On the stability of one-particle states generated by quantum fields fulfilling Yang—Feldman equations

Hanno GottschalkReports 2001 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical proof that in standard quantum field theory (QFT), a one-particle state is inherently stable if the theory obeys the positivity of the state space metric. Utilizing the Yang-Feldman equations to describe field behavior at infinite time, the author demonstrates that a particle cannot decay into any other state—even in the absence of a mass gap in the spectrum—unless the underlying geometry of the state space is indefinite. A counter-example is provided to show that in indefinite metric theories, such decays can occur, emphasizing the role of metric positivity in physical stability.

Introduction

In particle physics, the stability of fundamental particles like the electron is often taken as a given, provided conservation laws are satisfied. Mathematically, this stability is typically ensured by assuming an "isolated mass shell"—a gap in the energy spectrum between the single-particle state and the multi-particle continuum. However, this research explores whether stability can be derived from more fundamental principles without assuming such a gap. Specifically, it investigates whether the Yang-Feldman equations, which relate interacting fields to asymptotic free "in" and "out" fields, combined with the Klein-Gordon equation, are sufficient to guarantee that a one-particle "in-state" remains identical to a one-particle "out-state."

Methods

The study is conducted within the framework of Wightman Quantum Field Theory, a mathematically rigorous approach to QFT. The author employs several key mathematical tools:

  1. Yang-Feldman Postulate: Interacting fields $\phi(x)$ are expressed as the sum of an asymptotic free field and a term involving the "current" $j(x)$ convolved with a Green's function.
  2. Fourier Analysis: The proof hinges on the analysis of Fourier transforms of fields, specifically looking at "on-shell" singularities where $k^2 = m^2$.
  3. Källén-Lehmann Representation: This representation is used to link field operators to physical states by decomposing the two-point function into a spectral measure.
  4. Proof by Contradiction: The author assumes a decay transition occurs and shows this leads to a specific singularity in the current's matrix elements that is mathematically incompatible with a positive-definite Hilbert space.

Key Insights and Results

The central insight of this work is the "Power of Positivity." The requirement that all physical states have a positive probability (a positive-definite metric) is what prevents decay. In such a space, the "on-shell" singularities of the field are too robust to be smoothed out by the theory's spectral measure. This generalizes the concept of stability; while traditional views suggest a particle of mass $m$ cannot decay into two particles of mass $\mu$ if $m < 2\mu$, this work shows that in a positive metric theory, a one-particle state cannot transition into any other state, regardless of the spectrum.

Theorem 1 and the Indefinite Metric Counter-Example

The primary result is Theorem 1, which states that in any QFT with a positive metric, the Yang-Feldman and Klein-Gordon equations imply that the one-particle "in" and "out" states are identical ($\phi^{in}(x)\Psi_0 = \phi^{out}(x)\Psi_0$), ensuring perfect stability.

To demonstrate the necessity of the positivity assumption, the author constructs a counter-example involving an indefinite metric. In this model, a particle of mass $m$ is shown to be capable of decaying into two particles of mass $\mu$, even while satisfying the Yang-Feldman equations.

A decay process $m \to 2\mu$ which is forbidden in positive-metric theories but possible in indefinite-metric models.

This counter-example proves that positivity is not merely a technical requirement but a physical necessity for the stability observed in nature. In theories with an indefinite metric, the energy-time uncertainty relation can effectively be "violated" in a way that allows for non-trivial decay reactions that would be forbidden in standard Hilbert spaces.

Limitations and Future Work

The current proof assumes a Hermitian scalar field for simplicity. While the logic is expected to hold for vector or spinor fields, formal extensions are required. Additionally, the results are particularly relevant for theories that are not asymptotically complete—where "in" and "out" states do not span the entire Hilbert space—though the full implications for such systems remain to be explored. The application of the indefinite metric findings to real-world phenomena, such as ghost states in gauge theories or quantum gravity models, remains a significant area for future discussion in the mathematical physics community.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{gottschalk2001stability,
  author = {Hanno Gottschalk},
  title = {{On the stability of one-particle states generated by quantum fields fulfilling Yang—Feldman equations}},
  booktitle = {Reports},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1016/s0034-4877(01)80039-2},
}
Figure