On the complexity of the middle curve problem

Maike Buchin, Nicole Funk, Amer KrivosijaarXiv 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "middle curve" problem, aiming to find a single representative curve for a set of input curves. The authors prove this problem is NP-complete, meaning finding an exact solution is computationally hard for large inputs. They also introduce approximation algorithms to find good-enough solutions more efficiently.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine you have data from multiple sources, like GPS tracks of migrating birds, that can be represented as sequences of points forming polygonal curves. How do you find a single "middle" curve that best represents the collective movement of all these birds? This is the essence of the "middle curve" problem. Previous work by Ahn et al. provided algorithms for this, but their running times were prohibitively exponential in the number of input curves. This paper investigates the fundamental computational limits of finding such a middle curve, asking: is there a more efficient way to solve this problem, or is it inherently difficult? They also explore how to find approximate solutions when exact solutions are too slow.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in its theoretical contributions.

  • NP-Completeness Proof: The authors establish that the "MIDDLE CURVE" problem (specifically, the UNORDERED MIDDLE CURVE problem) is NP-complete. This is a significant theoretical result, implying that no polynomial-time algorithm is likely to exist for finding an exact middle curve for all possible inputs. Their proof uses a reduction from the Shortest Common Supersequence (SCS) problem, a known NP-hard problem. They construct specific polygonal curves from sequences to demonstrate this hardness.
  • Parameterized Versions: They also consider parameterized versions of the problem, where the complexity is measured with respect to specific parameters like the number of input curves or the complexity of the middle curve itself.
  • Approximation Algorithms: For the parameterized version where the complexity of the middle curve is bounded, they present an approximation algorithm. This algorithm leverages existing approximation algorithms for the (k, l)-center problem on curves.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical complexity and algorithmic design, using constructed instances for proofs rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inherent Difficulty: The proof of NP-completeness is a major insight. It tells us that for the general middle curve problem, we shouldn't expect to find a perfectly optimal solution quickly for large numbers of input curves. This shifts the focus towards finding efficient approximate solutions.
  • Hierarchy of Middle Curve Problems: The paper clarifies the relationships between different variants of the middle curve problem (unordered, ordered, restricted) and shows that their NP-hardness extends across these variants.
  • Connection to SCS: The reduction from the Shortest Common Supersequence (SCS) problem is a clever way to leverage existing complexity results. It highlights how seemingly different problems can share underlying computational difficulties.
  • Approximation Guarantees: The development of a (2+ε)-approximation algorithm for the parameterized problem provides a practical way to obtain good solutions within a controlled error margin, especially when the desired middle curve is not too complex.

Key Results

  • NP-Completeness: The paper proves that the UNORDERED MIDDLE CURVE problem (and its variants) is NP-complete for both discrete and continuous Fréchet distances.
  • Parameterized Complexity: They show that the problem is W[1]-hard when parameterized by the number of input curves.
  • Approximation Algorithm: They present a (2+ε)-approximation algorithm for the PARAMETERIZED MIDDLE CURVE optimization problem (bounded middle curve complexity) for the discrete Fréchet distance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Open Question on FPT: While they show the problem is XP-time solvable when parameterized by the middle curve's complexity (meaning runtime is polynomial in input size but exponential in the parameter), they leave open whether the problem is fixed-parameter tractable (FPT) with respect to this parameter. This would mean a runtime that is only exponential in the parameter, but polynomial in the input size.
  • Continuous vs. Discrete Fréchet Distance: The paper addresses both discrete and continuous Fréchet distances, showing NP-completeness for both. The approximation algorithm is specifically for the discrete version, though the theoretical hardness results apply to both.
  • Practical Performance: The paper focuses on theoretical complexity and approximation guarantees. Further research could explore the practical performance of these algorithms on real-world data.

Summary updated

Abstract

For a set of curves, Ahn et al. introduced the notion of a middle curve and gave algorithms computing these with run time exponential in the number of curves. Here we study the computational complexity of this problem: we show that it is NP-complete and give approximation algorithms.
BibTeX
@misc{buchin2020complexity,
  author = {Maike Buchin and Nicole Funk and Amer Krivosija},
  title = {{On the complexity of the middle curve problem}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2001.10298},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10298},
}
Figure