On the Cis to Trans Isomerization of Prolyl–Peptide Bonds under Tension

Jian Chen, Scott Edwards, Frauke Gräter, Carsten BaldaufThe Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how mechanical tension can accelerate the cis-to-trans isomerization of prolyl-peptide bonds, crucial for protein folding dynamics. Using advanced QM/MM simulations, they show that stretching weakens the peptide bond, lowering the energy barrier and enabling faster isomerization, potentially acting as a force-modulated timer in biological processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteins fold into complex 3D structures, and the speed and pathways of this folding are critical for their function. A key element in protein folding is the prolyl-peptide bond, which can exist in either a cis or trans conformation. While the cis conformation is often found in protein turns and acts like a hinge, the isomerization between cis and trans states is typically slow due to a high rotational energy barrier. This slowness can be exploited by proteins to regulate folding or function. Previous studies suggested that mechanical forces, like those experienced in biological environments (e.g., blood flow), might influence this isomerization. However, the precise mechanism by which external force accelerates this process, especially considering the electronic changes involved in bond isomerization, remained unclear. This paper aims to elucidate this mechanism by simulating the cis-to-trans isomerization of a prolyl-peptide bond under applied tensile force.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated computational approach: Hybrid Quantum Mechanical/Molecular Mechanical (QM/MM) Force-Clamp Molecular Dynamics (FCMD) simulations.

  • Molecular Dynamics (MD): This is a standard technique to simulate the movement of atoms and molecules over time, allowing researchers to observe dynamic processes.
  • Force-Clamp: In this setup, a constant pulling force is applied to specific parts of the molecule (in this case, the alpha-carbon atoms of flanking residues). This mimics the experimental conditions of force spectroscopy.
  • QM/MM: This is the novel and crucial aspect. Standard MD simulations often use classical force fields that are not accurate enough to describe the electronic changes occurring during bond breaking and formation, which are central to isomerization. QM/MM overcomes this by treating a small, critical region of the molecule (the prolyl-peptide bond and its immediate surroundings) with highly accurate quantum mechanics (QM), while the rest of the system (the solvent and the rest of the peptide) is treated with faster, classical molecular mechanics (MM). This allows for a detailed description of the electronic effects involved in the isomerization process.

They specifically used the B3LYP/6-31G* hybrid functional for the QM region and the OPLS-AA force field for the MM region, simulating the peptide in a TIP4P water box.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on in silico simulations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Force as a Catalyst: Mechanical tension directly accelerates the cis-to-trans isomerization of prolyl-peptide bonds, overcoming the inherent slow rate at equilibrium.
  • Bond Weakening Mechanism: Under tension, the prolyl-peptide bond's character shifts from a partial double bond towards a single bond. This involves a reduction in electronic conjugation around the bond.
  • Transition State Dynamics: The isomerization proceeds through a non-planar transition state where the nitrogen atom of the peptide moiety adopts an sp³ hybridized, pyramidal state. This transient state is key to allowing the rotation.
  • Restoration of Character: Upon reaching the trans state, the bond character and planarity are restored, similar to the cis state but in the trans configuration.
  • Directionality: The isomerization consistently occurs via rotation from 0° to 180° (cis to trans), never through the negative angles, suggesting a preferred pathway dictated by peptide chirality and strain.
  • QM/MM Necessity: Pure molecular mechanics simulations fail to capture the essential electronic changes (hybridization and bond order shifts) that drive the isomerization, highlighting the importance of QM/MM for this problem.

Key Results

  • Force Threshold: Isomerization was observed within 500 ps at forces as low as 3 nN. Higher forces (4-5 nN) led to sub-picosecond transitions.
  • Lifetime-Force Relationship: The relationship between isomerization lifetime and applied force followed a linear Bell model, yielding a transition state distance (Δx) of approximately 0.02 nm.
  • Activation Energy: The simulations estimated an activation free energy of ~60 kJ/mol, consistent with experimental values for zero-force isomerization.
  • Structural Changes: The cis-to-trans transition involved a distinct jump in the distance between alpha-carbon atoms (dcaca) from ~0.35 nm to ~0.4 nm, and a rotation of the peptide bond torsion angle (@Ala-Pro) from 0° to 180°.
  • Nitrogen Hybridization: The volume of the tetrahedron formed by the nitrogen and its neighbors (VNCCaCs) showed a transient increase from ~0.15 ų to ~0.3 ų during isomerization, indicating the sp³ hybridization of nitrogen.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Extrapolation Uncertainty: The limited accessible timescales in QM/MM simulations introduce uncertainty when extrapolating to zero-force lifetimes and distinguishing between different kinetic models (e.g., Bell vs. Dudko-Hummer).
  • Force Application: The study used constant force, whereas experimental methods often employ constant velocity pulling, which can lead to differences in observed forces and timescales.
  • Model System: The study used a short, model peptide (AAPA). Future work could explore larger, more complex protein systems to see how these findings translate to real-world protein folding.
  • Transition State Energy: The limited sampling of transitions did not allow for a definitive relationship to be established between transition state energy and force.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that these findings provide insight into how prolyl-peptide bonds can act as "force-modulated mechanical timers or switches" in protein refolding, with potential functional importance in proteins like von Willebrand factor (VWF). Further investigation into the role of these force-induced isomerization events in larger biological contexts is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The cis peptide bond is a characteristic feature of turns in protein structures and can play the role of a hinge in protein folding. Such cis conformations are most commonly found at peptide bonds immediately preceding proline residues, as the cis and trans states for such bonds are close in energy. However, isomerization over the high rotational barrier is slow. In this study, we investigate how mechanical force accelerates the cis to trans isomerization of the prolyl-peptide bond in a stretched backbone. We employ hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical force-clamp molecular dynamics simulations in order to describe the electronic effects involved. Under tension, the bond order of the prolyl-peptide bond decreases from a partially double toward a single bond, involving a reduction in the electronic conjugation around the peptide bond. The conformational change from cis to extended trans takes place within a few femtoseconds through a nonplanar state of the nitrogen of the peptide moiety in the transition state region, whereupon the partial double-bond character and planarity of the peptide bond in the final trans state is restored. Our findings give insight into how prolyl-peptide bonds might act as force-modulated mechanical timers or switches in the refolding of proteins.
BibTeX
@article{chen2012cis,
  author = {Jian Chen and Scott Edwards and Frauke Gräter and Carsten Baldauf},
  title = {{On the Cis to Trans Isomerization of Prolyl–Peptide Bonds under Tension}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry B},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1021/jp3042846},
}
Figure