On the Fast Radio Burst and Persistent Radio Source Populations

Casey Law, Liam Connor, K.k. AggarwalThe Astrophysical Journal 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the relationship between Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) and Persistent Radio Sources (PRS), proposing a new definition for PRS and analyzing their prevalence. The study suggests that PRS might be a significant, previously underappreciated population of radio sources, potentially including misidentified active galactic nuclei (AGN).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are enigmatic, millisecond-duration radio transients originating from extragalactic distances. While initially thought to be cataclysmic events, the discovery of repeating FRBs and, crucially, the association of some FRBs with persistent radio sources (PRS) has opened up new avenues of research. However, the nature of these PRS and their connection to FRBs, particularly whether they are a common feature of FRB environments, remains unclear. This paper aims to address this by compiling and analyzing the properties of known FRB-PRS associations to better understand the populations involved and their implications for FRB origins.

Methods

The authors compiled a catalog of localized FRBs and their associated PRS properties, including luminosity and upper limits. They propose a practical definition for a PRS as an FRB-associated radio source with a spectral luminosity greater than $10^{29} \text{ erg s}^{-1} \text{ Hz}^{-1}$ that is not attributable to star formation activity in the host galaxy. They then used statistical modeling (binomial distributions) to assess the occurrence rate of PRS in repeating versus non-repeating FRBs. To estimate the density of FRB-emitting sources, they utilized CHIME/FRB event statistics to bound the mean per-source repetition rate and combined this with estimates of the volumetric FRB rate. Finally, they compared the inferred density and phenomenology of PRS to those of known extragalactic radio sources, particularly AGN.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from various radio surveys and observational campaigns, including:

  • Localized FRB sources with measured or limited PRS properties.
  • CHIME/FRB catalog data for repetition statistics.
  • Existing radio source catalogs (e.g., FIRST, VLASS, RACS) for population density estimates.
  • Published host galaxy properties for localized FRBs.

No new datasets were introduced in this paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Defined PRS: The paper provides a concrete, luminosity-based definition for Persistent Radio Sources associated with FRBs, helping to standardize future studies.
  • PRS Not Necessarily Tied to Repeaters: Contrary to initial intuition, the statistical analysis suggests there isn't strong evidence yet that repeating FRBs are preferentially associated with PRS compared to non-repeaters.
  • PRS as a New Radio Source Class: The study posits that PRS, with their specific luminosity and association with FRBs, represent a potentially significant, underappreciated class of extragalactic radio sources.
  • Phenomenological Similarity to "Wandering" AGN: The observed properties and estimated densities of PRS bear a striking resemblance to off-nuclear, "wandering" active galactic nuclei (AGN), suggesting a possible overlap or misidentification.
  • DMhost as a Potential Indicator: FRBs with both high host galaxy dispersion measure (DMhost) and high PRS luminosity, like FRB 121102 and FRB 190520, stand out and may be key targets for further investigation.

Key Results

  • The paper estimates the mean per-source repetition rate of FRBs to be between 25 and 440 yr$^{-1}$, based on CHIME/FRB data.
  • This leads to an estimated density of FRB-emitting sources in the local universe ranging from $2.2 \times 10^2$ to $5.2 \times 10^4$ Gpc$^{-3}$, assuming a pulsar-like beaming fraction.
  • The study implies that PRS could constitute up to 1% of compact, luminous radio sources in the local universe.
  • The volumetric density of PRS is estimated to be comparable to that of candidate "wandering" AGN in dwarf galaxies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Uncertainty: The current sample size of localized FRBs with PRS measurements is small, leading to significant uncertainties in the statistical conclusions, particularly regarding the association of PRS with repeating FRBs.
  • Observational Bias: While the authors attempt to account for potential biases, the detection and localization of FRBs and their PRS counterparts can still be influenced by observational sensitivities and survey footprints.
  • Definition Ambiguity: The distinction between PRS and certain types of AGN, especially off-nuclear ones, remains somewhat ambiguous and requires further investigation.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on:

  • Obtaining deeper radio imaging of more localized FRBs to better constrain PRS properties and search for new associations.
  • Further refining the statistical analysis with larger samples to confirm or refute the preferential association of PRS with repeating FRBs.
  • Investigating the physical mechanisms that could produce both FRBs and PRS, potentially linking them to specific astrophysical objects like magnetars or compact objects in AGN-like environments.
  • Clarifying the relationship between PRS and off-nuclear AGN through more detailed multiwavelength observations and theoretical modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The first fast radio burst (FRB) to be precisely localized was associated with a luminous persistent radio source (PRS). Recently, a second FRB/PRS association was discovered for another repeating source of FRBs. However, it is not clear what makes FRBs or PRS or how they are related. We compile FRB and PRS properties to consider the population of FRB/PRS sources. We suggest a practical definition for PRS as FRB associations with luminosity greater than 10 29 erg s −1 Hz −1 that are not attributed to star formation activity in the host galaxy. We model the probability distribution of the fraction of FRBs with PRS for repeaters and nonrepeaters, showing there is not yet evidence for repeaters to be preferentially associated with PRS. We discuss how FRB/PRS sources may be distinguished by the combination of active repetition and an excess dispersion measure local to the FRB environment. We use CHIME/FRB event statistics to bound the mean per-source repetition rate of FRBs to be between 25 and 440 yr −1 . We use this to provide a bound on the density of FRB-emitting sources in the local universe of between 2.2 × 10 2 and 5.2 × 10 4 Gpc −3 assuming a pulsar-like beamwidth for FRB emission. This density implies that PRS may comprise as much as 1% of compact, luminous radio sources detected in the local universe. The cosmic density and phenomenology of PRS are similar to that of the newly discovered, off-nuclear “wandering” active galactic nuclei (AGN). We argue that it is likely that some PRS have already been detected and misidentified as AGN.
BibTeX
@article{law2022fast,
  author = {Casey Law and Liam Connor and K.K. Aggarwal},
  title = {{On the Fast Radio Burst and Persistent Radio Source Populations}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ac4c42},
}
Figure