On-surface isostructural transformation from a hydrogen-bonded network to a coordination network for tuning the pore size and guest recognition

Dong‐Dong Zhou, Jun Wang, Pin Chen, Yangyong He, Jun‐Xi Wu, Sen Gao, Zhihao Zhong, Yunfei Du, Dingyong Zhong, Jie‐Peng ZhangChemical 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated a novel on-surface transformation of hydrogen-bonded molecular networks into coordination networks on a silver surface. This transformation allows for precise tuning of pore sizes, leading to distinct host-guest recognition behaviors for molecules like fullerenes and ferrocenes, opening new avenues for designing functional 2D materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing and controlling the structure and function of supramolecular assemblies on surfaces is a significant challenge. While hydrogen-bonded networks are well-established, their transformation into coordination networks, which can offer different properties, is often difficult to achieve and predict. Specifically, researchers aim to create surface-supported porous materials with tunable pore sizes for selective guest molecule capture and recognition. Existing methods for creating such materials often result in significant structural changes, making it hard to control the final outcome. This paper addresses the need for a controllable, on-surface transformation that maintains structural integrity while altering pore dimensions and, consequently, host-guest interactions.

Methods

The study utilizes Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) as the primary experimental technique to visualize and characterize the molecular structures formed on metal surfaces. The researchers deposited benzotrisimidazole (H₃btim) molecules onto Au(111) and Ag(111) surfaces under ultrahigh vacuum conditions. They then employed controlled heating (annealing) to induce transformations. Molecular Mechanics (MM) simulations were used to model the structure of the resulting coordination network. Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were performed to understand the adsorption enthalpies of guest molecules (C₆₀ and ferrocene) within the pores of both the hydrogen-bonded and coordination networks, providing insights into the host-guest recognition mechanisms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on in situ surface science experiments and computational modeling rather than training on large datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Isostructural Transformation: The most striking finding is the ability to transform a hydrogen-bonded network into an isostructural coordination network on the same surface. This means the overall honeycomb arrangement is preserved, but the bonding within the network changes.
  • Metal-Induced Transformation: The transformation on the Ag(111) surface is driven by an unconventional "metal-acid replacement reaction," where silver atoms replace the acidic protons in the H₃btim molecules, forming N-Ag-N coordination bonds. This is a key difference from transformations on Au(111), where the H₃btim network simply evaporates.
  • Pore Size Tuning: The transformation from N-H⋯N hydrogen bonds to N-Ag-N coordination bonds significantly expands the pore diameter of the honeycomb network, from 3.8 Å to 6.9 Å. This precise pore size tuning is crucial for selective guest recognition.
  • Size-Selective Host-Guest Recognition: The expanded pores in the [Ag₃(btim)] coordination network exhibit dramatically different host-guest behaviors compared to the original hydrogen-bonded network. Larger molecules like C₆₀ are better accommodated in the larger pores, while smaller molecules like ferrocene also show preferential binding in the coordination network due to favorable adsorption enthalpies.
  • Irreversible Process: The transformation from the coordination network back to the hydrogen-bonded network was not observed, suggesting an irreversible process driven by hydrogen evolution.

Key Results

  • H₃btim molecules form honeycomb-like hydrogen-bonded networks on both Au(111) and Ag(111) surfaces.
  • On Au(111), the H₃btim network evaporates above 453 K.
  • On Ag(111), at 423 K, the H₃btim network transforms into an isostructural [Ag₃(btim)] coordination network.
  • The pore diameter of the honeycomb network expands from 3.8 Å (hydrogen-bonded) to 6.9 Å ([Ag₃(btim)] coordination).
  • STM imaging and DFT calculations reveal that the [Ag₃(btim)] network selectively accommodates C₆₀ and ferrocene molecules based on their size and binding energies, demonstrating tunable host-guest recognition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Irreversibility: The transformation is irreversible, meaning that once the coordination network is formed, it cannot be easily converted back to the hydrogen-bonded state. This limits the ability to dynamically switch between states.
  • Substrate Dependence: The observed transformation is specific to the Ag(111) surface. Further research could explore if similar transformations can be induced on other metal substrates.
  • Scalability: While the [Ag₃(btim)] networks can grow up to 200 nm, the paper suggests that external metal sources and continuous H₃btim deposition could benefit the growth of larger networks. Future work could focus on scaling up the synthesis of these materials for practical applications.
  • Broader Guest Molecules: The study focused on C₆₀ and ferrocene. Future work could investigate the recognition of a wider range of guest molecules to fully explore the potential of these tunable porous networks.
  • Application Potential: The authors suggest that these results can provide a new clue for the preparation and property modulation of new 2D materials with potential for energy conversion and storage. Future research could explore these specific applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rational manipulation of supramolecular structures on surfaces is of great importance and challenging. We show that imidazole-based hydrogen-bonded networks on a metal surface can transform into an isostructural coordination network for facile tuning of the pore size and guest recognition behaviours. Deposition of triangular-shaped benzotrisimidazole (H<sub>3</sub>btim) molecules on Au(111)/Ag(111) surfaces gives honeycomb networks linked by double N-H⋯N hydrogen bonds. While the H<sub>3</sub>btim hydrogen-bonded networks on Au(111) evaporate above 453 K, those on Ag(111) transform into isostructural [Ag<sub>3</sub>(btim)] coordination networks based on double N-Ag-N bonds at 423 K, by virtue of the unconventional metal-acid replacement reaction (Ag reduces H<sup>+</sup>). The transformation expands the pore diameter of the honeycomb networks from 3.8 Å to 6.9 Å, giving remarkably different host-guest recognition behaviours for fullerene and ferrocene molecules based on the size compatibility mechanism.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2020surface,
  author = {Dong‐Dong Zhou and Jun Wang and Pin Chen and Yangyong He and Jun‐Xi Wu and Sen Gao and Zhihao Zhong and Yunfei Du and Dingyong Zhong and Jie‐Peng Zhang},
  title = {{On-surface isostructural transformation from a hydrogen-bonded network to a coordination network for tuning the pore size and guest recognition}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1039/d0sc05147k},
}
Figure