TL;DR
This paper investigates whether language models can transfer causal reasoning skills between understanding news narratives and instructional plans. They find that while larger models already possess some of this knowledge, smaller models benefit from cross-domain training, particularly when learning about indirect causal relationships.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding the "why" behind events is crucial for comprehending various forms of text, from news articles to instructional guides. This involves identifying causal relationships, such as preconditions (what must be true before an event can occur) and effects. Humans seamlessly transfer this causal reasoning ability across different domains. However, it's unclear if language models can do the same. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring whether training models on causal knowledge from one domain (news) can improve their understanding in another (instructional plans), and vice-versa.
Methods
The researchers employed a transfer learning approach using two main datasets: PEKO for news article preconditions and CAT-BENCH for causal dependencies in cooking recipes. They explored three training regimes:
- Finetuning (FT): Standard fine-tuning on a single dataset to establish a baseline.
- Causal Pretraining (CP): Pretraining a model on one domain's causal knowledge and then finetuning it on the other. This tests direct knowledge transfer.
- Multi-Task Finetuning (MTF): Training on a mixed dataset from both domains simultaneously to see if models can learn diverse causal aspects.
They used T5 and FLANT5 models (both base and large variants) and analyzed performance based on step distance and dependency types within the instructional plans.
Datasets
- PEKO (Precondition Knowledge): A dataset of crowdsourced annotations of precondition relations between event pairs in news articles.
- CAT-BENCH (Causal and Temporal Benchmarks): A benchmark for evaluating causal and temporal reasoning in instructional plans, specifically focusing on step order prediction in cooking recipes. It includes questions about whether one step must happen before or after another, categorized into dependent (DEP) and non-dependent (NONDEP) pairs.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Smaller Models Benefit Most: Larger, pre-trained models (like FLANT5) often already encode significant causal knowledge, making the benefits of cross-domain transfer less pronounced. Smaller models, however, show noticeable improvements.
- Indirect Connections are Key: Causal pretraining and multi-task finetuning are particularly effective at helping models understand indirect causal connections and dependencies between non-adjacent steps in plans. This suggests that learning from diverse causal contexts helps models grasp more complex reasoning.
- Domain Differences Matter: The effectiveness of different training regimes varies. While transferring news knowledge to plans helps, the reverse also holds true, indicating a general benefit of cross-domain causal learning.
- Not All Causal Knowledge is Equal: Different types of causal relationships (e.g., preconditions vs. temporal ordering) impact models differently, and the paper highlights areas where combining knowledge from various sources can be most beneficial.
Key Results
- Improved Performance: All training regimes generally improved performance compared to baselines.
- CP and MFT Outperform FT: For T5-BASE models, Causal Pretraining (CP) and Multi-Task Finetuning (MTF) showed improvements over standard Finetuning (FT) on CAT-BENCH, with MTF yielding a significant ~7% improvement.
- Distant Steps Benefit: Both CP and MTF improved reasoning more for distant steps in instructional plans compared to closer steps, suggesting better handling of long-range dependencies.
- Non-Dependent Pairs are Harder: CP was found to be particularly helpful for identifying non-dependent step pairs in CAT-BENCH, which are more challenging to detect than dependent ones.
- FLANT5 vs. T5: FLANT5 models showed less improvement from CP and MTF compared to T5 models, likely due to their extensive pretraining.
Limitations and Future Work
- Model Size: The study was limited to T5 and FLANT5 models, which are smaller than state-of-the-art decoder-only large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3. The findings might not directly translate to these larger models.
- Language: The research was conducted solely on English-language documents, limiting the generalizability of the findings to other languages.
- Future Work: The authors suggest further research into how to better leverage different types of causal knowledge together and exploring aspects of plans that are particularly well-captured through cross-domain causal understanding. They also emphasize the need for extensive testing before deploying models trained with these methods.
Summary updated