On the role of asymmetric molecular geometry in high-performance organic solar cells

Jinfeng Huang, Tianyi Chen, Le Mei, Mengting Wang, Yuxuan Zhu, Jiting Cui, Yanni Ouyang, Youwen Pan, Zhaozhao Bi, Wei Ma, Zaifei Ma, Haiming Zhu, Chunfeng Zhang, Xiankai Chen, Hongzheng Chen, Lijian ZuoNature Communications 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that asymmetric molecular design in non-fullerene acceptors (NFAs) for organic solar cells (OSCs) significantly boosts open-circuit voltage (Voc) by reducing non-radiative recombination. This is achieved through more diverse donor-acceptor (D:A) interfacial interactions, leading to higher charge-transfer states and suppressed triplet exciton formation, ultimately yielding a champion efficiency of 18.80%.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic solar cells (OSCs) hold immense promise for flexible, low-cost energy generation, but their performance still lags behind inorganic counterparts. While asymmetric molecular design has been a successful strategy for improving OSC efficiency, the precise correlation between molecular geometry and optoelectronic properties has remained unclear. This ambiguity makes it challenging to design new materials effectively, as asymmetry often introduces confounding variations in energy levels, molecular packing, and morphology. This study aims to isolate and elucidate the specific role of molecular asymmetry in high-performance OSCs by creating carefully controlled experimental conditions.

Methods

The researchers designed and synthesized six pairs of symmetric and asymmetric non-fullerene acceptors (NFAs) that were identical in their physical and optoelectronic properties, as well as film morphology. This crucial step allowed them to isolate the effect of molecular asymmetry. They employed a range of characterization techniques, including:

  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations: To predict and confirm energy levels (HOMO/LUMO) and molecular structures.
  • Cyclic Voltammetry (CV) and UV-Vis spectroscopy: To experimentally verify energy levels and optical properties.
  • Grazing-Incidence Wide-Angle X-ray Scattering (GIWAXS): To analyze molecular packing and film morphology.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): To assess surface morphology.
  • Device fabrication and characterization: Including J-V curves, external quantum efficiency (EQE), and photocurrent density (Jph) vs. effective voltage (Veff) measurements.
  • Photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy: To study charge transfer efficiency.
  • Femtosecond Transient Absorption Spectroscopy (TAS): To probe ultrafast charge transfer dynamics and exciton behavior.
  • All-atom Molecular Dynamics (AA-MD) simulations: To investigate detailed D:A interfacial interactions and molecular packing at the nanoscale.
  • Electrostatic Potential (ESP) calculations: To understand intermolecular interactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the design, synthesis, and characterization of novel materials and their performance in devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Asymmetry is a powerful tool for boosting Voc: Even with identical energy levels and morphology, asymmetric NFAs consistently yielded higher Voc compared to their symmetric counterparts. This suggests asymmetry directly impacts charge recombination dynamics.
  • Diverse D:A interactions are key: Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that asymmetric NFAs create a richer variety of molecular interaction patterns at the donor-acceptor interface. This increased diversity is linked to improved device performance.
  • Higher charge-transfer states matter: The asymmetric design leads to higher D:A interfacial charge-transfer (CT) state energies. This higher energy barrier for charge recombination is a primary driver for the increased Voc.
  • Triplet exciton suppression: Asymmetric structures effectively suppress the formation of triplet excitons, which are known pathways for non-radiative energy loss. This further contributes to reduced recombination and higher Voc.
  • Trade-offs exist, but asymmetry can optimize: While asymmetric NFAs with straight side chains showed slightly lower short-circuit current density (Jsc), those with branched side chains demonstrated a better balance of charge generation, recombination, and transport, leading to superior overall efficiency.

Key Results

  • Champion Efficiency: The best-performing device, utilizing the asymmetric NFA PM6:BO-EH-ACI, achieved a power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 18.80%, which is among the best results for binary OSCs.
  • Increased Voc: Asymmetric NFA-based devices universally showed a higher Voc (approximately 10 mV increase) compared to their symmetric counterparts.
  • Reduced Non-radiative Recombination: This was evidenced by higher EQEEL (electroluminescence quantum efficiency) and lower AV3 (non-radiative recombination loss) in asymmetric NFA devices.
  • Higher CT Energy: The asymmetric PM6:BO-EH-ACI blend exhibited a higher charge-transfer state energy (ECT = 1.420 eV) compared to the symmetric PM6:BO-EH-SCI (ECT = 1.390 eV).
  • Improved Charge Mobility: Asymmetric acceptors with branched side chains showed slightly improved and more balanced hole and electron mobilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Confounding factors: The authors acknowledge that while they meticulously controlled for many variables, it can still be challenging to completely disentangle the effects of molecular geometry from subtle variations in energetic structures.
  • Side-chain influence: The study highlights that side-chain structure plays a significant role in determining charge mobility, suggesting that optimizing both asymmetry and side-chain architecture is crucial.
  • Future Directions: The work strongly suggests that manipulating D:A interfacial structures through asymmetric molecular design is a promising avenue for future OSC development. Further research could focus on exploring a wider range of asymmetric designs and their impact on interfacial energetics and charge dynamics to push OSC performance even higher. The authors also propose that understanding the interplay between CT energy, triplet exciton formation, and D:A interfacial interactions is key for designing next-generation high-performance OSCs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although asymmetric molecular design has been widely demonstrated effective for organic photovoltaics (OPVs), the correlation between asymmetric molecular geometry and their optoelectronic properties is still unclear. To access this issue, we have designed and synthesized several symmetric-asymmetric non-fullerene acceptors (NFAs) pairs with identical physical and optoelectronic properties. Interestingly, we found that the asymmetric NFAs universally exhibited increased open-circuit voltage compared to their symmetric counterparts, due to the reduced non-radiative charge recombination. From our molecular-dynamic simulations, the asymmetric NFA naturally exhibits more diverse molecular interaction patterns at the donor (D):acceptor (A) interface as compared to the symmetric ones, as well as higher D:A interfacial charge-transfer state energy. Moreover, it is observed that the asymmetric structure can effectively suppress triplet state formation. These advantages enable a best efficiency of 18.80%, which is one of the champion results among binary OPVs. Therefore, this work unambiguously demonstrates the unique advantage of asymmetric molecular geometry, unveils the underlying mechanism, and highlights the manipulation of D:A interface as an important consideration for future molecular design.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2024role,
  author = {Jinfeng Huang and Tianyi Chen and Le Mei and Mengting Wang and Yuxuan Zhu and Jiting Cui and Yanni Ouyang and Youwen Pan and Zhaozhao Bi and Wei Ma and Zaifei Ma and Haiming Zhu and Chunfeng Zhang and Xiankai Chen and Hongzheng Chen and Lijian Zuo},
  title = {{On the role of asymmetric molecular geometry in high-performance organic solar cells}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-47707-5},
}
Figure