On the Online Weighted Non-Crossing Matching Problem

Joan Boyar, Shahin Kamali, Kim S. Larsen, Ali Mohammad Lavasani, Yaqiao Li, Denis PankratovSWAT 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "Online Weighted Non-Crossing Matching" problem, where points with weights arrive sequentially, and an algorithm must match them with non-intersecting lines to maximize total weight. They show deterministic algorithms struggle without restrictions, but randomization offers a constant competitive ratio, and allowing edge revocations enables a deterministic algorithm with a constant ratio.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine points appearing one by one on a screen, each with a certain "value" (weight). Your job is to connect these points with straight lines, but with a crucial rule: no two lines can cross. The twist is that you don't know all the points in advance; they arrive online. When a new point appears, you must decide immediately whether to match it with an existing unmatched point or leave it alone. This decision is final (in the basic model). The goal is to maximize the total value of all the points you successfully match. This problem, known as the Online Weighted Non-Crossing Matching (OWNM) problem, is relevant in areas like computational geometry and even has connections to biological structures like RNA. The challenge lies in making optimal decisions with incomplete information while adhering to the non-crossing constraint.

Methods

The paper explores several scenarios to find effective algorithms:

  • Restricted Weights: When point weights are confined to a known range [1, U], they develop a deterministic algorithm called "Wait-and-Match" (Wam) and prove it achieves a competitive ratio of $\Omega(2^{-2\sqrt{\log U}})$. They also establish a matching lower bound of $O(2^{-\sqrt{\log U}})$.
  • Randomization: Surprisingly, even without weight restrictions, randomization alone is sufficient. They introduce a randomized algorithm, "Tree-Guided-Matching" (TGM), which guarantees a competitive ratio of at least 1/3. They also prove a lower bound of 16/17 for randomized algorithms in the unweighted case.
  • Revocable Acceptances: If algorithms are allowed to "undo" previous matches (revoke acceptances), they present a deterministic algorithm, "Big-Improvement-Match" (Bim), that achieves a constant competitive ratio of approximately 0.2862. They also show that even with revocations, deterministic algorithms cannot beat a ratio of 2/3 in the unweighted case.
  • Advice Complexity: For the problem with advice (where an oracle provides limited pre-computed information), they propose an algorithm called "Split-And-Match" (Sam) that achieves perfect matching using advice strings related to Catalan numbers, improving upon previous bounds.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is defined on abstract point sequences in the Euclidean plane, not on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Deterministic algorithms struggle without constraints: The paper highlights that for the general weighted online non-crossing matching problem, deterministic algorithms can't guarantee a good outcome. This is a fundamental limitation that necessitates exploring other approaches.
  • Randomization is surprisingly powerful: The fact that randomization alone can achieve a constant competitive ratio (1/3) for the weighted problem, even without weight restrictions, is a significant finding. It suggests that introducing controlled randomness can effectively navigate the uncertainty of online arrivals.
  • Revocations offer a deterministic path to constant ratio: While revocations don't improve the ratio for the unweighted case, they unlock a deterministic algorithm with a constant competitive ratio for the weighted problem. This shows that the ability to correct past decisions can be very valuable.
  • Catalan numbers for advice complexity: The connection to Catalan numbers for the advice-based algorithm is elegant and suggests a deep structural property of the problem that can be exploited for efficient advice encoding.

Key Results

  • Restricted Weights: Deterministic algorithm "Wam" achieves $\Omega(2^{-2\sqrt{\log U}})$ competitive ratio, with a lower bound of $O(2^{-\sqrt{\log U}})$.
  • Randomization: Randomized algorithm "TGM" achieves a 1/3 competitive ratio. A lower bound of 16/17 is shown for randomized algorithms in the unweighted case.
  • Revocable Acceptances: Deterministic algorithm "Bim" achieves a ≈ 0.2862 competitive ratio. A lower bound of 2/3 is shown for deterministic algorithms with revoking in the unweighted case.
  • Advice Complexity: Algorithm "Sam" achieves optimal matching with advice complexity related to Catalan numbers ($C_n$), improving upon prior bounds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bounds are not tight: The paper explicitly mentions that the bounds for competitive ratios in several scenarios are not tight, leaving room for improvement.
  • Generalizing results: The authors suggest exploring other variations of the problem, such as allowing a limited number of crossings or considering edge-weighted versions.
  • Further analysis of randomized algorithms: While a 1/3 ratio is achieved, further investigation into tighter bounds for randomized algorithms, especially in the weighted case, is warranted.
  • Understanding the "Big-Improvement-Match" algorithm: The deterministic algorithm with revocations achieves a constant ratio, but its complexity and the exact nature of the constant (≈ 0.2862) could be further analyzed and potentially improved.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce and study the weighted version of an online matching problem in the Euclidean plane with non-crossing constraints: 2n points with non-negative weights arrive online, and an algorithm can match an arriving point to one of the unmatched previously arrived points. In the vanilla model, the decision on how to match (if at all) a newly arriving point is irrevocable. The goal is to maximize the total weight of matched points under the constraint that straight-line segments corresponding to the edges of the matching do not intersect. The unweighted version of the problem was introduced in the offline setting by Atallah in 1985, and this problem became a subject of study in the online setting with and without advice in several recent papers. We observe that deterministic online algorithms cannot guarantee a non-trivial competitive ratio for the weighted problem. We study various regimes of the problem which permit non-trivial online algorithms. In particular, when weights are restricted to the interval [1, U] we give a deterministic algorithm achieving competitive ratio Ω(2^{-2√{log U}}). We also prove that deterministic online algorithms cannot achieve competitive ratio better than O (2^{-√{log U}}). Interestingly, we establish that randomization alone suffices to achieve competitive ratio 1/3 even when there are no restrictions on the weights. Additionally, if one allows an online algorithm to revoke acceptances, then one can achieve a competitive ratio ≈ 0.2862 deterministically for arbitrary weights. We also establish a lower bound on the competitive ratio of randomized algorithms in the unweighted setting, and improve the best-known bound on advice complexity to achieve a perfect matching.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{boyar2024online,
  author = {Joan Boyar and Shahin Kamali and Kim S. Larsen and Ali Mohammad Lavasani and Yaqiao Li and Denis Pankratov},
  title = {{On the Online Weighted Non-Crossing Matching Problem}},
  booktitle = {SWAT},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=iBhmD9cmDW},
}
Figure