On the Convergence of Asynchronous Parallel Pattern Search

Tamara G. Kolda, Virginia TorczonSIAM J. Optim 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proves that an asynchronous version of the pattern search optimization algorithm, where individual search directions operate semi-autonomously, can still converge to a stationary point of the optimization problem. This is a significant theoretical result for parallel optimization, showing that the benefits of asynchronous processing (reduced idle time) can be achieved without sacrificing convergence guarantees.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional pattern search algorithms for optimization rely on tight synchronization between different search directions. This means that all search directions must complete their work and share information before any further progress can be made. While effective, this synchronization can lead to significant idle time, especially in parallel computing environments, as slower processes or communication delays can hold up the entire computation. The problem this paper addresses is how to design and analyze an asynchronous parallel pattern search algorithm that eliminates this synchronization bottleneck, allowing processes to work more independently, while still guaranteeing that the algorithm will eventually find a good solution (a stationary point of the objective function).

Methods

The authors extend the theoretical framework for analyzing synchronous pattern search algorithms to the asynchronous setting. The core of their approach involves:

  • Formalizing Asynchronous Behavior: They introduce a detailed mathematical model for asynchronous parallel pattern search (APPS), where each of the $p$ processes operates semi-autonomously. This involves defining "successful" and "unsuccessful" time steps for each process, and carefully tracking how the best-known point and step-length control parameter evolve over time.
  • Bounding Step-Length Control: A crucial element of their analysis is bounding the step-length control parameter. They show that even though individual processes might have outdated information, by ensuring that the step-length control parameter is bounded after any successful step (one that finds a lower function value), they can prove convergence.
  • Algebraic Structure of Iterates: They establish an algebraic structure for the iterates (the points generated by the algorithm), showing they lie on a rational lattice. This property is essential for proving convergence.
  • Subsequence Convergence: The proof relies on showing that certain subsequences of the step-length control parameters converge to zero. This is a standard technique in pattern search convergence proofs, but it's more complex in the asynchronous setting due to the independent nature of the processes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Asynchronism Doesn't Kill Convergence: The most significant insight is that by carefully managing the step-length control parameter and ensuring that information about improvements eventually propagates, asynchronous operation can be achieved without losing the guarantee of convergence to a stationary point.
  • The Importance of Bounding Step-Length: The analysis hinges on bounding the step-length control parameter. This parameter dictates how far the algorithm searches along a direction. If it can be shown to shrink sufficiently over time, it implies that the search is becoming more refined and is likely to converge.
  • Handling Outdated Information: The paper grapples with the challenge of processes having potentially outdated information about the best point found so far. The framework developed allows for this by focusing on the eventual dissemination of information and the consistent handling of tie-breaking.

Key Results

The paper proves that for an asynchronous parallel pattern search algorithm, a subsequence of the iterates converges to a stationary point of the objective function. This means that under standard assumptions (e.g., the objective function is continuously differentiable and the level set is bounded), the algorithm will eventually find a point where the gradient is zero.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for future work:

  • Changing Search Directions: The current analysis assumes a fixed set of search directions. Relaxing this to allow directions to change over time, as done in some earlier pattern search work, would be a practical extension.
  • Handling Process Failures: The current APPS implementation ignores process failures as long as the remaining active processes maintain a positive spanning set of directions. More robust handling of process failures could be explored.
  • Alternative Step-Length Control: The analysis relies on specific decrease conditions for successful steps. Exploring alternative mechanisms for controlling step-length, such as sufficient decrease conditions, could lead to more flexible algorithms.
  • Initial Conditions: The assumption that all processes start with the same initial iterate and step-length parameter is for convenience. Relaxing this would add complexity but might be more realistic.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kolda2004convergence,
  author = {Tamara G. Kolda and Virginia Torczon},
  title = {{On the Convergence of Asynchronous Parallel Pattern Search}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Optim.},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1137/s1052623401398107},
}
Figure