Abstract: It is not currently clear how important it will be to include conservative self-force (SF) corrections in the models for extreme-mass-ratio inspiral (EMRI) waveforms that will be used to detect such signals in LISA (Laser Interferometer Space Antenna) data. These proceedings address this issue for circular-equatorial inspirals using an approximate EMRI model that includes conservative corrections at leading post-Newtonian order. We present estimates of the magnitude of the parameter estimation errors that would result from omitting conservative corrections and compare these to the errors that arise from noise fluctuations in the detector. We also use this model to explore the relative importance of the second-order radiative piece of the SF, which is not presently known.
1. Introduction
Extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs) occur when a compact object (CO), such as a stellar-mass black hole or neutron star, spirals into a supermassive black hole (SMBH). The gravitational waves (GWs) emitted during this process are a primary target for the future Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). A significant challenge in modeling these signals is the "gravitational self-force" (SF)—the effect of the CO's own gravitational field on its trajectory. This paper investigates whether simplified "kludge" models, which often ignore conservative SF corrections, are sufficient for accurate parameter estimation or if they introduce unacceptable systematic biases.
2. Methodology
The study utilizes a Numerical Kludge (NK) waveform model, which combines exact particle trajectories in curved spacetime with simplified wave-emission formulas. To enhance the model's physical accuracy, the authors incorporated:
- First-order radiative self-force: Accounting for orbital shrinkage due to GW emission.
- Conservative self-force corrections: Approximated using Post-Newtonian (PN) theory up to 2PN order to account for orbital frequency shifts.
- Fisher Information Matrix: Used to predict parameter estimation uncertainties given expected LISA noise levels.
- Monte Carlo Simulations: Thousands of simulations were performed with varying source positions and orientations to compare model-induced errors against detector noise.
The synthetic population modeled consists of a $10^6 M_\odot$ SMBH and a $10 M_\odot$ CO at a distance of 1 Gpc.
3. Results: Noise-Induced Error Distributions
A primary goal was to establish the baseline precision of LISA for EMRI detections. For a typical source with a Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of 30, the simulations show that LISA can measure the masses and spins of the black holes with high fractional accuracy, typically in the range of $10^{-4}$ to $10^{-3.5}$.
As shown in Figure 4, the noise-induced error distributions for SMBH mass, SMBH spin, CO mass, and initial inspiral radius peak at values that suggest high precision is achievable, provided the underlying waveform models are accurate.
4. The Impact of Model Errors
The authors define a ratio $R$ of model-induced error to noise-induced error. If $R > 1$, the systematic errors from the simplified model exceed the statistical errors from detector noise, potentially leading to incorrect physical conclusions.
Key findings include:
- Detection vs. Estimation: Simplified models are generally adequate for signal detection (finding the EMRI), but they often fail for parameter estimation (measuring the system's properties).
- Mass Sensitivity: For lighter COs like neutron stars, noise usually dominates ($R < 1$). However, for stellar-mass black hole inspirals, model errors frequently exceed noise errors ($R > 1$), making high-precision self-force corrections essential.
- 2PN Sufficiency: While conservative corrections are necessary, the study suggests that improvements beyond the 2PN order may offer diminishing returns for current precision requirements.
5. Limitations and Future Work
This study focused on circular-equatorial orbits, the simplest case. Real-world EMRIs are expected to be eccentric and inclined, which significantly increases waveform complexity. Additionally, the "kludge" model relies on weak-field approximations that may degrade in the strong-field regime near the event horizon. Finally, the unknown "second-order radiative" piece of the self-force may be as significant as the conservative effects studied, representing a critical area for future theoretical development.
Summary updated