ON THE PROBABILITY OF RUIN IN A CONTINUOUS RISK MODEL WITH DELAYED CLAIMS

Wei Zou, Jiehua XieJournal of the Korean Mathematical Society 2013 · DOI

Abstract

This paper investigates a continuous-time risk model characterized by two types of dependent claims: main claims and by-claims. Unlike traditional models where claims are independent or delays are constant, this research introduces a state-dependent delay mechanism where the occurrence of a by-claim is delayed based on the magnitude of the associated main claim. Utilizing integro-differential equations, Laplace transforms, and Rouché’s theorem, the authors derive a closed-form solution for the survival probability. Furthermore, the survival probability is shown to satisfy a defective renewal equation. For scenarios involving exponential claim sizes, explicit formulas are provided, and numerical examples illustrate the sensitivity of the model to various parameters.

Introduction

In classical actuarial science, the Cramer-Lundberg model serves as the foundation for ruin theory, typically assuming that claims occur as independent and identically distributed events. However, real-world insurance scenarios often involve secondary impacts. For instance, a major automobile accident (the main claim) may trigger subsequent legal or medical expenses (by-claims).

While previous literature has explored delayed claims, it often assumes the probability of delay is a fixed constant. This paper addresses a more sophisticated and realistic scenario: state-dependent delay. In this framework, the delay of a secondary claim is contingent upon the severity of the primary event. By modeling this dependency, the research provides a more accurate representation of how large-scale catastrophes impact an insurer's surplus over time.

The Risk Model and Delay Mechanism

The core innovation of this model is the introduction of a threshold mechanism, $B$. The interaction between main claims ($Y_i$) and by-claims ($Z_i$) is defined as follows:

  1. Immediate Settlement: If the main claim amount $Y_i$ is less than the threshold $B$, the by-claim $Z_i$ occurs simultaneously with the main claim.
  2. Delayed Settlement: If $Y_i$ exceeds or equals $B$, the by-claim $Z_i$ is delayed and occurs at the time of the next main claim event.

This structure effectively mimics administrative and legal bottlenecks where larger, more complex claims require longer settlement periods, thereby spreading the financial impact across multiple time intervals.

Methodology

To solve for the survival probability $\Phi(u)$—the probability that the surplus never falls below zero given an initial capital $u$—the authors employ a multi-step analytical approach:

1. Integro-Differential Equations

The authors construct a system of integro-differential equations to describe the surplus process. To account for the recursive nature of the delays, they introduce an auxiliary survival function, $\Phi_1(u)$, which represents the survival probability when a delayed claim is already pending at the start of the observation period.

2. Laplace Transforms and Rouché’s Theorem

By applying Laplace transforms to the system of equations, the authors move the problem from the time domain to the $s$-domain. A critical challenge in this step is determining the boundary constants (the probability of survival with zero initial capital). The authors utilize Rouché’s Theorem to prove the existence of unique roots within the complex plane, which allows for the determination of these essential constants.

3. Defective Renewal Equations

The research demonstrates that the survival probability can be expressed as a defective renewal equation. This is a significant finding because it aligns the complex dependent model with standard risk theory frameworks, facilitating easier numerical computation and the use of compound geometric distribution solutions.

Key Insights and Results

The Impact of Delay on Stability

One of the most compelling findings is that the survival probability is an increasing function of the delay probability. In this model, the delay of a claim effectively "spreads out" the financial burden. Under the right conditions, this delay can actually stabilize the insurance portfolio in the short term by preventing a massive, simultaneous drain on the surplus.

Closed-Form Solutions for Exponential Distributions

For the specific case where claim sizes follow an exponential distribution, the paper provides explicit, ready-to-use formulas for $\Phi(u)$. These formulas allow practitioners to calculate ruin probabilities without needing to solve complex integral equations from scratch.

Numerical Sensitivity

Numerical simulations highlight the importance of the threshold $B$. As the threshold for delay decreases (meaning more claims are categorized as "large" and thus delayed), the non-ruin probability generally increases. For example, simulations showed that increasing the initial surplus $u$ from 0 to 10 could improve the survival probability from approximately 18% to nearly 80%, demonstrating the high sensitivity of the model to initial capital and delay parameters.

Limitations and Future Research

While the model provides a significant step forward, it operates under certain constraints:

  • Fixed Delay Timing: The model assumes a delayed claim occurs exactly at the time of the next main claim. Future iterations could explore delays that span multiple periods or occur independently of future claim timings.
  • Distributional Constraints: While the framework is theoretically general, the explicit solutions rely on the Exponential distribution. Deriving results for "heavy-tailed" distributions, which are more representative of catastrophic "black swan" events, remains a challenge.
  • Economic Factors: The current model does not incorporate the effects of inflation or interest rates on the surplus, both of which are vital for long-term actuarial planning.

Conclusion

This paper advances ruin theory by successfully integrating state-dependent delays into a continuous-time risk model. By proving that such a model still follows a defective renewal structure, the authors provide both a theoretical foundation and practical tools for insurers to better understand the risks associated with complex, multi-stage claim settlements.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we consider a continuous time risk model involving two types of dependent claims, namely main claims and by-claims. The by-claim is induced by the main claim and the occurrence of by-claim may be delayed depending on associated main claim amount. Using Rouch<TEX>$\acute{e}$</TEX>'s theorem, we first derive the closed-form solution for the Laplace transform of the survival probability in the dependent risk model from an integro-differential equations system. Then, using the Laplace transform, we derive a defective renewal equation satisfied by the survival probability. For the exponential claim sizes, we present the explicit formula for the survival probability. We also illustrate the influence of the model parameters in the dependent risk model on the survival probability by numerical examples.
BibTeX
@article{zou2013probability,
  author = {Wei Zou and Jiehua Xie},
  title = {{ON THE PROBABILITY OF RUIN IN A CONTINUOUS RISK MODEL WITH DELAYED CLAIMS}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Mathematical Society},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.4134/jkms.2013.50.1.111},
}

Loading related content...

Figure