Abstract
Insertion mechanisms of multivalent ions in transition metal oxide cathodes are poorly understood and subject to controversy and debate, especially when performed in aqueous electrolytes. To address this issue, we have here investigated the reversible reduction of nanostructured amorphous TiO<sub>2</sub> electrodes by spectroelectrochemistry in mild aqueous electrolytes containing either a multivalent metal salt as AlCl<sub>3</sub> or a weak organic acid as acetic acid. Our results show that the reversible charge storage in TiO<sub>2</sub> is thermodynamically and kinetically indistinguishable when carried out in either an Al<sup>3+</sup>- or acetic acid-based electrolyte, both leading under similar conditions of pH and concentrations to an almost identical maximal charge storage of ∼115 mA h g<sup>-1</sup>. These observations are in agreement with a mechanism where the inserting/deinserting cation is the proton and not the multivalent metal cation. Analysis of the data also demonstrates that the proton source is the Brønsted weak acid present in the aqueous electrolyte, i.e. either the acetic acid or the aquo metal ion complex generated from solvation of Al<sup>3+</sup> (i.e. [Al(H<sub>2</sub>O)<sub>6</sub>]<sup>3+</sup>). Such a proton-coupled charge storage mechanism is also found to occur with other multivalent metal ions such as Zn<sup>2+</sup> and Mn<sup>2+</sup>, albeit with a lower efficiency than Al<sup>3+</sup>, an effect we have attributed to the lower acidity of [Zn(H<sub>2</sub>O)<sub>6</sub>]<sup>2+</sup> and [Mn(H<sub>2</sub>O)<sub>6</sub>]<sup>2+</sup>. These findings are of fundamental importance because they shed new light on previous studies assuming reversible Al<sup>3+</sup>-insertion into metal oxides, and, more generally, they highlight the unsuspected proton donor role played by multivalent metal cations commonly involved in rechargeable aqueous batteries.
Introduction
The development of rechargeable aqueous batteries utilizing multivalent ions such as $Zn^{2+}$, $Mg^{2+}$, or $Al^{3+}$ represents a significant frontier in grid-scale energy storage. These systems offer advantages in safety, cost, and theoretical energy density compared to lithium-ion counterparts. However, the fundamental mechanism of charge storage in transition metal oxide cathodes remains a subject of intense debate. Specifically, the "multivalent ion intercalation" theory—where bulky, highly charged ions enter the host lattice—faces significant thermodynamic hurdles due to large hydration shells and strong electrostatic repulsions.
Methods
To investigate these mechanisms, researchers employed nanostructured amorphous $TiO_2$ films fabricated via Glancing Angle Deposition (GLAD). This technique produces vertically aligned nanocolumns with high porosity, serving as an ideal model electrode. The primary analytical tool was spectroelectrochemistry, which correlates electrochemical measurements with optical absorbance at 780 nm (where $TiO_2$ darkens upon reduction). Crucially, the team compared the behavior of $TiO_2$ in $Al^{3+}$-based electrolytes against electrolytes containing acetic acid, a known proton donor, at equivalent pH levels.
Key Insights: Protons as the True Charge Carriers
The study's most striking finding is that the electrochemical and optical signatures of $TiO_2$ in $Al^{3+}$ electrolytes are virtually identical to those in acetic acid. This suggests that the electrode is not intercalating $Al^{3+}$ ions, but rather protons ($H^+$) donated by the metal-aquo complexes.
When metal salts like $AlCl_3$ dissolve, they form complexes such as $[Al(H_2O)_6]^{3+}$. These complexes act as Brønsted weak acids, releasing protons at the electrode surface:
$[M(H_2O)_6]^{n+} \rightleftharpoons [M(H_2O)_5(OH)]^{(n-1)+} + H^+$
The efficiency of charge storage correlates directly with the acidity ($pK_a$) of these complexes. $Al^{3+}$, with a $pK_a$ of approximately 5, is a much more effective proton donor than $Zn^{2+}$ or $Mn^{2+}$ ($pK_a$ 9–10), explaining its superior performance in these aqueous systems.
Results and Discussion
Both $Al^{3+}$ and acetic acid electrolytes achieved a maximal charge storage capacity of approximately 115 mAh/g. Furthermore, the kinetics were remarkably fast, with equilibrium reached in under a minute. This speed is inconsistent with the sluggish diffusion expected for bulky multivalent ions but aligns perfectly with proton-coupled electron transfer. The rate-limiting step was identified as the diffusion of the proton donor in the liquid phase, rather than ion movement within the solid electrode.
Conclusion
This research fundamentally reshapes the understanding of aqueous multivalent batteries by identifying the "unsuspected" role of metal cations as proton activators. While demonstrated here on amorphous $TiO_2$, this mechanism likely extends to other popular cathode materials like $MnO_2$ and $V_2O_5$. Future studies must address the faster kinetics observed during discharging (disinsertion) and determine how lattice rigidity in crystalline materials might influence this proton-coupled pathway.
Summary updated