggests that a crossover from velocity-weakening at low speeds to velocity-strengthening at higher speeds is a generic feature of dry friction. We argue that while thermal activation leads to logarithmic strengthening, a transition to stronger-than-logarithmic regimes may occur at higher velocities due to changes in dissipation mechanisms.

Introduction

In geophysics and materials science, "velocity-weakening" friction is often the focus because it triggers instabilities like earthquakes. However, the authors of this study argue that Steady-State Velocity-Strengthening (SVS) is equally critical. SVS acts as a stabilizer, limiting rupture speeds and determining the energy left behind after a slip event. This paper addresses the lack of a unified framework explaining why friction eventually increases with velocity and why this increase often exceeds standard logarithmic predictions.

Theoretical Framework and Key Insights

The authors utilize the "rate-and-state" friction formalism, focusing on the competition between asperity "aging" (which increases friction) and "rheology" (material flow under stress).

A central insight is that the "U-shape" friction curve is generic. At low speeds, increasing velocity "rejuvenates" the interface, breaking contact points faster than they reform, leading to weakening. However, the contact area eventually hits a physical floor. Once this saturation point is reached, the intrinsic shear strength of the material dominates, causing friction to rise.

Conceptual schematic of the transition from steady-state velocity-weakening (SVW) to velocity-strengthening (SVS), highlighting the crossover to stronger-than-logarithmic regimes.

Furthermore, while standard models assume friction increases only with the logarithm of velocity (due to thermal activation), the authors propose that at high speeds, "athermal" processes—such as phonon drag or momentum transfer—lead to stronger-than-logarithmic strengthening (e.g., linear or quadratic increases).

Experimental Evidence and Results

To validate these ideas, the authors compiled and re-analyzed a vast array of experimental data covering rocks (halite, granite, aplite), polymers (PMMA), granular materials (glass beads), and even paper (Bristol board).

Experimental data across various materials showing the transition from velocity-weakening to velocity-strengthening. Blue circles represent data points; dashed lines indicate the crossover velocity.

The results consistently show the predicted "U-shape." In materials like PMMA and Halite, the crossover point ($v_m$) is clearly visible. For Bristol board and glass beads, the data supports a linear relationship ($\tau \propto v$) at high speeds, confirming the transition to different dissipation mechanisms. Interestingly, some materials like wet clay appear to be in a perpetual strengthening state, likely because their contact area is already saturated.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While the "U-shape" appears universal, several challenges remain:

  • Parameter Estimation: The characteristic velocity ($v_0$) where thermal activation breaks down is difficult to determine independently and varies by material.
  • High-Speed Physics: The specific mechanisms for stronger-than-logarithmic strengthening (e.g., Bagnold scaling) remain conceptual "sketches" requiring more rigorous modeling.
  • Experimental Constraints: Reaching the high velocities needed to observe these transitions without excessive frictional heating is difficult. The authors call for more precise steady-state experiments over broader velocity ranges to further refine these models.

Summary updated

Abstract

The onset of frictional instabilities, e.g., earthquakes nucleation, is intimately related to velocity‐weakening friction, in which the frictional resistance of interfaces decreases with increasing slip velocity. While this frictional response has been studied extensively, less attention has been given to steady state velocity‐strengthening friction, in spite of its potential importance for various aspects of frictional phenomena such as the propagation speed of interfacial rupture fronts and the amount of stored energy released by them. In this note we suggest that a crossover from steady state velocity‐weakening friction at small slip velocities to steady state velocity‐strengthening friction at higher velocities might be a generic feature of dry friction. We further argue that while thermally activated rheology naturally gives rise to logarithmic steady state velocity‐strengthening friction, a crossover to stronger‐than‐logarithmic strengthening might take place at higher slip velocities, possibly accompanied by a change in the dominant dissipation mechanism. We sketch a few physical mechanisms that may account for the crossover to stronger‐than‐logarithmic steady state velocity strengthening and compile a rather extensive set of experimental data available in the literature, lending support to these ideas.
BibTeX
@article{barsinai2014velocitystrengthening,
  author = {Yohai Bar‐Sinai and Robert Spatschek and Efim A. Brener and Eran Bouchbinder},
  title = {{On the velocity‐strengthening behavior of dry friction}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Solid Earth},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1002/2013jb010586},
}
Figure