On Production and Green Transportation Coordination in a Sustainable Global Supply Chain

Feng Guo, Qi Liu, Dunhu Liu, Zhaoxia GuoSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the complex challenge of coordinating production and green transportation in global supply chains to enhance sustainability. By developing a hybrid genetic algorithm, they demonstrate that integrating these operations significantly reduces total supply chain costs and carbon emissions, offering a practical approach for businesses aiming for greener operations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's globalized economy, supply chains face increasing pressure to be both efficient and environmentally responsible. A key challenge is the coordination between production scheduling and the transportation of finished goods. Traditional approaches often treat these as separate, sequential processes, leading to suboptimal outcomes. This paper addresses the "Coordination Problem of Production and Green Transportation" (CPGT), which aims to jointly optimize production and transportation decisions. The problem is further complicated by realistic factors such as:

  • Multiple transportation modes: Air, sea, and land transport, each with different costs, speeds, and carbon footprints.
  • Fixed delivery departure times: Third-party logistics providers often have scheduled pickup times.
  • Varying order complexities and batch sizes: Orders aren't uniform, impacting production and shipping.
  • Carbon emissions: A critical factor for sustainability, requiring accurate measurement for different transport modes.

The goal is to minimize the total supply chain cost, which includes holding costs, transportation costs, earliness/tardiness penalties, and carbon emission costs.

Methods

The authors propose a Hybrid Genetic Algorithm-based Optimization (HGAO) approach to solve the CPGT problem. This method combines the strengths of genetic algorithms with heuristic procedures:

  • Hybrid Genetic Algorithm: This core component is used to find the optimal production sequence of orders. It involves:
  • Encoding: Representing a production sequence as an individual.
  • Initialization: Generating an initial population of random production sequences.
  • Genetic Operators: Uniform crossover and inversion mutation are used to create new offspring (sequences) from existing ones, promoting diversity and exploration.
  • Tournament Selection: A method to select the fittest individuals for reproduction.
  • Tabu Search-Based Local Improvement: A local search technique applied to the best individuals to further refine the solution and escape local optima.
  • Heuristic Procedures: Once a production sequence is determined by the genetic algorithm, these procedures are used to:
  • Calculate production beginning and completion dates.
  • Determine optimal departure times for product batches.
  • Select the most suitable transportation mode for each batch, considering delivery dates and costs.
  • Calculate the total supply chain cost, including carbon emission costs.

The paper also details how carbon emissions for sea, land, and air transportation are measured, considering factors like fuel consumption, distance, speed, and vehicle load.

Datasets

The study uses experimental data collected from a global Make-to-Order (MTO) manufacturing enterprise in China. Three distinct experiments were conducted, varying in the number of orders and product batches:

  • Experiment 1: 8 orders, 38 product batches.
  • Experiment 2: 10 orders, 43 product batches.
  • Experiment 3: 11 orders, 40 product batches.

These experiments simulate real-world scenarios and are used to validate the performance of the HGAO approach. The paper provides detailed tables of order data, including quantity, expected delivery date, penalty costs, and complexity. Transportation parameters (time, cost, distance) for different modes and destinations are also provided in a separate table.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coordination is Key for Sustainability: The most significant insight is that coordinating production and green transportation decisions, rather than treating them sequentially, leads to substantial improvements in both cost efficiency and environmental impact.
  • Realistic Constraints Matter: Incorporating factors like fixed departure times and multiple transport modes makes the problem more complex but also more reflective of real-world supply chains.
  • Carbon Cost Integration: Explicitly including carbon emission costs in the optimization objective is crucial for driving greener transportation choices.
  • Hybrid Approach Effectiveness: The combination of a genetic algorithm for global search (finding good production sequences) and tabu search for local refinement proves effective in navigating the complex solution space.
  • Earliness vs. Tardiness Trade-off: The study highlights how the decision to incur earliness penalties (to avoid higher holding costs or meet tight deadlines) versus tardiness penalties is influenced by the relative costs of these penalties and transportation.

Key Results

The HGAO approach was validated against an enumeration method, demonstrating its ability to find optimal or near-optimal solutions with significantly less computation time.

  • Cost Reduction: The coordinated approach (CPGT) reduced total supply chain costs by 9.60% to 21.90% compared to sequential optimization methods (SPTO and SPGTO).
  • Computational Efficiency: The HGAO approach was substantially faster than the enumeration method, with computation times for HGAO being orders of magnitude lower (e.g., seconds vs. tens of minutes/hours).
  • Solution Quality: The HGAO approach achieved the same optimal results as the enumeration method in the tested experiments, indicating high solution quality.
  • Carbon Emission Reduction: While not quantified as a separate percentage, the inclusion of carbon emission costs in the objective function inherently drives the selection of greener transportation options, leading to reduced emissions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty: The current model assumes deterministic parameters. Real-world supply chains face numerous uncertainties (e.g., demand fluctuations, transport delays, production breakdowns). The authors acknowledge this as a major limitation.
  • Single Plant Focus: The study focuses on a single production plant. Future work could extend this to multi-plant scenarios.
  • Green Production: The paper focuses on green transportation. Investigating the integrated optimization of green production processes alongside green transportation would be a valuable extension.
  • Collaboration: Exploring collaboration models between different entities within the supply chain could further enhance sustainability.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper addresses a coordination problem of production and green transportation and the effects of production and transportation coordination on supply chain sustainability in a global supply chain environment with the consideration of important realistic characteristics, including parallel machines, different order processing complexities, fixed delivery departure times, green transportation and multiple transportation modes. We formulate the measurements for carbon emissions of different transportation modes, including air, sea and land transportation. A hybrid genetic algorithm-based optimization approach is developed to handle this problem, in which a hybrid genetic algorithm and heuristic procedures are combined. The effectiveness of the proposed approach is validated by means of various problem instances. We observe that the coordination of production and green transportation has a large effect on the overall supply chain sustainability, which can reduce the total supply chain cost by 9.60% to 21.90%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2017production,
  author = {Feng Guo and Qi Liu and Dunhu Liu and Zhaoxia Guo},
  title = {{On Production and Green Transportation Coordination in a Sustainable Global Supply Chain}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9112071},
}
Figure