On the Performance of Transmit Antenna Selection Based on Shadowing Side Information★

Ahmet Turan Yılmaz, Ferkan Yılmaz, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini2016

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new transmit antenna selection (TAS) technique that leverages "shadowing side information" (SSI) instead of instantaneous channel state information (CSI). This approach significantly reduces the reliance on high-rate feedback channels and simplifies receiver complexity, while still achieving performance gains in generalized-K fading channels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In modern wireless systems, multiple antennas at the transmitter can boost performance, but they also increase cost and complexity due to the need for multiple radio frequency (RF) chains. Transmit Antenna Selection (TAS) offers a solution by using only one RF chain and selecting the "best" antenna. Traditional TAS methods rely on the receiver estimating the instantaneous Channel State Information (CSI) for all transmit antennas and sending the index of the best antenna back to the transmitter. This requires a high-rate feedback channel, which is often a bottleneck in wireless systems. Furthermore, CSI fluctuates rapidly, making it difficult to maintain accurate selection. This paper addresses the need for a TAS scheme that is less demanding on feedback resources and more robust to rapid channel variations.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the use of Shadowing Side Information (SSI) for TAS. Instead of relying on the instantaneous fading coefficient (CSI), the proposed method selects the transmit antenna that has the strongest "shadowing coefficient." Shadowing is a slower-changing phenomenon than fading, representing larger-scale obstructions like buildings. By using SSI, the system can:

  • Reduce feedback frequency: Since shadowing changes slowly, the selected antenna index needs to be updated less often.
  • Simplify receiver complexity: The receiver only needs to estimate the CSI of the selected antenna for demodulation, rather than all antennas for selection.
  • Analyze performance in Generalized-K fading: The paper derives exact and closed-form expressions for key performance metrics like outage probability, moment-generating function (MGF), signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) moments, and symbol error probability (SEP) under an independent but not identically distributed (i.n.d.) Generalized-K composite fading model.
  • Investigate diversity order and array gain: Asymptotic expressions are derived to understand the system's diversity order and array gain.

The mathematical framework involves deriving CDFs, PDFs, and MGFs for the selected SNR, leveraging properties of Gamma and Bessel functions, and employing the Meijer-G function for complex derivations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on theoretical derivations and Monte Carlo simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shadowing as a stable selection criterion: The paper demonstrates that using the slower-changing shadowing coefficient as a basis for antenna selection can be a practical and effective alternative to relying on rapidly fluctuating CSI.
  • Reduced feedback overhead: This is a significant practical advantage, as feedback channels are often a limiting factor in wireless system design.
  • Simplified receiver design: Offloading the selection decision based on SSI simplifies the receiver's processing requirements.
  • Performance gains in challenging fading: The Generalized-K fading model, which combines Gamma and K distributions, represents a realistic scenario for many wireless environments, and the proposed TAS scheme shows performance improvements in this context.
  • Trade-off between shadowing and fading parameters: The paper highlights how the relative strengths of shadowing (characterized by $m_\alpha$) and fading (characterized by $m_\beta$) influence the achievable diversity gain and array gain. In cases of severe shadowing ($m_\alpha$ is low), the system can achieve diversity gain.

Key Results

  • Exact and closed-form expressions: The paper provides comprehensive analytical expressions for outage probability, MGF, SNR moments, and SEP for the proposed TAS scheme.
  • Performance improvement with more antennas: Numerical results show that increasing the number of transmit antennas ($L$) leads to improved outage probability and SEP. For instance, with $L=2, 3, 4$ antennas, the outage probability can be 9, 11, and 12 dB better than a single-antenna system, respectively, at a specific outage level.
  • Diversity and array gain: The analysis reveals that the system can achieve both array gain and diversity gain, with the diversity order being the minimum of the sum of shadowing parameters and the minimum of fading parameters.
  • Impact of shadowing severity: The performance improvement of TAS based on SSI is more pronounced in heavy shadowing conditions.
  • Validation: Theoretical results are validated by Monte Carlo simulations, showing excellent agreement.
  • Feedback error impact: Simulations indicate that feedback errors degrade performance, but the degradation is manageable with low error probabilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The analysis assumes an error-free and delay-free feedback channel for the antenna index. The impact of feedback errors is investigated through simulations but is not part of the core theoretical derivation.
  • Correlation: The paper briefly touches upon the impact of correlation between shadowing coefficients, noting that increased correlation reduces the performance gain. Further investigation into correlated shadowing scenarios could be beneficial.
  • Channel Models: While Generalized-K fading is considered, exploring other realistic fading models and their impact on the proposed TAS scheme would be valuable.
  • Distributed Systems: The paper mentions potential applications in distributed transmit antenna systems, suggesting future work in this area.
  • Optimization: Exploring more sophisticated antenna selection criteria or adaptive selection strategies based on SSI could lead to further performance enhancements.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, a transmit antenna selection scheme, which is based on shadowing side information, is investigated. In this scheme, the selected single transmit antenna provides the highest shadowing coefficient between a transmitter and a receiver. By the proposed technique, the frequency of the usage of the feedback channel from the receiver to the transmitter and channel estimation complexity at the receiver can be reduced. We study the performance of our proposed technique, and in the analysis, we consider an independent but not identically distributed generalized- <i xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">K</i> composite fading model. More specifically, exact and closed-form expressions for the outage probability, the moment-generating function, the moments of signal-to-noise ratio, and the average symbol error probability (SEP) are derived. In addition, asymptotic outage probability and SP expressions are also presented to investigate the diversity order and the array gain. Finally, our theoretical performance results are validated by Monte Carlo simulations.
BibTeX
@misc{ylmaz2016performance,
  author = {Ahmet Turan Yılmaz and Ferkan Yılmaz and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Performance of Transmit Antenna Selection Based on Shadowing Side Information★}},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure