ON THE CHANGING OF FRONT SPANS AND EAVE'S SPACES IN MIAO TRIBE'S RURAL HOUSES OF FENGHUANG XIAN IN CHINA : Study on the space construction of minorities' rural houses of Hunan in China Part 3

Jian Tang, Katamu Agenyra, Mitsuyoshi TsuchidaJournal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ) 2003 · DOI

Abstract

This study explores the structural and social evolution of the "transition zone" in Miao tribe houses in Fenghuang County, Hunan Province. By analyzing the relationship between the Tunkou (a recessed entrance porch) and roof eaves, researchers demonstrate how changes in religious rituals and the adoption of second-story floors drove a shift from deep, low porches to shallow, high ones. This architectural evolution was made possible by the engineering innovation of curved cantilevered beams (Tiaofang), which provided the necessary structural strength to extend the roofline as the porch depth decreased.

Introduction

Traditional architecture in Hunan's minority regions is a dynamic response to social functions and technical capabilities. The "front span" of a Miao house—the semi-outdoor space mediating between the public exterior and private interior—has undergone significant transformation. In older styles, this space was defined by a deep Tunkou and complex internal "opening paths." Modern constructions show a trend toward shallower porches and deeper eaves, a shift that balances interior space requirements with the need for environmental protection.

Spatial Evolution of the Tunkou

The primary driver for spatial change was the evolution of social and religious needs. In older houses (Type 1), religious rituals required complex internal corridors known as "opening paths." As these rituals transitioned to a centralized "hall" (Doya) and families began incorporating second floors for storage and guest space, the internal layout was simplified.

Comparison of floor plans between an old-style house (left, 200 years ago) and a new-style house (right, 1987), showing the simplification of internal paths and the shallowing of the Tunkou porch.

This social shift physically "pushed" the interior walls forward. In Type 1 houses, Tunkou depth often exceeded 1800mm, whereas in newer Type 2 houses, this depth frequently dropped below 1200mm. This reduction in porch depth necessitated a compensatory increase in eave extension to protect the wooden facade from the region's heavy rainfall.

Structural Innovation: The Curved Beam

The transition from deep porches to deep eaves required a "technical guarantee." While straight beams are standard in Han architecture, the Miao utilized the natural curvature of mountain timber grown on slopes. By processing these into curved cantilevered beams (Tiaofang), they increased the beam's cross-sectional depth at critical stress points by 25% to 90%.

3D structural diagrams illustrating the transition from deep recessed porches (left) to shallower porches with extended eaves (right) supported by cantilevered beams.

These curved beams allowed for deeper eave extensions that straight beams could not structurally support. The increased vertical depth at the pillar junction provides superior resistance to the rotational moments (torque) created by the extended roofline. Furthermore, the higher eaves in newer houses created a gap above the first-floor ceiling, facilitating the installation of windows for the newly formed second floors.

Conclusion

The architectural evolution of Miao houses in Fenghuang County represents a sophisticated trade-off between social utility and engineering. The shift toward shallower Tunkou porches and deeper eaves reflects a move toward centralized interior living and ritual spaces, enabled by the regional innovation of curved cantilevered beams. This "wild beauty" (野趣) of the curved timber serves as both a technical solution to load-bearing and a distinct aesthetic marker of Miao regional architecture.

Summary updated

Abstract

There are front spans and eave's spaces between the outside and the interior space in Miao Tribe's rural houses of FENGHUANG XIAN. The front spans and eave's spaces are constructed from "TUNKOU", eave's spaces, and opening paths which only existed in old style rural houses. Even though these spaces aren't the spaces mainly used, they play an important part in function. Furthermore the spaces become a joint between the exterior and the interior spaces, which are valuable spaces of spatial construction. With the changing process of religious service places, the formation of the second floor, and the development of construction methods, the opening paths, which just existed in old style rural houses, were no longer arranged, "TUNKOU" changed from low and deep ones to high and shallow ones and the eaves became deeper in the new style rural houses. It is especially conceivable that "TUNKOU" and the eaves were changed relatively. On the one hand, with the changing process of the religious service place and the formation of the second floor, "TUNKOU" became shallow; on the other hand, the development of construction from beams extending straight out to beams extending out on a curved line was the technical guarantee, which made it possible for the eaves to become deeper.
BibTeX
@article{tang2003changing,
  author = {Jian Tang and Katamu AGENYRA and Mitsuyoshi TSUCHIDA},
  title = {{ON THE CHANGING OF FRONT SPANS AND EAVE'S SPACES IN MIAO TRIBE'S RURAL HOUSES OF FENGHUANG XIAN IN CHINA : Study on the space construction of minorities' rural houses of Hunan in China Part 3}},
  journal = {Journal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ)},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.3130/aija.68.161\_2},
}
Figure