On the Role of Oral Configurations in European Portuguese Nasal Vowels

Conceição Cunha, Samuel Silva, António Teixeira, Catarina Oliveira, Paula Martins, Arun A. Joseph, Jens FrahmInterspeech 2019

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel quantitative method for analyzing real-time MRI data of speech, specifically focusing on European Portuguese nasal vowels. By meticulously examining vocal tract configurations, the study reveals that oral articulatory adjustments, particularly in tongue position, play a significant role in distinguishing nasal vowels from their oral counterparts, rather than solely relying on velar lowering.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how nasal vowels are produced is challenging because the velopharyngeal port (the opening between the oral and nasal cavities) significantly alters the acoustic properties of the vocal tract. While previous research has explored this, a systematic, quantitative analysis of the oral configurations associated with European Portuguese (EP) nasal vowels has been lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by developing and applying a robust method to real-time MRI data, seeking to clarify the interplay between velar movement and oral articulator adjustments in creating the nasal vowel contrast in EP.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in its advanced methodology for analyzing real-time MRI (RT-MRI) speech data. Key aspects include:

  • High-Framerate RT-MRI Acquisition: The study utilizes RT-MRI at a high frame rate (50 fps) to capture dynamic vocal tract movements. This is crucial for understanding the temporal aspects of articulation.
  • Automated Vocal Tract Contour Extraction: A previously developed method is employed to automatically extract vocal tract contours from the RT-MRI images. This allows for consistent and objective identification of the vocal tract shape.
  • Quantitative Articulatory Analysis Framework: The authors extend their prior work by developing a quantitative framework to analyze these contours. This framework normalizes differences in articulators (like the velum, tongue, and lips) and constrictions (degree and place) across different vowels.
  • Constriction Analysis: Beyond general articulator positions, the study specifically quantifies constriction locations (CL) and sagittal distances (CD) in key vocal tract regions (tongue tip, tongue dorsum, velum, tongue back).
  • "Closest Oral Counterpart" Metric: A novel aspect is the development of a metric to quantitatively determine which oral vowel is the closest articulatory match to a given nasal vowel, based on the analyzed parameters.

Datasets

The study uses a corpus of minimal pairs of oral and nasal vowels in European Portuguese. This corpus includes words with vowels like [i, e, E, a, O, o, u, 6] and their nasal counterparts [6~, e~, i~, o~, u~]. The data analyzed in this specific paper comes from two native EP speakers (one male, 31 years old; one male, 50 years old) from the central region of Portugal. This is part of a larger dataset collected from 16 native speakers (8 male, 8 female) for a broader experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oral Articulation is Key: The most significant finding is that oral articulatory adjustments, particularly in tongue height and position, are crucial for distinguishing EP nasal vowels from their oral counterparts. This suggests that the oral cavity plays a more active role than previously assumed, beyond just accommodating velar lowering.
  • Tongue Dorsum Adjustments: The study highlights specific changes in the tongue dorsum. For instance, nasal vowels like [6~] and [u~] show differences in tongue dorsum position compared to their oral counterparts, indicating a lowered tongue dorsum for [u~] and potentially for [6~] as well.
  • Pharyngeal Region Less Involved: Contrary to some expectations, the pharyngeal region appears to play a minimal role in differentiating EP nasal vowels from their oral counterparts, with few significant differences observed.
  • Velar Region: Subtle Changes: While velar lowering is a prerequisite for nasalization, the study found that the velar region itself shows less dramatic differences between nasal and oral vowels compared to oral articulator changes, with some exceptions.
  • [6~] vs. [6]/[a]: Significant Oropharyngeal Differences: The nasal vowel [6~] shows more substantial oropharyngeal adjustments compared to its oral counterparts [6] and [a] than other nasal/oral vowel pairs.

Key Results

  • Major Differences in Tongue Tip and Lip Aperture: The study identified major differences between nasal and oral vowels in the tongue tip (TT) and lip aperture (LA) regions.
  • [6~] and [a~] Show Pronounced Differences: The nasal vowels [6~] and [a~] exhibited more articulatory adjustments with respect to their oral congeners than the high vowels [i~] and [u~].
  • [6~] vs. [6]/[a]: Intermediate Tongue Blade Position: The nasal vowel [6~] displayed an intermediate tongue blade position between the oral vowels /a/ and /6/, and a wider pharyngeal region compared to both oral vowels.
  • [u~] and [o~] Show Lowered Tongue Dorsum: The nasal vowel [u~] showed a lower tongue dorsum position compared to [u], and similarly, [o~] tended to show a tongue dorsum position similar to [O].
  • Quantitative Metrics for "Closest Oral Counterpart": The analysis provided quantitative metrics to identify the closest oral counterpart for nasal vowels, highlighting [6] as the closest to [6~] and [o] as the closest to [o~] for both speakers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Speaker Data: The current analysis focuses on only two speakers, which the authors acknowledge is a preliminary step. They plan to extend the analysis to the full database of 16 speakers.
  • Focus on Stop Consonants: The study primarily examined nasal vowels in the context of stop consonants. Future work could explore other consonantal contexts.
  • Dynamic Pattern and Gestural Timing: While the method allows for quantitative analysis, future research will focus on the dynamic patterns of nasal vowel production and gestural timing.
  • Improvements in Visualization and Metrics: The authors suggest further improvements in visualization techniques and the introduction of additional metrics to enhance the proposed framework.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cunha2019role,
  author = {Conceição Cunha and Samuel Silva and António Teixeira and Catarina Oliveira and Paula Martins and Arun A. Joseph and Jens Frahm},
  title = {{On the Role of Oral Configurations in European Portuguese Nasal Vowels}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure