On the exponential convergence of the Kaczmarz algorithm

Liang Dai, Thomas B. SchönIEEE Signal Processing Letters 2014 · DOI · OpenReview

Abstract

The Kaczmarz algorithm (KA) is a foundational row-action method for solving systems of linear equations. While randomized variants have seen significant theoretical advancement, the deterministic cyclic Kaczmarz algorithm has remained more difficult to bound tightly. This paper presents a novel approach by reframing the KA as a discrete-time dynamical system. By applying stability analysis from control theory, we derive a new exponential convergence bound and demonstrate through partitioning strategies how these bounds can be tightened.

Introduction

Solving large-scale linear systems $Ax = b$ is a core challenge in numerical linear algebra, with applications ranging from signal processing to medical imaging. The Kaczmarz algorithm (KA) iteratively projects estimates onto the hyperplanes defined by the system's rows. Despite its simplicity, the convergence rate of the cyclic KA—where rows are processed in a fixed order—is highly sensitive to the matrix structure and row ordering. While the Randomized Kaczmarz Algorithm (RKA) offers well-understood convergence properties, providing tight theoretical guarantees for the cyclic version has been an ongoing challenge. This work bridges this gap by leveraging the tools of dynamical systems and stability theory.

Methodology

The primary innovation of this research lies in interpreting the iterative path of the Kaczmarz algorithm as the output of a dynamical system.

Dynamical Systems Mapping

The authors define an error vector $\theta_k$, representing the difference between the current estimate and the true solution. The evolution of this error over a full cycle of $m$ projections is modeled as a discrete time-varying linear system. By defining a "cycle operator" that encapsulates one complete pass through all equations, the convergence problem is transformed into an analysis of the spectral properties of this operator.

Stability Analysis and Partitioning

Using asymptotic stability results from control theory, the paper proves that the error vanishes exponentially. To improve the tightness of the resulting bounds, the authors introduce a matrix partitioning strategy. By grouping rows into non-overlapping sub-matrices, they derive a "product-based" bound. This approach acknowledges that the interaction between blocks of rows often provides a more accurate reflection of the algorithm's behavior than treating the matrix as a monolithic entity.

Results and Discussion

The theoretical findings were validated using synthetic numerical experiments. A system with $m=30$ equations and $n=3$ unknowns was generated using random Gaussian matrices with normalized rows. The performance of the cyclic KA and RKA was compared against the newly derived bounds ($KA_{BD1}$ and $KA_{BD2}$) and existing literature.

Convergence of KA and RKA compared to theoretical bounds. The left panel shows the overall error decay, while the right panel highlights the improvement offered by the partitioned bound (KABD2) over the basic bound (KABD1).

As illustrated in Figure 1, the actual performance of the KA (black line) and RKA (red line with dots) is significantly faster than the theoretical upper bounds. However, the partitioned bound ($KA_{BD2}$) provides a noticeably tighter estimate than the basic version ($KA_{BD1}$), particularly visible in the zoomed-in right panel. This confirms that accounting for row groupings captures more of the algorithm's dynamics. Furthermore, the new bound is shown to be superior to classical bounds, such as those derived from the Meany inequality, under specific conditions—notably when the matrix has small singular values.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that viewing optimization algorithms through the lens of control theory can yield powerful new insights. While the current bounds remain conservative due to approximations in the proof process, the dynamical systems framework provides a robust foundation for future analysis. Subsequent research may focus on identifying optimal partitioning strategies to further tighten these bounds and extending the framework to inconsistent or noisy systems where $Ax \approx b$.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Kaczmarz algorithm (KA) is a popular method for solving a system of linear equations. In this note we derive a new exponential convergence result for the KA. The key allowing us to establish the new result is to rewrite the KA in such a way that its solution path can be interpreted as the output from a particular dynamical system. The asymptotic stability results of the corresponding dynamical system can then be leveraged to prove exponential convergence of the KA. The new bound is also compared to existing bounds.
BibTeX
@article{dai2014exponential,
  author = {Liang Dai and Thomas B. Schön},
  title = {{On the exponential convergence of the Kaczmarz algorithm}},
  journal = {IEEE Signal Processing Letters},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1109/lsp.2015.2412253},
}
Figure